disney cruise food vs royal caribbean

Royal Caribbean vs. Disney Cruise Line: Which Is Best for You?

You're looking for the perfect family cruise vacation -- do you choose Royal Caribbean or Disney Cruise Line ? Both cruise lines get high marks for entertaining kids and adults of all ages (including babies and toddlers) with expansive kids clubs, onboard attractions, shows and activities.

While you can't go wrong with either line, there are some differences. Disney is perhaps the more premium experience with smaller ships and slightly more fare inclusions, but its cruises are more expensive and limited to a smaller fleet and itinerary options.

Some Royal Caribbean ships carry thousands of passengers and can feel crowded and overrun with kids during peak travel periods, but with a large roster of ships and cruise destinations, you can find options that are quieter and more adult-oriented. Although you might feel nickeled and dimed onboard, base fares are generally much lower than Disney, and you have much more choice of places to eat and things to do onboard.

For more on Royal Caribbean vs. Disney, read our comparison across categories below to determine which cruise line is best for you.

Disney vs. Royal Caribbean: Fleet Stats

Royal Caribbean and Disney Cruise Line have drastically different fleet sizes. Royal Caribbean has 27 ships and a young fleet -- 20 of which were built after the year 2000, and two more ships will be launched in July 2024 and summer 2025. Disney has five ships: three were built after 2000, and one more ship will be delivered in December 2024.

Royal Caribbean's ships range in size from 1,992 passengers ( Grandeur of the Seas ) to 5,734 passengers ( Wonder of the Seas ), based on double occupancy. Disney's ships are much smaller by comparison, carrying either 1,754 ( Disney Magic and Fantasy ) or 2,500 passengers (Disney Dream, Disney Fantasy, and Disney Wish ). Since both lines carry lots of families, however, the actual number of passengers onboard your cruise can be much higher when the third, fourth, and fifth berths are filled.

Royal Caribbean sails from over 10 North American homeports and offers year-round sailings to the Bahamas , the Caribbean and Mexico . It also sails seasonally to Europe , Bermuda , Alaska , Hawaii and Asia , as well as farther off destinations, like South America and the South Pacific . It even offers a world cruise .

Disney always sails to the Bahamas and the Caribbean from Port Canaveral and Ft. Lauderdale , and seasonally to Alaska from Vancouver . Other itineraries vary by year and may include Mexico, Hawaii, Europe, Canada/New England and the South Pacific. The line makes it easy to combine a vacation at Walt Disney World in Florida with a cruise out of Port Canaveral.

Choose Royal Caribbean if You Want to Be Spoiled for Choice

If you want your pick of a wide selection of ship sizes and onboard offerings, Royal Caribbean is the line for you. It has seven classes of ships, all with varying cabin types, amenities, and styles.

Choose Disney Cruise Line if You Want the Disney Cruise Experience

While there are some nuanced differences among the five Disney cruise ships, the entertainment, dining venues, and accommodations are consistent fleet-wide. Most people decide they want to experience Disney's superb attention to detail and entertainment mastery, choose a destination, and end up booking the ship that goes there -- rather than selecting a ship first.

Disney vs. Royal Caribbean: Cabins

Both cruise lines offer the same basic categories of stateroom: windowless inside cabins, oceanview rooms with a porthole or picture windows, balcony cabins with private verandas, and larger suites. Suite guests benefit from a variety of perks, such as priority boarding and tendering, exclusive lounge access, and concierge or butler service. Disney and Royal Caribbean ships all offer connecting cabins for families or travel groups who want to share space without squeezing into a single stateroom.

On select ships, both cruise lines try to enhance the inside cabin experience with virtual views. On Disney Dream and Disney Fantasy, Disney offers Magical Portholes, which are video screens that look like porthole windows and display real-time views enhanced with animated characters.

Royal Caribbean offers virtual balconies in some inside cabins on select ships; these floor-to-ceiling LED screens mimic the sliding-glass doors of veranda cabins and also stream live views from outside the ship.

Choose Disney for Truly Family-Friendly Accommodations

While most Royal Caribbean ships have a limited number of triple and quad occupancy cabins (except for Icon of the Seas , where 80 percent of staterooms accommodate three or more), all of Disney's cruise ship rooms are family-friendly, sleeping at least three.

Even inside cabins come equipped for families with a split bathroom (one with sink and toilet, the other with tub/shower combo and sink), room-dividing blackout curtains (so little ones can sleep while parents stay awake with the lights on), and extra berths (pulldown bunk beds or sofa beds). There are even Disney character murals above the bunk beds for kids to look at as they drift off to sleep.

Choose Royal Caribbean for the Largest Selection of Suite Types and Perks

While Disney ships have three to seven types of suites (called Concierge Staterooms), a small Royal Caribbean ship could have six, while larger vessels, such as the newest Icon of the Seas, have up to 13 kinds of suite accommodations. These range from Junior Suites with large balcony cabins to bi-level Loft Suites and Ultimate Family Suites with multiple bathrooms, bedrooms, and balconies.

On other ships, Family Connected Junior Suites combine three cabin types to sleep ten, while the Presidential Family Suite can house 14 in four bedrooms.

While Disney does offer expanded amenities to suite guests, Royal Caribbean's Royal Suite Class , a tiered perks program available on Oasis-, Quantum-, and Icon-class ships, adds attractive benefits like a dedicated restaurant, complimentary gratuities, specialty dining, Royal Genie butlers and alcoholic beverage packages for top-end suites.

Especially with Royal Caribbean's larger ships, variety doesn't just come with suites. Six ships in the fleet have solo cabins designed for one traveler (also perfect for the single grandparent traveling with their family), and Oasis-class ships also have rooms that look into Central Park and the Boardwalk (Icon has rooms overlooking Surfside) rather than out to sea.

Voyager-, Freedom-, and Oasis-class also have innovative Promenade-facing cabins that look into the interior dining/shopping thoroughfare. Onboard Icon of the Seas, you'll also find the Ultimate Family Townhouse, a three-story, two-bedroom affair with a slide that leads from the kids' bedroom to the living room, a home theater, three balconies and direct access into the Surfside family neighborhood. You’ll also find cabins with infinite balconies, where the entire window drops down halfway to create an indoor balcony.

Disney vs. Royal Caribbean: Dining

When it comes to dining, Disney and Royal Caribbean take somewhat different approaches. Both offer main dining venues and buffets that are included with the fare, plus extra-fee restaurants, beverage packages, celebrity chef partnerships, room service and kids’ menus. Both have at least one formal night per cruise, but that's where the similarities end.

Choose Disney if You Like a Pre-Set Dining Schedule

Disney features a rotational dining system. Guests are assigned a dining time, tablemates and waiter, and eat with the same people at a different main dining room (there are three) each night, on a pre-set schedule. In addition to the buffet, there's pizza and burgers, while one or two specialty restaurants are upscale, adults-only, and charge a fee.

Choose Royal if You Like Traditional and/or Flexible Dining with More Venues

Royal Caribbean gives passengers a choice of traditional (same time, same table) or flexible (come anytime, sit with whomever you like) dining options in designated dining rooms. Royal Caribbean ships can have quite a large number of alternative dining venues, from casual hot dog stands to upscale fine dining establishments and an array of restaurants serving international cuisine. Not all extra-fee restaurants are fancy, and kids are welcome.

On average, Royal Caribbean ships offer more alternative dining venues than Disney, many of which are family-friendly. If you don't want to be pinned down to eating at the same time each night, you can choose the flexible MyTime Dining option and switch off between the main dining room(s), the buffet, specialty restaurants, and room service as you see fit. Royal is also aware that children may not be able to sit through long drawn-out meals, so it offers MyTime Family dining in the main dining room, where children aged three to 11 will have their meals served within 45 minutes, and the Adventure Ocean youth staff will collect them for evening activities while parents linger over dessert and coffee.

Choose Disney if You Don't Want to Be Nickeled and Dimed on Food -- and Like Whimsical Venues

Family-friendly dining options are always included on Disney ships, and should you opt out of paying for a specialty restaurant, you'll still get to try multiple restaurants and only miss out on an adults-only date night or two. Disney does not charge for soda (unlike all other mainstream cruise lines) or room service (Royal Caribbean charges a fee for all room service orders except continental breakfast).

Disney does a great job at making dinner fun for young cruisers, who might not have the patience for a multi-course meal. The Animator's Palate restaurant features different "shows" on Disney Magic, Wonder, Dream, and Fantasy, such as conversations with Crush the Turtle from "Finding Nemo" and an animated sequence featuring diners' drawings. And onboard Disney Wish, you’ll find a Frozen- and an Avengers-themed dining experience.

Character dining is always included, and themed dinners featuring Princesses and other classic Disney characters add fun for the entire family. Even Palo, the adults-only venue, allows guests to wear jeans, and the upscale Remy, while requiring dressy attire, has an adorable rat motif, inspired by the movie "Ratatouille."

Choose Royal if You Want a Multitude of Cuisines

Disney's specialty restaurants are upscale French and Italian. Royal Caribbean offers Italian, Brazilian, Mexican, Asian, sushi, teppanyaki, and a steakhouse on their ships. Its buffets also include a multitude of international fare. If you're partial to a certain cuisine, choose a ship that offers your favorite.

Disney vs. Royal Caribbean: Entertainment

Disney and Royal Caribbean both know how to wow guests when it comes to entertainment. Shows take place in onboard theaters or venues around the ship, and adults can enjoy plenty of bar and nightclub options. Disney is known for its Pirate Night live-action show on the pool deck, followed by a fireworks display. Royal Caribbean offers full-length Broadway shows on select ships, as well as energetic themed parades for kids to participate in.

Choose Royal Caribbean if You Love Broadway Shows and Want to See Innovative, Cutting-edge Performances

The largest and newest Royal Caribbean ships feature full-length Broadway or London West End musicals on every sailing. Shows include "Hairspray," "We Will Rock You," "Cats," "Mamma Mia!" "Grease," and “The Wizard of Oz,” which debuted on Icon of the Seas. Also in rotation with the big production (and on the smaller ships) are guest acts and song-and-dance shows developed for the cruise line.

One of the more innovative cruise lines out there, Royal Caribbean doesn't stop with the stage when it comes to live-action shows. Its Oasis- and Icon-class ships feature the AquaTheater , a water-based stage that showcases high diving and acrobatics, and its Quantum-class ships offer Two70, a high-tech performance venue that combines music, dance, digital imagery, and computer technology to wow audiences. Voyager-, Freedom-, Oasis-, and Icon-class ships offer ice skating shows in an onboard rink, while select Vision- and Radiance-class ships feature evening aerial shows in the atrium.

Choose Disney if you Love Disney Characters and Songs -- or You Want to Watch First-run Disney Movies

High-quality live performances are a mix of animated classics brought to life (think "Frozen", "Beauty and the Beast", "Aladdin", “The Little Mermaid," and “Fantasia”) and original stories that weave in classic Disney songs and characters. The familiar faces and stories will delight children, and creative costuming and colorful sets will impress adults. Each ship typically runs three different shows per cruise.

All ships are licensed to screen Walt Disney Studios flicks, including popular movies currently showing in land-based theaters. If you happen to be onboard at the same time as a Disney movie is released, you also get to attend the premiere at sea. Ships will also run classic Disney movies in the theater, on the poolside Jumbotron, and the cabin television channels.

Disney vs. Royal Caribbean: Outdoor Fun

You can't have a family-friendly cruise line without having plenty of outdoor fun. All Disney and Royal Caribbean ships have multiple pools (many with poolside movie screens), including adults-only sun deck areas with pools and hot tubs. Select ships have kids' water play areas, including the H2O Zone and Splashaway Bay on Royal and the AquaLab on Disney. Both lines offer sports areas with attractions like basketball courts and mini-golf courses.

Choose Royal Caribbean if You're an Adrenaline Junkie

Royal Caribbean is the king of crazy top-deck attractions, especially on their newer, larger ships of the Oasis-, Quantum-, and Icon-class. All Royal ships have rock climbing walls, 19 of them offer the FlowRider surf simulator.

The Quantum-class ships have skydiving simulators and a London Eye-esque observation capsule, the Oasis-class ships have zip lines and the 10-story drop slide Ultimate Abyss (except on Allure of the Seas ), and the newest Icon of the Seas offers Crown’s Edge, an over-the-water challenge course that tests your balance and coordination.

On the other hand, Disney offers the AquaDuck and AquaDunk “water coasters” on the Fantasy and Dream, with a new longer version called the Aqua Mouse onboard Disney Wish, but that's the extent of adrenaline-inducing activities.

Choose Disney Cruise Line if you Want More Water Play for Little Ones

While Freedom- and Oasis-class ships have small splash areas for the swim diaper set and water play areas for kids, most Royal Caribbean water activities tend to be geared towards older children, teens, and young adults.

Disney goes out of its way to offer all-ages water fun on all five ships. It's got splash zones for toddlers, shallow pools and junior water slides for kids, and regular pools for family fun. Select ships have the AquaLab water play area with water dump buckets, geysers and the aforementioned water rides. Both lines have lifeguards stationed at pools.

Disney vs. Royal Caribbean: Indoor Fun

Expect standard cruise ship entertainment like bingo, wine tastings and trivia . But gamblers, take note: Disney does not have casinos on their ships . Disney's daytime events revolve primarily around character meet-and-greets (photo ops, autograph sessions, etc.). Royal Caribbean's parades (onboard ships with the Royal Promenade ) are always a hit.

Because most of Royal Caribbean's ships are much larger than Disney's, they have the space to house some impressive indoor attractions. Disney is focused more on events and activities in well-designed -- rather than out-of-the-box -- spaces, though the line does have some pretty spectacular Frozen-, Star Wars- and Marvel-themed kids’ club spaces.

For self-guided fun, check out the Midship Detective Agency scavenger hunt onboard Disney Fantasy and Dream, a Muppets-themed mystery with clues hidden in "enchanted art" -- digital artwork that comes to life when you approach. And onboard Disney Wish, the interactive mobile phone-based Disney Uncharted Adventure takes guests throughout the ship on a quest to battle a Disney villain.

Choose Royal Caribbean if You Want an Amusement Park or Mall on Your Ship

Royal Caribbean's biggest ships have some pretty impressive onboard attractions. Fourteen ships have indoor ice rinks, with open hours for skating. Quantum-class ships offer the SeaPlex, an indoor activity complex with bumper cars, roller skating, trapeze classes, games and an arcade, while Icon-, Oasis-, Quantum-, Voyager- and Freedom-class ships feature the Royal Promenade, an indoor mall with restaurants, bars, and shops.

Plenty of shopping opportunities exist onboard Royal Caribbean ships, from sundries and souvenirs to clothing, jewelry, watches and vintage haute couture bags.

Choose Disney for Holiday Fun Onboard

Just like Disneyland and Walt Disney World, Disney ships go all-out when it comes to the holidays. It has the most robust Halloween offerings , running from September through October with a transforming pumpkin tree, onboard decorations and costume parties. "Very Merrytime" holiday cruises take over from November through December, with holiday-costumed characters, snow in the atrium (courtesy of Anna and Elsa from "Frozen"), carolers, holiday crafts, storytellers and a Winter Wonderland ball.

Disney vs. Royal Caribbean: Kids Clubs and Babysitting

These two cruise lines have enormous kids clubs , including nurseries for little ones ages 6 to 36 months (on all Disney and select Royal Caribbean ships), age-appropriate youth activities, and cool hangouts for tweens and teens.

You might find a science lab or animation studio, as well as areas for crafts, games and videos. Play areas for the youngest cruisers will be filled with toys, while tweens and teens will have dance floors, gaming stations and space to socialize. Both lines provide day and evening options for when families need to go their separate ways.

Disney and Royal Caribbean both offer group babysitting in their respective kids’ clubs at night, so parents can enjoy a late meal or time in the bars and clubs. However, after 10 p.m., Royal Caribbean charges an hourly fee per kid, while Disney remains complimentary.

Choose Royal Caribbean if You Like Separate Activities for Different Ages of Kids

Royal Caribbean's Adventure Ocean program divides children into specific age groups: Royal Babies & Tots (ages 6-36 months), Aquanauts (ages 3 to 5), Explorers (ages 6 to 8), Voyagers (ages 9 to 11), tweens (ages 12 to 14) and teens (ages 15 to 17).

They have separate play spaces and programming, and parents cannot lobby for their "advanced" child to participate in programming for older kids. The separation allows kids to get to know the youth staff for their age group and parents to know who is looking after their kids or where they might be at any time.

Brand new on Icon of the Seas is the Surfside neighborhood, a space designed especially for families with children aged six and under to play together. Parents can either participate in activities with their children or relax nearby in a restaurant, bar or sun deck while their children are at play. There’s also a family buffet open for all meals and a bar serving beverages for all ages.

Choose Disney if the Older and Younger Kids in Your Travel Group Want to Stay Together

Disney is unlike any other cruise line in that it offers an array of activities in its Oceaneer Club and Lab for kids ages 3 to 12, without divisions. Games, crafts, and programming target certain age groups, but no one who might be deemed too old or too young is turned away.

The benefit of this is that young siblings, cousins and friends can always be together, regardless of age. The drawback (for some) is that the system gives kids a lot of freedom and can be overwhelming for preschoolers -- or worrisome for parents who don't know exactly where their kid might be in the large play area. (Note that the youngest kids cannot sign themselves into or out of the club to prevent anyone from wandering away.)

…Or if Your Kid Loves Star Wars or the Marvel Universe

Each Disney ship offers at least one themed play area centered on the Star Wars or Marvel franchises. On Disney Dream, kids can climb into the Millennium Falcon and practice their space flying. Disney Wonder and Disney Magic have the Marvel Super Hero Academy, where kids learn to embrace their inner superhero.

Disney Fantasy has both a Star Wars-themed space and the Marvel Super Hero Academy. And onboard Disney Wish, in addition to the Marvel Headquarters, you’ll find Star Wars Cargo Bay, where kids become a part of a fun-filled adventure with Rey and Chewbacca.

Disney vs. Royal Caribbean: Private Island Destination

Both Disney and Royal Caribbean have their own private island in the Bahamas that their ships visit during the cruise. Both islands have docking facilities, which makes getting off and on the ship a cinch, and you’ll find the same amenities being offered by both brands: family, all-ages, and adults-only sections with their own beaches, a complimentary lunch buffet, optional watersports excursions, and water toys and private cabanas for rent.

Choose Royal Caribbean if You Want Thrills and Exclusive Beach Clubs

The Perfect Day at CocoCay carries Royal Caribbean’s shipboard thrills onto the island. The central attraction is Thrill Waterpark, with 14 waterslides (including the tallest slide in North America) and the largest wave pool in the Caribbean.

For panoramic views, take the Up, Up, and Away helium balloon ride that soars 750 feet in the air, or try ziplining. There are several all-ages beach areas to enjoy, but those seeking exclusivity can check into Coco Beach Club, enjoy a private beach, restaurant, and infinity pool, or book an overwater bungalow (children are allowed here).

Newly unveiled is Hideaway Beach , an adults-only section with its own infinity pool, sandy beach, and beachside bungalows with plunge pools. Although lounging on the beach and the use of sun loungers are free on Perfect Day at CocoCay, there’s a charge for the waterpark, zipline, and balloon ride, as well as to access Coco Beach Club and Hideaway Beach.

And due to the number of Royal Caribbean ships that sail in the area year-round, there could be two ships calling at Perfect Day at CocoCay at the same time, meaning you may have to contend with a few more guests than those from your ship.

Choose Disney if You Want a More Traditional Family Beach Day

Disney’s Castaway Cay provides a more laid-back beach experience where families can play together, and childless travelers can enjoy an adult-only section. There is a snorkeling lagoon, a couple of waterslides and splash parks for the little ones; the youth staff will also schedule activities, and teens have their own hideout to lounge and chill. Disney characters also make their rounds on the island, so be on the lookout for Captain Hook or perhaps even Captain Jack Sparrow.

Other than excursions, watersports equipment rentals, and a little souvenir shopping, there aren’t really any extra charges to incur on the island.

Disney vs. Royal Caribbean: Price

Like on any cruise line, Royal Caribbean and Disney Cruise Line fares vary by ship, itinerary and season. In general, Disney cruises command premium pricing because the brand is very well known (and beloved), and the line only has five ships, which means they typically sail full and prices will remain high. Plus, it includes slightly more amenities in its fares, such as soft drinks and late-night group babysitting , and has fewer extra-fee attractions (no casino, limited extra-fee dining, etc.).

Royal Caribbean's newest ships are priced much higher than its older ships because of all the new bells and whistles. But fares can vary greatly across the fleet, so it’s always worth comparing. With more complimentary dining venues than Disney, Royal’s prices offer good value, and although guests will be tempted by a variety of specialty restaurants, the big-name theater performances and cool activities like the surf simulators and bumper cars are free of charge.

Choose Royal Caribbean for a Better Chance of Getting a Deal

While last-minute discounts are only offered on short sailings of four nights or less, Royal Caribbean offers so many itineraries, often with multiple ships in the same destination, that flexible travelers can often find reasonable deals.

Look for limited-time promotions offering discounts, onboard credit, or reduced deposits. On select sailings, Royal Caribbean also offers reduced rates for seniors (55+), military personnel, police and firefighters, and residents of specific states and Canadian provinces.

Choose Disney if You Want the All-Encompassing Disney Experience

Just as Disneyland and Walt Disney World vacations cost more than other resort stays, Disney cruises are also pricier than other big-ship cruises because you are paying for the elevated service and quality amenities that come with the Disney brand.

The line also has tremendously loyal guests who sail frequently, keeping the ships full and therefore not leaving much room for discounts or promotional offers. A three-night cruise on Disney could cost the same as a seven-night cruise on Royal Caribbean. But you can only get the true Disney experience on a Disney ship, and serious Disney fans believe the quality of a Disney cruise warrants (and are willing to pay) the high price tag.

© 1995— 2024 , The Independent Traveler, Inc.

• Credit cards
• View all credit cards
• Banking guide
• Loans guide
• Insurance guide
• Personal finance
• View all personal finance
• Small business
• Small business guide
• View all taxes

You’re our first priority. Every time.

We believe everyone should be able to make financial decisions with confidence. And while our site doesn’t feature every company or financial product available on the market, we’re proud that the guidance we offer, the information we provide and the tools we create are objective, independent, straightforward — and free.

So how do we make money? Our partners compensate us. This may influence which products we review and write about (and where those products appear on the site), but it in no way affects our recommendations or advice, which are grounded in thousands of hours of research. Our partners cannot pay us to guarantee favorable reviews of their products or services. Here is a list of our partners .

Disney Cruise vs. Royal Caribbean: How They Stack Up

Many or all of the products featured here are from our partners who compensate us. This influences which products we write about and where and how the product appears on a page. However, this does not influence our evaluations. Our opinions are our own. Here is a list of our partners and here's how we make money .

Disney Cruise Line and Royal Caribbean are two well-known companies for cruises. Although they both set sail from multiple ports within the United States, that’s about where their similarities end.

Let’s take a look at Disney Cruise versus Royal Caribbean, including the main differences between these two powerhouses.

» Learn more: The best ways to book a cruise

The main difference: Disney Cruise Line vs. Royal Caribbean

The biggest difference when it comes to Disney versus Royal Caribbean is fleet size. Disney Cruise Line has just five ships, while Royal Caribbean boasts 26 ships in its fleet.

Royal Caribbean also has much larger ships; its Wonder of the Seas craft can accommodate 6,988 passengers. In comparison, the Disney Wish — the biggest ship on Disney’s cruise line — can only hold 4,000 passengers.

Royal Caribbean vs. Disney Cruise Line

Because Royal Caribbean is a much larger cruise line, it can sail many more routes than Disney Cruise Line. You can find a Royal Caribbean cruise nearly anywhere in the world, including but not limited to:

North America.

The Panama Canal. 

South America.

Disney does have quite a few routes, despite its much smaller size. You’ll find destinations including:

The Caribbean.

» Learn more: The pros and cons of cruises

Cabin types

Most cruise lines feature fairly similar cabin types, and Royal Caribbean and Disney Cruise Line are no different. You can expect all the standard cabins, such as interior, oceanview, verandah and suites on both cruise lines.

However, Royal Caribbean has done its best to differentiate itself with interior rooms featuring windows to indoor spaces. Some of its ships also include virtual balconies, which operate gigantic digital screens to show outdoor views in every room.

Disney Cruise Line, meanwhile, is a little different in that all its rooms are built to accommodate families. You’ll find group-friendly features such as curtained room dividers. You’ll also be able to enjoy split bathrooms; these include a toilet and sink in one room and a shower and sink in another.

» Learn more: How Norwegian and Royal Caribbean cruise lines differ

Not sure whether to take a Disney Cruise or one on Royal Caribbean? You’ll certainly want to consider the amenities that each cruise line offers. Again, you can expect to enjoy certain standard amenities when cruising on either of these lines. This includes daily activities, dedicated children's areas, live entertainment, pools, spas and fitness centers.

However, you can find much more on these ships. Royal Caribbean’s ships can accommodate many more activities, so you’ll find things such as:

Indoor skydiving 

Multiple water slides.

Rock wall climbing.

Wave pools.

Zip lining. 

Although smaller, Disney Cruise Line’s ships still provide plenty to do. This can include:

Broadway-quality shows.

Character meet and greets.

Movie screenings

Water slides and more. 

The biggest enticement here is that Disney’s ships all offer Disney-branded entertainment, so if you’re a fan of, say, "Frozen," "The Lion King" or Mickey Mouse, you’ll have a blast on a Disney cruise.

» Learn more: Disney cruise review 2023

Cruises generally aren’t all-inclusive so it’s definitely something you’ll want to consider in a comparison of a Royal Caribbean cruise and a Disney cruise. When onboard, your food is included, as is entertainment, access to the pools and many other activities.

However, there are a few differences in inclusions between these two cruise lines.

First, those sailing on a Disney Cruise Line ship will not need to pay extra if they’d like to drink soda, as soft drinks are included on these cruises. This is not the case for Royal Caribbean; if you’d like to have soda, you’ll need to pay or purchase a soda package.

Second, Disney cruises offer complimentary in-room dining. This is available 24/7 and even includes unlimited Mickey ice cream bars sent to your room. While Royal Caribbean also offers 24/7 room service, it charges a fee for delivery.

» Learn more: Are cruises all-inclusive?

Pricing is probably where the Disney-versus-Royal Caribbean breakdown is most noticeable. Disney cruises are significantly more expensive than Royal Caribbean ones.

For example, a three-night cruise from Miami to the Bahamas on Royal Caribbean will cost as little as $770.48 for two people.

On Disney, meanwhile, a three-night cruise departing from Port Canaveral and heading to the Bahamas is a minimum of $1,993. That’s more than twice as much as a Royal Caribbean cruise.

» Learn more: The best travel credit cards right now

Both Royal Caribbean and Disney Cruise Line offer packages for purchase for your cruise. If you’re interested in Wi-Fi , you’ll be able to purchase a package on either cruise line. The cost is going to vary based on the speed you choose and how long you’re sailing.

Royal Caribbean also offers the ability to purchase a drink package that includes alcohol. This means you’ll be able to have as many alcoholic drinks as you’d like, including wine, beer and liquor.

While Disney does allow you to buy a reusable beer mug that grants you discounted refills, there’s no beverage package available for guests. This is true for both alcohol and specialty drinks such as smoothies; these are charged on a per-item basis.

» Learn more: How much does a Disney cruise cost?

If you’re debating Royal Caribbean vs. Disney Cruise Line

While it's true that both Disney and Royal Caribbean offer cruises, they’re fairly different overall.

Royal Caribbean has larger ships, more amenities, and more cruises available.

Disney Cruise Line, meanwhile, has a much smaller fleet that carries fewer passengers. But you’ll still find a wide variety of sailings across the globe.

You can expect to pay more for a Disney Cruise than Royal Caribbean, but you’ll also be able to enjoy free unlimited sodas and room service.

(Top photo courtesy of Royal Caribbean)

How to maximize your rewards

You want a travel credit card that prioritizes what’s important to you. Here are our picks for the best travel credit cards of 2024 , including those best for:

Flexibility, point transfers and a large bonus: Chase Sapphire Preferred® Card

No annual fee: Bank of America® Travel Rewards credit card

Flat-rate travel rewards: Capital One Venture Rewards Credit Card

Bonus travel rewards and high-end perks: Chase Sapphire Reserve®

Luxury perks: The Platinum Card® from American Express

Business travelers: Ink Business Preferred® Credit Card

on Chase's website

1x-5x 5x on travel purchased through Chase Travel℠, 3x on dining, select streaming services and online groceries, 2x on all other travel purchases, 1x on all other purchases.

60,000 Earn 60,000 bonus points after you spend $4,000 on purchases in the first 3 months from account opening. That's $750 when you redeem through Chase Travel℠.

on Bank of America's website

1.5x-2x Earn unlimited 2 points for every $1 spent on travel and dining purchases and unlimited 1.5 points for every $1 spent on all other purchases.

60,000 Receive 60,000 online bonus points - a $600 value - after you make at least $4,000 in purchases in the first 90 days of account opening.

Disney Cruise vs Royal Caribbean (Who’s the Winner?)

Are you looking for a comparison between Disney Cruise Line and Royal Caribbean? Many families are loyal to a specific cruise brand and may feel leery about trying a different cruise line. This is especially true for those who are avid cruisers with Disney or Royal Caribbean.

If you are wondering how two of the most popular cruise lines measure up against each other, this post is for you! In the article below, we take a deep dive into the similarities and differences between cruising with Disney and Royal Caribbean. We’ll compare pools, entertainment, food, service, staterooms, and more!

Whether you’re a first time cruiser torn between which cruise brand to choose or you’re debating making the leap to new territory, you’ll find everything you need to know. So, for a full account of who wins in a Disney Cruise vs Royal Caribbean showdown, continue reading below for our candid thoughts and honest opinions on these two popular cruise lines!

Let’s begin our comparison by discussing the similarities and differences between Royal Caribbean and Disney Cruise Line ships. Royal Caribbean International features over 20 cruise ships in its fleet. This is a lot larger than the Disney Cruise Line fleet, which has (at the time of this writing) 5 ships.

When planning your family cruise vacation, it may be difficult deciding which ship to choose. Even though the Disney Cruise Line ships offer varying levels of activities and entertainment, you can confidently assume that all of the ships are kid-friendly.

Because of this, it’s fairly easy to choose the best Disney ship for your family since there are only 5 to choose from. Once you narrow down your search by travel dates, itineraries, and prices, you’ll probably find just a few options available.

On the other hand, Royal Caribbean offers multiple ship classes that feature different levels of family friendly activities and entertainment. Most cruisers would argue that the Oasis class ships and the new Icon class are the most kid-friendly vessels. However, many of the smaller ships have incorporated water slides and kid-friendly activities as well.

Who wins? Since Royal Caribbean offers a much larger variety of ships to choose from, we will give them the win for best ship options!

Cruise Planning

The cruise planning process for a Disney Cruise is quite different than that of Royal Caribbean. Depending on what type of planner you are, you may appreciate one more than the other.

Disney Cruise Line

The cruise booking process for a Disney Cruise is super simple. When booking your cruise, you basically choose a stateroom and pick your (early or late) dining time. Depending on your Castaway Club status, you can then add on excursions (aka port adventures) and reservations for a few onboard activities. First time cruisers with DCL can do this at 75 days before your cruise.

Additionally, you will want to research your particular ship’s entertainment options and dining venues. The Disney ships don’t offer a ton of restaurants, so this process is fairly simple. After all of those tasks are completed, you can mostly relax until your cruise. For a complete guide to planning a Disney Cruise vacation , you can check out this post. In that article, we provide a timeline with tasks to complete to get organized for your trip!

Royal Caribbean

The Royal Caribbean booking process is similar to Disney’s in that you choose your cruise cabin and dining time. However, on Royal Caribbean, you will choose between early, late, and My Time Dining. After you book your cruise, you’ll want to access the Online Cruise Planner. This is where you can purchase extras like internet packages , The Key, dining packages, and drink packages to name a few.

You’ll want to go through each of the extra items in the Online Cruise Planner to determine if it’s cost effective for you or if it’s something you would like. As you get closer to your sail date, you will have the opportunity to book specialty dining reservations, show reservations , spa appointments, etc. So, you’ll want to spend some time researching all of the available restaurants on the ship in which you are sailing.

You will notice that a lot of the dining options are complimentary, but many of them are considered specialty restaurants. Furthermore, some of the Royal Caribbean restaurants are only complimentary during certain meals (like breakfast) but not at all meals. If you’re a planner, this is a pretty tedious process as each restaurant features different menus, hours of operation, styles (buffet, sit down, counter service), dress codes, etc.

Winner: Disney Cruise or Royal Caribbean

We are going to give the edge to Disney Cruise Line in the cruise planning department. A Disney cruise vacation is a super simple vacation to plan, but planning a Royal Caribbean cruise can sometimes feel similar to planning a visit to Walt Disney World. That being said, the reason Royal Caribbean is more stressful to plan is because it offers so many extras (packages, restaurants, activities) that it’s hard to consider this a con.

The actual boarding process is fairly similar with both cruise lines. After arriving at the port during the port arrival time you chose during online check-in, you will go through security before arriving at the check in desk. My family and I have never had an issue with either cruise line and have always boarded the ship in a timely fashion.

One main difference between the boarding process for DCL and RCCL is that Disney Cruise Line announces your family as you walk onboard. Before you step into the ship’s atrium, a cast member will ask you for your family name. He/she will then welcome your family onboard over a microphone while surrounding cast members clap and cheer your arrival.

This is actually a really special moment right before you step foot into the beautiful atrium of the ship. Royal Caribbean does not announce your arrival like this, but you will find crew members at the entrance greeting and waving. You then enter the ship in the Royal Promenade, which is sort of like a beautiful mall.

Who wins? Our winner for best boarding experience goes to Disney Cruise Line for the magical touch they add to the embarkation process.

Muster Drill

The dreaded Muster Drill is the safety lesson that every cruiser must participate in before the ship is cleared to sail. Each stateroom has a specified muster station (near the lifeboats) where cruisers must report in the event of a severe emergency. Disney Cruise Line requires all passengers to meet at their muster stations at a specific time on embarkation day . Cast members at each station relay all the important safety information that you need to know for the cruise.

This is obviously not the most exciting time, especially if it’s incredibly hot outside or if you have young kids. Luckily, it usually takes less than 30 minutes. Royal Caribbean adopted a new way to complete these safety drills during the pandemic.

On the morning of your cruise, you can watch the safety video in the Royal Caribbean app. You then click the prompt in the app to confirm you watched the video. Once you board the ship, you walk over to your assigned station, and a crew member will scan the app to show that you participated. And that’s it!

Who wins? Royal Caribbean hands down wins the muster drill experience.

Both Royal Caribbean and Disney Cruise Line offer different types and levels of staterooms on their ships. That being said, Royal features a lot more options than Disney. Disney basically provides options for interior staterooms, ocean view staterooms with windows, oceanview staterooms with balconies, and suites. Royal Caribbean features many stateroom options for guests. If you’re sailing on an Oasis class ship, you can choose from:

• interior rooms
• cabins with windows
• staterooms with balconies overlooking the ocean
• rooms with balconies overlooking one of the neighborhoods

Furthermore, Royal Caribbean offers elaborate suites that include multiple bedrooms and bathrooms, wrap around balconies, outdoor hot tubs, and more.

Who wins? While my family and I like the split bathroom that Disney provides, we are going to award Royal Caribbean with the best staterooms since they offer so many more options.

Suite Perks

Before we begin discussing suite perks, it’s important to note that for the remainder of this post, we will mostly be comparing the Royal Caribbean Oasis class ships to the Disney Cruise Line fleet. The larger ships that are part of the Oasis class and Icon class offer some of the more popular features for families.

Disney’s Concierge Level and Royal’s Suite Class include high-quality rooms and amenities for guests. If you sail in a concierge suite with Disney, you may receive perks like priority boarding and tendering, access to a suite lounge with food and beverages, access to an exclusive sun deck, and priority reservations onboard the ship.

For a full review of all the perks included, you can check out our post on Disney Cruise Line Concierge Level Benefits . In that post, we discuss the extras you receive from cruising in the Concierge level. We also provide our honest opinion on whether or not it’s worth the price!

Royal Caribbean provides different levels to its suite program, including the Sea Class level, Sky Class level, and Star Class level. Depending on the level your room includes, you will have access to different perks.

One major difference in the suite perks between the two lines is the access to an exclusive suite restaurant. Royal Caribbean suite guests can dine in Coastal Kitchen, which is a beautiful suite restaurant that offers special menus and exemplary service.

Furthermore, if you opt to book one of the top level suites, aka the Star Class, you get access to a Royal Genie. This opens the door to even more perks. Guests can use the Royal Genie to bypass lines at the waterslides, gain priority seats in entertainment venues, and eat meals in their cabin among other things.

Winner: Royal Caribbean or Disney Cruise Line

Royal Caribbean wins the award for best suite perks. The newest Icon class ships seal the deal even more by providing an entire exclusive neighborhood for suite guests!

The dining options onboard the Royal Caribbean ships and the Disney ships are quite different. In addition to the main dining rooms, which we will discuss in more detail below, Disney Cruise line offers a few dining venues that are included in your cruise fare. These dining options include the buffet, room service, and quick service restaurants near the pools. In addition, DCL offers a few specialty restaurants for an additional charge. Although the most popular of these are the adults only dining venues.

Royal Caribbean Cruise Line features numerous restaurants in addition to its main dining rooms. Guests can enjoy the buffet, El Loco Fresh, quick service stops for pizza or hot dogs, and cafes. Additionally, Royal Caribbean offers multiple family-friendly specialty restaurants with options for Italian food, BBQ, pub fare, steaks, and even four course meals.

Who wins? Although it can feel stressful differentiating between all the available options onboard the Royal Caribbean ships, we will award Royal with best dining options over Disney Cruise Line.

Main Dining Rooms

The differences in the main dining room experiences onboard Disney Cruise ships and Royal Caribbean ships are quite vast.

Dinners in the main dining rooms are some of my family’s favorite experiences on the Disney ships. Disney Cruise Line features three main dining rooms on each of its ships. These dining rooms are themed, and some of them even include live shows based on popular films like Frozen , Tangled , and The Princess and The Frog . Each evening, you rotate to a different dining room so that you can experience the uniqueness of each one.

After being seated in the dining room, kids are given crayons and a separate menu that serves as a coloring page. The assistant server greets you and takes your drink order before the main server arrives to take your food order. If you are torn between two items, the server will usually bring both of them to you.

Although subjective, my family and I find the food delicious and are usually stuffed by the end of the meal. As you dine, your kids are entertained with coloring, dinner shows (when available), and magic tricks/balloon animals from the servers.

The main dining room experience on the Royal Caribbean ships is much different. You dine in the same room each night, so families don’t rotate like on Disney. In addition, the dining rooms are not themed; however, they are really beautiful. While kids have a separate menu, they are not given coloring pages or crayons to keep them busy.

Nor did we experience magic tricks or special attention from the servers. Although, the servers are incredibly kind and helpful. My family and I found the food quality in the Royal Caribbean dining rooms to be really good. However, the portions were extremely small, and we all left feeling hungry.

Winner: Disney Cruise vs Royal Caribbean

The winner for best main dining room experience easily goes to Disney Cruise Line for its theming, service, and portions.

This section is going to compare the pool decks on the Disney Cruise ships and the Royal Caribbean ships. Since there’s a lot to break down here, I’ll separate each topic below. 

Before we start discussing the differences between the pool decks on Royal Caribbean vs Disney Cruise Line, I want to mention a major difference between the two brands: pool towels.

Royal Caribbean requires you to show your SeaPass card at the towel desk on the pool deck in order to take a towel. A crew member will mark down the number of pool towels you take, and you will be charged if you do not return them. This towel check-out process was always super simple.

However, returning the towels was a different story. My family and I would pile our four towels on a chair with our coverups, flip flops, phones, etc. as we swam. (Note that we used one chair for this and always chose a chair that was in the back row.)

After swimming, we would go back to the pile of towels to discover that one of them was missing. This happened to us numerous times on our Oasis of the Seas cruise. Luckily, we noticed that the crew member at the towel desk didn’t count the towels when we returned them. So, we were able to just show our SeaPass card and throw the towels in the laundry bin. 

But, until we learned this, my family and I were completely stressed out about missing one towel each day. We also had to check our onboard account at the end of the cruise to make sure we hadn’t been wrongly charged for towels as I heard this was common occurrence. To read about some of the other important things we learned as first time cruisers with Royal, check out our post on Royal Caribbean Tips and Tricks .

Disney Cruise Line has a super simple pool towel process. Towels are readily available at stations for you to grab and go whenever you like. You then return the towels to the Used Towels station when you are finished. This means you don’t have to stand in line to check out towels or to return them. Additionally, you can take your towels back to your stateroom after swimming, and the room host will dispose of them with your bathroom towels.

Disney Cruise Line easily wins the pool towel competition. I did not anticipate the headache that the pool towels would become on Royal Caribbean.

Swimming is one of the most popular activities for kids to enjoy on cruise ships. While Disney Cruise Line and Royal Caribbean both feature multiple pools on each ship, there are quite a few differences in the pool decks. Disney Cruise ships offer notoriously small pools; although, they are themed well (like the Mickey Pool). My family and I like to swim right after boarding on embarkation day and right after the pools open on sea days. This helps to bypass at least some of the crowds.

Royal Caribbean Oasis class ships also provide several swimming pools for families to enjoy. These pools are larger and hold a lot more people. Plus, the Sports Pool on Oasis of the Seas is heated and always felt warm, even in December. Disney and Royal will heat other pools if the temperature drops below a certain point. However, we enjoyed having a fully heated pool even in the 80-degree weather since it was often windy and cool when you stepped out of the water.

Who wins? Royal Caribbean easily wins the award for best pools compared to Disney Cruise Line.

Water Play Areas for Babies

Cruise lines across the board do not allow non-potty-trained kids in their pools. Luckily Disney and Royal both provide splash pad areas for these kids to play. Although, it’s important to check your specific ship as some of these splash zones differ drastically.

The Disney ships offer small splash pads like Nemo’s Reef and Nephews’ Splash Zone that feature fun geysers, Disney characters spraying water, and (sometimes) tiny slides. 

Some of the Royal Caribbean ships provide either the H2O Zone or a baby section of Splashaway Bay. 

Who wins? While we like the theming of the splash zones on the Disney ships, the Royal Caribbean baby play areas are just as sufficient for babies and toddlers. Therefore, we will call this race a tie for both cruise brands.

Water Slides

The Disney Cruise Line ships feature water slides; although, they can be different depending on which ship you book. Some of the Royal Caribbean ships also offer water slides, but many do not. So, make sure you check out the options before you book if water slides are important to you.

Additionally, some of the Royal Caribbean ships feature a Splashaway Bay water play area for kids who may not quite meet the height requirement for the larger water slides. This splash zone is a huge hit for kids and is much more fun than Disney’s Aqua Lab splash area.

Who wins? Royal Caribbean wins for best water slides since they feature a lot more of them.

Pool Deck Food and Drinks

The Disney Cruise ships offer counter service dining options right by the pools. You’ll also find lots of tables and chairs where you can eat a quick lunch or snack. Royal Caribbean did not offer this on Oasis of the Seas. If you wanted to grab food, you had to walk to a completely different deck. My family and I really missed the ease of getting food while wearing our swimsuits and eating by the pool. Instead, we had to put on our coverups and shoes, pack up our things, and brave the buffet or another dining venue.

Additionally, the Disney ships provide easy access to free drink stations on the pool deck. And guests who want a cocktail or drink that’s an extra cost can easily order from one of the many servers walking around by the pool. We tried to order drinks by the pool multiple times on Oasis of the Seas and were told that we needed to go to the bar. I’m not sure if this is standard or if they were low on workers, but we also missed the ease of ordering alcoholic drinks and beverages while still watching the kids swim.

Who wins? The winner of available food and drinks on the pool deck is Disney Cruise Line.

Pool Atmosphere

While the pool decks on Disney Cruise Line and Royal Caribbean are both typically full of families, there are a few differences. The Disney ships feature a large TV screen that plays popular Disney shows and movies while you swim. I didn’t realize how much we would miss this until sailing with Royal, but the large screen is just another one of those magic touches that Disney provides.

Another important difference in the atmosphere on the pool deck is the presence of cigarette smoke. I know that the Disney ships offer designated smoking areas, but I do not know where those are because I have never smelled smoke on a Disney ship.

I anticipated smelling smoke in and around the casino on Royal Caribbean; however, it did not occur to me that we would also smell it outside by the pool. One of the smoking sections is located near the heated pool that my kids loved to play in. Unfortunately, we frequently smelled cigarette smoke outside by this pool.

Who wins? Disney Cruise Line is the winner for the best pool deck atmosphere.

My family and I love attending the family friendly shows onboard the Disney Cruise ships. We enjoy eating dinner and then heading to a show each evening of the trip. The Disney Broadway style shows are all incredibly entertaining for both kids and adults. Plus, the comedy and magic shows we have seen on Disney ships have also been great.

We really missed this aspect of cruising while on Royal Caribbean. Although the Oasis class ships offer amazing Aqua shows that you don’t want to miss, we didn’t really love the other options onboard.

Our family attended the ice show but found it very bizarre and even boring. Additionally, the Broadway style shows weren’t really appropriate for our youngest child. We had been excited to attend the comedy show, but the comedian on our sailing performed adult- only shows, even at 7:00 pm. Therefore, we found ourselves with a lack of entertainment options to enjoy in the evenings before bedtime.

Who wins? Because of this, we are choosing Disney Cruise Line as the winner for best shows.

Onboard Activities

Since we already discussed the pools and water slides above, we will talk about other onboard activities in this section. Both of the cruise lines offer some similarities in regard to onboard activities like cooking classes, sports decks, youth clubs, game shows, etc.

When highlighting the differences between the two cruising brands, Disney Cruise Line provides fun entertainment options for families like character meet and greets, fireworks show, Pirate Night, Midship Detective Agency, and Hero Zone .

Royal Caribbean offers their own onboard experiences that include rock climbing walls, ice skating rink, dry slide, Flow Rider, carousel, and zip line.

Who wins? We are going to call the onboard activities race a tie as Disney Cruise Line offers incredible options, especially for families with younger kids. However, if your kids are older and meet the height requirements of the Royal Caribbean activities, you would probably give them the edge.

The price of a Disney Cruise is notoriously higher than that of other cruise lines. It is true that Royal Caribbean cruises are cheaper; however, there are a few important points to make here. My family and I typically travel in a Deluxe Family Oceanview Stateroom with Verandah on Disney Cruise Line.

We find that the equivalent to this on Oasis of the Seas is the more expensive Junior Suite . Therefore, you can’t necessarily compare the price of a balcony room on Disney to one on Royal. The Junior Suites are more expensive than a regular balcony room, but they tend to still be cheaper than a Disney stateroom. For example, our Royal Caribbean 7 night cruise in a Junior Suite cost the same as a Disney 4 night cruise in a Deluxe Family Balcony room.

Additionally, our junior suite provided a few suite perks like priority boarding and access to the exclusive suite restaurant at dinners. I will add that my family and I usually do not purchase additional items on Disney cruises, but we did enjoy a few of the specialty restaurants onboard the Royal Caribbean ship for an additional cost. This by no means made the two prices equal, but it’s something to consider.

Who wins? I’m sure it’s no surprise that the winner of the best prices goes to Royal Caribbean over Disney Cruise Line. Even after the add-ons, our 7 night trip was cheaper than a shorter Disney cruise.

Winner of Best Cruise: Disney Cruise Line or Royal Caribbean

Overall, I would recommend both cruise lines for a family vacation. If you are an experienced Disney cruiser, you may find the service on Royal is not up to par. I suggest booking a Junior Suite (or higher) so that you have access to Coastal Kitchen for meals.

Our main cons with Royal compared to Disney were the lack of service, cigarette smoke, and evening entertainment. Also, the Oasis of the Seas felt incredibly crowded; although, this was to be expected on such a large ship.

If you are a loyal Royal Caribbean cruiser who is debating Disney Cruise Line, you may find Disney to be a bit boring. I suggest going in with a laid back mindset as you will find much less going on throughout the ship. If your kids are younger and enjoy meeting characters like Mickey Mouse, you should be fine.

However, teens and older kids may miss the larger pools, waterslides, rock walls, zip line, etc. So, if you’re wondering who the overall winner is in the Royal Caribbean vs Disney Cruise match up, it’s the family who gets to enjoy a vacation with either of these fabulous cruise lines! You’re sure to have a great time no matter which you choose!

In summary, my family and I have developed an appreciation for both cruise lines and would happily sail with either of them again. I hope you found this post helpful at highlighting the main differences between Disney Cruise Line and Royal Caribbean.

You may have completely different experiences with the two brands, and I hope you feel free to comment below with anything you’d like to add to my review! Will you choose Royal Caribbean or Disney Cruise Line? Comment below to share your vote!

Shari is an experienced planner and organizer for Disney vacations, cruising, and U.S. travel. Her family vacation information, reviews, and tips provide insight for moms and dads everywhere. You can read more about her story, including her journey through breast cancer, in the about me page.

Similar Posts

Guide to Royal Caribbean Ship Classes

Disney Cruise Boarding Groups and Embarkation Day Guide

35 Best Places to Visit in Tennessee (Local’s Guide)

Scoring an Early Boarding Time on Royal Caribbean

Zoos and Animal Attractions near Gatlinburg, Tennessee

The Village of Baytowne Wharf: Restaurants and Entertainment Guide

Leave a reply cancel reply.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.

Frequently Asked Questions

How can I change or modify my reservation?

Disney Cruise vs Royal Caribbean: The Ultimate Comparison

Are you considering Disney Cruise vs Royal Caribbean for your next family vacation? You’re not alone! That’s why we have created this ultimate comparison guide to help you make the right decision for your family! Deciding between these two cruise lines can be like picking your favorite ice cream flavor – both are delightful but in different ways. As seasoned travel professionals who have a love for both theme parks and cruises, we are here to guide you through this exciting journey. Choosing a R oyal Caribbean vs Disney Cruise doesn’t have to be difficult! But from what we found, it’s a lot of back and forth on their respective websites. So, we have put together this guide to help you compare the two cruise lines in one place. 

We hope you find this post helpful! And if you are planning a Disney Cruise Line Vacation, check out our other FREE vacation planning tools. Our goal at The Park Prodigy has always been to help you save time on your next vacation and find the cheapest Disney Cruise Line vacations !

Disney Cruise Line vs. Royal Caribbean

Embarking on a cruise is like stepping into a world of wonder, and when it comes to choosing between Disney Cruise Line vs   Royal Caribbean , the decision becomes an even more intriguing adventure. As a seasoned traveler who has set sail numerous times on an adult only Disney Cruise vacation , I’ve experienced firsthand the enchantment that Disney uniquely provides on their ships. It’s perfect for those seeking a sprinkle of pixie dust and character-filled moments. Disney cruises are a dream come true for families and Disney aficionados alike. But what about Royal Caribbean? With its own set of charms and surprises, it caters to a different, yet equally thrilling, set of preferences. So, let’s dive into the specifics of each, exploring why you might choose one over the other for your next unforgettable vacation.

Choose Royal Caribbean for the Largest Selection of Suite Types and Perks

• Royal Caribbean stands out with its diverse array of suite options. From cozy interior rooms to sprawling Royal Suites, there’s something for every family size and budget. If you’re seeking a touch of luxury on vacation with a more reasonable price tag, Royal Caribbean is the ship for you!

Choose Disney for Truly Family-Friendly Accommodations

• Disney Cruise Line is the epitome of family-oriented cruising. Their staterooms are designed with families in mind, offering ample storage, split bathrooms (a godsend!), and whimsical touches that appeal to both kids and kids at heart. Disney Cruises has also always been my preferred cruise line for its impeccable customer service!

Related Post: Complete Guide to a Disney Cruise for Adults

Disney Cruise Line vs Royal Caribbean – The Basics

Disney Cruise Line: 

• Western, Eastern, & Southern Caribbean
• Northern Europe
• Norwegian Fjords
• Mediterranean
• British Isles
• Mexican Riviera
• Panama Canal
• Pacific Coast
• Transatlantic
• South Pacific
• New Zealand & Australia
• Singapore – Sailing in 2025

Royal Caribbean:

• Greece & Greek Isles
• New England

Important to know :

When it comes to destinations,  Disney Cruise Line   vs   Royal Caribbean both whisk travelers away on journeys filled with wonder and excitement. Each cruise line has a wonderful variety of routes that cater to any traveler’s dream. Each company also has its own private island. Royal Caribbean’s CocoCay offers diverse activities, including hot air balloon rides and a water park! Disney Cruise Line’s island, Castaway Cay , is an idyllic paradise exclusively for Disney cruisers. This serene haven is often cited as a pinnacle experience, offering families a unique blend of Disney magic and tropical bliss. We have to give this one to the Disney Cruise Line for their slightly more expansive destination list. The only downside of DCL’s routes is the missing stops in Greece and Italy in comparison to Royal Caribbean.

Related Post: When is the Cheapest Time to Go on a Disney Cruise?

Cabin Types – R oyal Caribbean vs Disney Cruise

• Standard/Deluxe Inside
• Deluxe/Family Oceanview
• Deluxe/Family Oceanview with Verandah
• Concierge Family Oceanview
• Concierge Family Oceanview with Verandah
• Concierge 1 & 2 Bedroom Suites with Verandah
• Concierge Royal Suite with Verandah
• Concierge 1 & 2 Stroy Royal Suites with Verandah
• Concierge Wish and Treasure Tower Suites
• Interior Studio, Spacious, Virtual Balcony, and promenade View
• Oceanview Studio, Spacious, Ultra Spacious, & Spacious Panoramic
• Oceanview with Large Balcony Ocean View, Spacious Ocean View, & Ultra Spacious
• Oceanview Suite with No Balcony Staterooms
• Junior 1 Bedroom & Large Balcony Suite
• Grand 1 & 2 Bedroom, Large Balcony, Panoramic, & Loft Suite
• Owner’s 1 & 2 Bedroom, Panoramic, & Loft Suite
• Royal 1 Bedroom Suite & 2 Bedroom Loft Suite
• Villa 4 Bedroom Suite
• Boardwalk View, Central Park View, Boardwalk AquaTheater View Neighborhood Staterooms
• 2 Bedroom Crown Loft & Sky Loft Suite
• 1 Bedroom AquaTheater, Spacious AquaTheater, & AquaTheater with Large Balcony Suite
• 2 Deck, 1 Bedroom Star Loft Suite
• 2 Deck, 1 Bedroom Grand Panoramic Suite
• 2 Deck, 2 Bedroom Royal Loft Suite

All cruise lines have 4 major categories of staterooms to choose from, no matter what they’re called. These are Inside, Oceanview, Balcony, and Suites. Royal Caribbean dazzles with its extensive array of cabin types, catering to diverse preferences and budgets; Disney Cruise Line stands out with its family-centric approach to accommodation design. But even though the DCL has families in mind, Royal Caribbean truly has a stateroom for any type of vacation you’re looking to have. So no matter what, when you compare Royal Caribbean vs Disney , you have to give it to the RC ships for their custom vacation thinking. Also, while we have listed out every stateroom available for each cruise line, some rooms are only available on select ships!

Related Post: How Many Ships Does Disney Have?

• Inside: $2,326
• Oceanview: $2,528
• Verandah: $2,824
• Concierge: $6,430
• Interior: $493
• Oceanview: $563
• Balcony: $616
• Suites: $1,421

All pricing above is for a 3-night sailing to the Bahamas on March 7th, 2025, from Port Canaveral, Florida. 

It’s almost impossible to compare the price on a cruise. Countless factors go into how much a cruise costs. Such as destination, duration, cabin type, and how many people are in your party. Our examples above are for similar cruises for each company! But in terms of pricing, this is where the contrast between a Disney Cruise vs Royal Caribbean Cruise Line  will be the most noticeable. As you can see in our pricing example above, Disney is more expensive than Royal Caribbean. But it doesn’t stop there; Disney Cruise Line is more expensive than almost every other cruise line out there! While it doesn’t make the top three most expensive cruises, it most certainly loses in the price factor when comparing these two popular cruise lines.

• Live Shows & Entertainment
• Disney Character Experiences
• Family Friendly Activities
• Fireworks at Sea
• Deck Parties
• Movie Theaters
• Rotational Main Dining
• Adult-Exclusive Dining
• Youth Clubs
• Nightclubs & Lounges
• Family Venues
• Pools & Water Slides
• Spa & Salon Services
• Sports & Fitness Centers
• AquaMouse – A Disney Attraction at Sea –  available only on the Wish & Treasure
• Main Dining

Both Disney Cruise Line   vs   Royal Caribbean excel in delivering a wide array of onboard amenities, each tailored to their unique brand of cruise experience. Royal Caribbean takes a slight lead when it comes to amenities geared towards adults and adventure seekers. With thrilling attractions like rock climbing walls that challenge you to reach new heights and surf simulators that bring the excitement of ocean waves onboard, they cater to those seeking an adrenaline rush and active leisure. Conversely, Disney Cruise Line focuses on family-centric amenities. They excel in creating enchanting environments and activities that captivate the imaginations of both young and old. From character meet-and-greets to themed play areas, Disney ensures that every family member, regardless of age, experiences the wonder of their magical world at sea. This distinct focus makes Disney cruises a haven for families looking to immerse themselves in the enchanting world of Disney.

Related Post: How Much Does a Disney Cruise Cost Per Person?

Inclusions – Disney vs Royal Caribbean

• Your Stateroom

Entertainment

• Variety of Dining Options
• 24-hour Room Service
• Pools & Recreation
• Private Island
• Character Meet & Greets

When weighing Disney Cruise Line or Royal Caribbean , it’s vital to consider the inclusions, as cruises aren’t typically all-inclusive. Both offer essentials like meals, entertainment, and pool access. A standout difference is in beverages; Disney Cruise Line includes free soda, unlike Royal Caribbean, where soda requires an extra fee or a soda package. Additionally, Disney cruises excel with complimentary 24/7 in-room dining, complete with my personal favorite perk: unlimited Mickey Premium ice cream bars! In contrast, Royal Caribbean provides 24/7 room service but charges a delivery fee. These distinctions are crucial in the Royal Caribbean vs Disney Cruise debate, especially for families prioritizing convenience and value.

Related Post: Every Disney Cruise Ship from the Newest to Oldest

Add-on Packages

• Pre-Pay Gratuities
• Ground Transportation
• Refillable Beer Mug
• In-Room Gifts
• Internet Access (unless staying in a Concierge-level stateroom)
• Port-Adventures
• Vacation Protection
• Beer, Wine, Spirit, & Sodas
• Internet Access

In the Disney Cruise Line vs Royal Caribbean comparison, both offer purchasable Wi-Fi packages, with costs varying by speed and cruise length. A key difference is Royal Caribbean’s inclusive alcoholic drink package, allowing guests unlimited access to wine, beer, and spirits. Contrastingly, Disney Cruise Line doesn’t offer a similar beverage package; instead, they have a unique reusable beer mug for discounted refills. For alcohol and specialty drinks like smoothies, Disney Cruise Line charges per item. This distinction is crucial for those considering the Disney vs Royal Caribbean choice, especially if inclusive drink options are a priority.

Related Post: Every Disney Cruise Ship Ranked

Booking Experience

• Through us! Click here for discounted Disney Cruise vacations!
• Online via the Disney Cruise website
• By calling the Disney Cruise Line at (800) 951-3532
• Online via the Royal Caribbean website
• By calling Royal Caribbean at (844) 278-9745

For me, the ease of booking a cruise can really impact my willingness to purchase a vacation. And I have to honestly say that Disney Cruise Line offers a very helpful, streamlined, and informative booking process. Originally, I wasn’t going to put this section into the guide. However, after doing my due-diligent research on the two cruise lines, I found it incredibly difficult to easily find some key information on the Royal Caribbean website. The website has the essential booking links displayed promptly on the home page, but for any detailed information, you have to dig in the search bar. At the same time, the DCL website lays everything out for you right on the home page. Making it a pleasurable and easy booking process. If you’re looking to eliminate the stress of booking your Disney Cruise, let us do it for you !

Related Post: Book Your Discounted Disney Cruise Stateroom!

Royal Caribbean vs Disney Cruise Line – The Fun Stuff

• 4 Main Dining Options
• 2 Sweet Shops
• 3+ All Day Eateries
• 4 Additional Fee Dining Options
• 1 Main Dining Room
• 5+ All Day Eateries
• 1 Sweet Shop
• 11 Additional Fee Dining Options

In the Disney Cruise Line vs Royal Caribbean culinary showdown, both cruise lines emerge as champions in their own unique ways. Disney Cruise Line excels in themed dining experiences that are a feast for the senses and the imagination. Families dining on a Disney cruise are treated to more than just a meal; they enjoy immersive, character-driven experiences , making each dinner a memorable part of the Disney vs Royal Caribbean journey. In contrast, Royal Caribbean impresses with its vast array of dining options. Whether you’re seeking international cuisine, gourmet experiences, or casual bites, Royal Caribbean delivers, making it a strong contender in the Royal Caribbean vs Disney cruise debate for food enthusiasts. This diversity in dining is a hallmark of the Royal Caribbean Disney Cruise comparison, ensuring that every guest’s palate is well catered to on their sea voyage.

Related Post: Complete List of Disney Cruise Line Characters

• Broadway-quality Shows
• Disney Character Greetings

Themed Cruises

• Themed Nights
• Themed Dining
• Escape Rooms
• Ice Skating Shows

Both cruise lines excel but cater to different tastes. Disney Cruise Line dazzles with Broadway-caliber shows and character-filled deck parties, a major draw in the Disney vs Royal Caribbean choice for families. These immersive, Disney-themed performances make every night on a Disney cruise an enchanting experience. On the other side, Royal Caribbean impresses with a diverse range of spectacular shows and live entertainment, from musical extravaganzas to acrobatic feats, appealing to a broader audience. This variety positions Royal Caribbean as a compelling option in the Royal Caribbean vs Disney cruise discussion for those seeking versatile and high-quality onboard entertainment.

Related Post: Your Complete Guide to Disney Christmas Cruises

Private Islands – R oyal Caribbean Cruise vs Disney Cruise

• Castaway Cay – Bahamas
• Lighthouse Point – Bahamas –  opening Summer 2024
• Coco Cay – Bahamas
• Labadee – Hati

The allure of exclusive private islands is a significant highlight when choosing a cruise line. Both cruise lines offer their guests this unique experience but in distinctively different styles. Disney’s Castaway Cay stands out in the Disney vs Royal Caribbean debate for its quintessential Disney magic. This private island delivers an immersive Disney experience, complete with character greetings that delight both young and old. The island’s meticulously themed environments transport guests into a storybook paradise. In contrast, while Royal Caribbean also offers private island experiences, they focus more on relaxation and island activities rather than themes, a factor to consider in the R oyal Caribbean Disney cruise decision. However, the private islands of the Royal Caribbean offer a wider array of activities and beaches to enjoy. This distinction in private island experiences is a key element in choosing between Disney Cruise Line and Royal Caribbean.

Related Post: Check out Disney’s Adult-Only Beach!

Kids’ Clubs

• Oceaneer Club – Ages 3 – 12
• Oceaneer Lab – Ages 3 – 12
• Edge – Ages 11 – 14
• Vibe – Ages 14-17
• “It’s a Small World” Nursery – Ages 6 months – 3 years
• Adventure Youth Program – Ages 3 – 12
• Teens & Tweens Program – Ages 13 – 17
• Babies & Tots Program – Ages 6 months – 3 years

Both cruise lines excel in providing exceptional kids’ clubs. However, Disney Cruise Line takes kids’ entertainment to a magical realm. Their clubs are not just spaces for play but portals into the enchanting world of Disney movies. Here, in these vividly themed and interactive clubs, children engage in activities led by their beloved Disney characters, an experience that stands out in the Disney vs Royal Caribbean debate. This direct interaction with the characters from their favorite stories makes every moment spent in Disney’s kids’ clubs a memorable adventure, a significant draw for families when booking a discount Disney Cruise . It’s this immersion into the Disney universe that gives Disney Cruise Line an edge in the Disney Cruise Line vs Royal Caribbean choice for those seeking a truly Disney-centric experience for their children.

Related Post: How to Book a Disney Cruise at a Discounted Rate

• Pixar Day at Sea
• Marvel Day at Sea
• Halloween on the High Seas
• Very Merrytime Cruises
• High Seas Motorcycle Rally
• Rock Legends Cruise
• Star Trek Cruise
• Ultimate 80’s Party
• The Old School Cruise
• Super Legends Cruise
• Christmas Cruise

In our epic Disney Cruise Line vs Royal Caribbean showdown, themed onboard experiences are a key highlight. Disney Cruise Line specializes in themed cruises, like Halloween on the High Seas , providing an immersive experience with character encounters, special shows, and activities that deeply engage fans, making Disney an ideal choice for those seeking themed adventures at sea. Conversely, Royal Caribbean caters to those who prefer shorter-themed events, offering themed nights, weekends, and parties. This approach suits travelers in the Royal Caribbean vs Disney Cruise debate who enjoy a blend of thematic and varied entertainment, offering a taste of themed fun without committing to a full-themed voyage.

Related Post: All of Disney’s Themed Cruises

Which is Better: Royal Caribbean or Disney Cruise

Choosing between a Disney Cruise Line and a Royal Caribbean cruise depends on what aligns best with your family’s vacation needs. For those enchanted by Disney’s magical and immersive experiences , tailored specifically for families and Disney enthusiasts, Disney Cruise Line is an ideal choice, perfectly fitting the Disney Cruise vs Royal Caribbean narrative. And if your preference leans more towards a variety of experiences suitable for different ages and interests, Royal Caribbean is a great cruise option. It offers an array of activities that cater to both adventure-seekers and those seeking relaxation, making it a strong contender in the Royal Caribbean vs Disney cruise decision. Each line offers unique and memorable experiences, but the right choice for your Disney or Royal Caribbean adventure will depend on your specific vacation desires and expectations.

Is a Disney Cruise Cheaper than Royal Caribbean?

• No, a Disney Cruise is typically more expensive than a Royal Caribbean Cruise. However, the value you get from a Disney cruise – especially if you’re a Disney fan – can make the extra cost worth it.

So, while both Disney Cruise Line and Royal Caribbean provide exceptional family vacation experiences if your heart is set on the enchanting world of Disney, we’ve got something special for you. At The Park Prodigy, we understand the allure of a Disney Cruise’s magical journey. That’s why we’re excited to offer exclusive deals on Disney Cruise Line vacations! Embark on a voyage filled with Disney magic and unforgettable moments, all at a fantastic value. Visit us to explore these exclusive discounted Disney Cruise offers and get ready to set sail on a dream vacation. Bon voyage and happy cruising!

Related Post: What is the Best Disney Cruise Ship?

Disney Cruise Line vs. Royal Caribbean FAQ

Q: What age groups are best suited for Disney Cruise Line?

A: Disney Cruise Line is ideal for families with children, especially those who love Disney characters and themes. It’s also great for multi-generational groups, offering activities and entertainment that appeal to all ages, from toddlers to grandparents. We also think that, if planned correctly, it’s great for adults who enjoy the Disney theme parks as an adult-only getaway!

Q: Does Royal Caribbean offer any family-oriented activities similar to Disney?

A: Yes, Royal Caribbean offers a variety of family-oriented activities. While they don’t have Disney characters, they do have family-friendly shows, kids’ clubs, and activities like rock climbing and ice skating that appeal to both children and adults.

Q: Can adults enjoy a Disney Cruise even if they’re not traveling with children?

A: Absolutely! Adults can enjoy Disney Cruises, too. There are adult-only areas, including lounges, spas, and pools, ensuring a relaxing and enjoyable experience even without children.

Q: What type of entertainment is offered on Royal Caribbean for teens?

A: Royal Caribbean provides a range of entertainment options for teens, including teen clubs, sports tournaments, DJ training sessions, and themed parties specifically designed for young adults.

Q: Are there any exclusive destinations that Disney Cruise Line visits that Royal Caribbean does not?

A: Yes, Disney Cruise Line has exclusive rights to Castaway Cay, their private island in the Bahamas, which is a unique destination not visited by Royal Caribbean.

Q: What is the average length of a cruise for both Disney Cruise Line and Royal Caribbean?

A: Both Disney Cruise Line and Royal Caribbean offer a range of cruise lengths, typically from 3 to 7 nights, with some extended voyages lasting up to 14 nights or more.

When is The Best Time to Embark on a Disney Cruise?

Our   Disney World Crowd Calendar  is the best tool to help you get the most out of your time at sea. This is simply because most guests who embark on a Disney Cruise pair their sea vacation with a land one in the parks. That’s why we break down park crowds, park hours of operation, ticket prices, and average temperature to help you better book your Disney Cruise Line Vacation. We also break down   the best time to go on a Disney Cruise   based on specific times of the year and special events.

Are You Ready to Plan Your Next Disney Cruise Trip?

Are you planning a trip to Walt Disney World? Be sure to speak with a   Disney World Travel Agent   for the most recent deals and promotions. The Park Prodigy will provide a  Free Quote  for all  Disney Cruise Vacation Packages .  The Park Prodigy can also help you save up to $20 per ticket when purchasing your   Walt Disney World Tickets ,  and we offer promotional discounts for special events such as   Mickey’s Not So Scary Halloween Party Tickets   and  Mickey’s Very Merry Christmas Party Tickets .

Don’t forget to check out our wonderful friends over at  Theme Park Today , as well!

Who We Recommend

Ticket Subtotal: $325.45

Ticket Price Including Tax:

* Your magic rewards program points are automatically calculated into all theme park ticket prices!

Kurt Gillman

Kurt is a former Disneyland Cast Member and seasoned explorer and is your trusted guide to the world of theme park travel. With countless visits to Walt Disney World, Universal Orlando, Universal Hollywood, Tokyo Disneyland, and even aboard the Disney Cruise Line, Kurt's expertise and passion make him the perfect companion for your enchanting adventures. As the Multi-Media Manager, Content Creator and Writer for The Park Prodigy, Kurt hopes his experience and knowledge of the theme park industry can not only save people money, but give them the stress free vacation of their dreams. If he isn’t found trying the newest treats in Disneyland, Kurt enjoys relaxing at home with his dog Sam and playing video games with friends in his free time.

RELATED PRODUCTS

Walt Disney World Tickets

Save time and money on your next Walt Disney World vacation with The Park Prodigy. With our discounted Walt Disney World theme park tickets guests can choose from the following parks!

• Magic Kingdom Park
• Disney’s Holywood Studios
• Disney’s Animal Kingdom

Universal Orlando Tickets

Save up to three hours at Universal Orlando with free vacation planning tools and added benefits. With our Universal tickets guests can choose from the following parks!

• Universal Studios
• Islands of Adventure

Disneyland Tickets

Save time and money with our your next vacation with The Park Prodigy. With our discounted Disneyland tickets guests can choose from the following parks!

• Disney’s California Adventure Park

the disney food blog

food IS a theme park

Read the Latest Posts

Looking for something?

Get the dfb newsletter.

STAY CONNECTED

Comparing Disney Cruise Line, Royal Caribbean, and Carnival — And How the Disney Wish Stacks Up

By Quincy Stanford Leave a Comment

Deciding on a cruise vacation can be a daunting task. There are some major players in the cruise industry, each with its own draws.

Disney Wish Concept Art ©Disney

For Disney fans, it can be hard to beat a Disney cruise — but whew, that price! Carnival might offer a much more affordable option and Royal Caribbean has the largest ships on seas. With Disney launching its largest ship yet , the Disney Wish , it seems a better time than ever to compare these cruise lines. So, how does Disney Cruise Line stack up to other major players like Carnival and Royal Caribbean? And where does the Disney Wish fit in with all this? Let’s find out.

Let’s start with the basics. Though Disney is a giant in the global entertainment industry, Disney Cruise Line is a relatively niche brand in the cruise world. The smallest of the three we’re talking about today (with just four existing ships and the coming Wish), what really sets Disney Cruise Line apart is, well, Disney .

Slushy on a Cruise

Disney Cruise Line offers the “magic” that the Disney brand brings to many fans. You’ll hear Disney music in the hallways, meet Disney characters, eat Disney-themed treats, and see Disney shows.

For those who love the Mouse, you can see why Disney becomes a contender in the who-do-I-cruise-with question.

Mickey at Castaway Cay

Royal Caribbean is the largest of the three lines we’re comparing today with a whopping 26 ships. Royal is known for its innovation and emphasis on the “wow” factor. The ships are huge with one of them holding the title of largest passenger ships in the world and the activities onboard are extremely unique.

©Royal Caribbean

Carnival has a different, more casual approach to cruising across its 23 ship fleet. The atmosphere aboard a Carnival cruise is known to be extremely laidback and the going rates tend to be the most budget-friendly of the three lines by far.

Now, let’s get into the details.

Royal Caribbean has the largest ships in its fleet with Carnival closing the gap and Disney trailing behind — though the Wish will take Disney closer to its competitors in size.

Royal Caribbean

As we mentioned, Royal Caribbean has some of the largest passenger ships in the world. The Wonder of the Seas is currently the largest cruise ship globally and all five of the Oasis-class vessels also sit at the top of the list. The smaller ships accommodate around 1,600 passengers with the Wonder of the Seas accommodating almost 7,000 passengers.

Carnival has long trailed behind Royal Caribbean when it comes to ship size but with the launch of its latest ship, the Mardi Gras, it’s done some catching up. Smaller Carnival ships carry around 2,600 passengers and the Mardi Gras has a competitive capacity of approximately 2,500 passengers.

Disney’s ships are MUCH smaller than those of its competitors. Currently sailing, the smaller ships carry around 1,700 passengers and the larger ships carry around 2,500 passengers.

Captain Minnie on the Ship’s Bow

The Wish will up the average, carrying 4,000 passengers , but it’s still hardly comparable to the gargantuan ships of the other two lines.

Click here to see how the Wish has been rated!

Itineraries.

All three of the cruise lines offer varied itineraries, but Royal Caribbean sails to the most locations and to some parts of the world that Carnival and Disney do not.

Royal Caribbean’s itineraries include popular destinations like the Bahamas, Caribbean, Mediterranean, and Alaska . The line has been known to have as many as seven ships cruising in Europe during a given summer season compared to one from Disney and three from Carnival.

Beyond that, Royal Caribbean sales across the globe with itineraries featuring destinations in Asia, Australia, and South America .

With Carnival’s budget focus, the majority of the cruises sail out of the United States, making it easier for the target audience to reach embarkation ports by car. The majority of itineraries sail to the Caribbean, Bahamas, and Mexico with fewer itineraries sailing in Europe, Alaska, and Hawaii .

With fewer ships, Disney is more regularly limited but does have a tendency to break out. The line always sails to the Bahamas and the Caribbean (making it easier for passengers to combine a vacation with Disney World and a cruise) with seasonal sailings to Alaska .

The Disney Magic

Other destinations vary year by year but have included Mexico, the Mediterranean, the Baltic, and Canada with New England . With its initial launch, the Wish is only set to sail out of Port Canaveral to the Bahamas .

Want to see more of the DCL itineraries? Click here!

Cabin sizes are pretty similar across the three lines although Carnival actually has the largest base inside cabins. The general vibe of the cabins is also fairly different from line to line.

Royal Caribbean’s cabins typically measure around 180 square feet , not including the balcony and there are a variety of higher-level options and suites as well. Decorations-wise, the general feel is elegant, more akin to what you might find at an upscale hotel.

Wonder of the Seas ©Royal Caribbean

Some more unique features include floor-to-ceiling screens in inside rooms that project real-time exterior views and unique or quirky room offerings . One ship has a stateroom that’s view is blocked by the Ben & Jerry’s sign; so, naturally, it’s decorated with a cow theme and the residing passengers are treated to free ice cream daily on the cruise.

Carnival’s staterooms typically measure around 185 square feet , not including the balcony. Of course, there are specialty cabins and suite offerings with this line too. The decor tends to be more colorful than Royal Caribbean, but less swanky.

Disney’s rooms are, on average, about 25% larger than standard rooms on other lines with the average standard cabin measuring around 205 square feet , not including the balcony. These rooms also come with Disney touches , and on the Dream and Fantasy, inside rooms have “Magical Portholes” that show real-time views with animated characters . More luxury rooms are available as well.

©Disney | Disney Dream stateroom

On the Wish, cabins are around 205 square feet as well, with extensive Disney touches including feature artwork and more.

©Disney Wish Stateroom

The staterooms are also designed with families in mind.

To see more of the Wish Staterooms, click here!

Royal Caribbean has by far the more unique activities with a focus on innovative experiences. On the other hand, Carnival has a more casual and party-friendly vibe, and Disney goes all out with Disney-fied activities and a variety of pools.

When Royal Caribbean calls themselves “innovative,” they mean it. This line brings a wild assortment of activities and the sheer size of the ships means they can pack a LOT of interesting recreation onboard. Royal ships have been known to feature surf simulators, zip-lining, ice skating, bumper cars, and high-thrill activities.

On some ships, the variety of activities is so great that it’s literally impossible to experience it all in seven days. Because there’s so much to do, these ships trump Carnival and Disney when it comes to family-geared offerings too. Basically, if you want your cruise to feel a bit like it has an onboard amusement park or mall, Royal Caribbean comes the closest.

Carnival’s activities are more standard with a focus on pool parties and classic cruise activities. Some newer ships feature more innovative activities, like a coaster at sea, but Carnival is all about some good old-fashioned fun.

Where Carnival really shines is the nightlife. Unlike Royal Caribbean and Disney, Carnival puts a real focus on getting the party going and KEEPING it going at nightlife venues around the ships.

As we’ve mentioned, Disney’s real stand-out factor is the fact that many of the activities are Disney activities. You can meet your favorite princesses, join in on pirate days, and play games featuring your favorite Disney characters. Disney also makes a priority of offering pools geared to all ages with more interesting features than your standard pools and hot tubs. Disney is also the only one of the three lines that does not offer gambling onboard — though Disney is looking into sports betting in other segments of the company.

Disney Cruise Line

The Wish is expanding on this further with more innovative offerings like the Disney Uncharted Adventure AR Experience and Disney’s first attraction at sea, the AquaMouse water coaster .

Click here to see more of the AquaMouse!

Reviews tend to agree that Disney stands out when it comes to dining with a fairly inclusive, rotational program. Carnival cruises are also pretty inclusive when it comes to dining with a mix of premium restaurants and included restaurants and a focus on casual fare. Royal Caribbean is widely considered the least inclusive with more specialty restaurants and celebrity concepts than other lines — for an added fee.

Royal Caribbean caters more to a foodie audience with diverse specialty restaurants, a wide variety of dining venues, and celebrity concepts . These ships also have family-friendly spots and a more culturally diverse cuisine than the other two cruise lines.

On the other hand, the wide selections of specialty restaurants could be a disappointment for those who like the all-inclusive nature of cruising as many of these come at a premium .

Carnival cruises offer more options to passengers so you can pick fixed or flexible dining  depending on what would be the right option for you. These ships offer some celebrity concepts, but fewer upscale options. Unlike Royal Caribbean, the basic dining options are typically well-liked, though there are specialty options available as well.

Disney cruises feature a rotational dining system where guests are assigned a dining time and waiter and they eat with the same group at the same time each night in one of the three main dining rooms on a pre-set schedule. Additionally, there are a few anytime options included and two specialty restaurants for an added fee .

Palo Brunch

Even without paying extra for food, you still get to try multiple table-service restaurants as part of the rotational dining. Additionally, unlike the other two lines, Disney does not charge for soda or room service . Our own team members who have taken a number of cruises note that the dining is what really stands out for Disney .

The Disney Wish will be no different with three rotational restaurants: 1923, Worlds of Marvel, and Arendelle: A Frozen Dining Adventure .

It will also offer two specialty restaurants and a number of casual dining locations, lounges, and a sweets shop .

Want to see ALL the restaurants coming to the Disney Wish? Click here!

Entertainment.

Entertainment varies pretty heavily across the three cruise lines. Royal Caribbean has a focus on variety shows and Broadway-scale shows, Carnival is more about the party scene, and Disney has a Broadway focus as well but with the Disney twist.

Six of Royal Caribbean’s ships feature Broadway or West End musicals on every sailing . Beyond that, unique variety shows like water-based high dive and acrobatics performances and music and dance shows in high-tech performance venues are the standards.

Carnivals entertainment is typically found in its nightlife offerings with DJs, parties, piano bar concepts, and more. Carnival is not super known for sweeping stage productions; the fun is found more on deck and in the bars.

Disney’s entertainment features Broadway-scale performances of classic Disney stories plus performances of original stories for the cruise ships . Beyond that, the ships are all licensed to screen Disney movies — including those that are still in theaters on land .

The Little Mermaid

The Wish will continue the trend with Broadway-style shows at the Walt Disney Theatre: The Little Mermaid , Disney Seas the Adventure , and Disney’s Aladdin: A Musical Spectacular . A team member noted that the cohesive stories in Disney cruise shows are an awesome perk for Disney fans, compared to the more medley style on Royal Caribbean.

To see more about the Disney Wish shows, click here!

Private islands.

All three of the cruise lines have access to their own private island and many sailings feature a stop at these spots. Royal Caribbean will take you to Perfect Day Island at CocoCay, Carnival swings by Half Moon Cay, and Disney stops at Castaway Cay.

Royal Caribbean’s Perfect Day Island is an absolute show-stopper and is widely considered the best of the cruise lines’ private islands . There are sandy beaches, theme park rides, water slides, and other wild opportunities like riding in a helium balloon above the island .

Additionally, Perfect Day Island just got a $200 million overhaul adding a major water park , and an exclusive private beach club is coming this year. One of our team members who’s been to both Perfect Day Island and Castaway Cay said the two were about on par with one another — but she went before the $200 million plus-ups.

Carnival’s island, Half Moon Cay has more basic offerings with a large white sand beach and activities such as watersports, boat trips, swimming, and snorkeling .

Disney’s Castaway Cay also has a more traditional cruise experience with beaches, water play areas, walking trails, dining locations, a snorkeling lagoon, character appearances, and more !

Castaway Cay (Disney’s Private Island)

The Wish’s Bahamian sailings will stop by this destination!

Click here to read things we wish we’d known before heading to Castaway Cay!

Quality for families.

All three of the cruise lines offer a solid family focus to passengers. Disney is widely considered the most family-geared because of the brand, but Royal Caribbean and Carnival do a lot to optimize for families as well.

Royal Caribbean is an awesome option for adults and families alik e — though maybe not for those looking for a quiet getaway. Additionally, these ships offer drop-off daycare for babies and toddlers (a rare cruise offering) and offer activities for kids of all ages .

Carnival cruises are positioned as bringing a family-friendly approach to cruising and are often mentioned as a great option for first-time travelers and those with children . This line isn’t, however, the best for those looking for a more upscale sailing.

Disney’s staterooms are designed with families in mind — an approach that will continue on the Wish. Additionally, kids tend to resonate with the characters onboard and Disney-themed activities .

Add Star Wars and Marvel-themed play areas and you’ve got a ship kids will love to play on. The Wish continues the line’s trend of offering TONS of kids-only and adults-only activities.

Want to see more about the Wish kids’ clubs? Click here!

When it comes to pricing for these cruise lines, the three options are fairly different from one another. Carnival is the cheapest with Royal Caribbean typically costing about twice as much and Disney cruises typically costing about four times as much. Whew.

Royal Caribbean is in the middle with moderate fares , however, this line is also known for offering discounts throughout the year . You can typically find reasonable fares on the older ships, just be warned that the newer ships are much pricier. Beyond that, Royal Caribbean has many dining and activity options that cost EXTRA !

Carnival is a budget option with the lowest prices of the three . In fact, the line made a name for itself by providing affordable cruises and most of the dining, entertainment, and activities are included .

Disney cruises are notoriously expensive and the line rarely offers any discounts or promotions. For Disney fans, the Disney “magic” can be worth the price, but for those without a connection to the brand, another line might make more sense.

The Wish is coming in on the pricy side too, with inside cabins starting at $400 per night .

To learn more about Disney Cruise pricing, click here! 

Our team typically ranks Disney Cruise Line above Royal Caribbean and Carnival — but keep in mind, we’re all Disney fans here. Each of the cruise lines has its merits and the right call for you might not be splurging on a Disney cruise just so your ship can be captained by Mickey Mouse.

Carnival, for instance, is hard to beat for those on a tight budget. It’s simply the most affordable. But, you get what you pay for when it comes to experience, and jumping up to Royal Caribbean or Disney could be the move for those who can afford a pricier vacation.

Royal Caribbean also features more older kid and teen amusements than Disney as Disney is geared at the younger crowd with most attractions. So, families with teens and those looking for a more extreme time with attractions might prefer Royal Caribbean of the three.

With Disney, you’re getting that Disney magic with a hefty premium to do so, but for many a Disney fan that can be worth it. Disney’s renowned service and attention to detail are also a staple onboard and with the themed offerings coming to the Wish, the cruise line certainly has its draws (if you’re willing to pay for them).

We’ll be getting an up-close look at the Wish as it gets closer to its first sailing, so stay tuned to DFB to find out exactly how worth it a cruise on Disney’s newest ship really is.

Click here to learn more about Disney Cruise Line!

Don't do it alone.

Our favorite people over at Small World Vacations are ready to help you save time, headaches, and best of all, money, when you book your Disney trip or cruise.

So book that trip now, then sit back and enjoy planning your Disney World Trip with a DFB-approved expert! Click here for a no obligation price quote today, and let them know DFB sent you 🙂

GET MORE INFO

What You Need to Know About Disney Cruise Line

Learn all about disney cruise line and its various ships, explore disney’s mega cruise ship – the wish, a full list of what you can’t bring on a disney cruise, these are the best times to book your disney cruise, the best ways to save space in your tiny cruise cabin, 10 things you need on your next cruise (that you won’t think to pack), what it’s like to live on a cruise ship for 6 months, join the dfb newsletter to get all the latest disney news delivered right to your inbox click here to subscribe.

Got questions about cruising? Ask them in the comments! 

TRENDING NOW

If you own a Disney Visa card, you NEED to see the new deals and...

Heads up! These are the biggest changes coming to Disney World in May!

This NEW bus route can take you straight to Disney Springs from the Orlando Airport...

Listen, before you book tickets for Mickey's Not So Scary Halloween Party, you have to...

Find out how the "real" Tiana is officially linked to Tiana's Bayou Adventure in Disney...

A series has been renewed at ABC following a prior cancelation on a different network.

An accident at Universal Studios Hollywood left 15 people injured last night.

Visiting Disney World in May? Be forewarned is forearmed.

Score two D23 deals right now!

Planning to head to Disney Springs on your upcoming trip? If they fall on one...

Some Disney World rides require some serious pregaming before you get into line -- here's...

You are going to want to go to Gideon's Bakehouse's Original location located outside of...

We just got a FIRST LOOK at an upcoming Magic Kingdom attraction!

Walt Disney World's Disney Springs might best be known for its nightlife. But did you...

Two major television shows have been canceled. Get the details here!

The free-roaming droids have returned to Disneyland!

We think Disney is going to announce the opening date for Tiana's Bayou Adventure SOON!

Another attraction is closing for refurbishment in Disney World.

Don't miss your chance to win this Disney vacation!

Two NEW Disney popcorn buckets are coming to Pixar Fest -- see them here!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.

CHECK OUT OUR OTHER EBOOKS

SUBSCRIBE TO OUR FEED

Comparing Royal Caribbean vs. Disney Cruise Line – Our Pick for Best Family Cruise

This post may contain affiliate links and ads. Read our disclosure policy here .

Trying to decide between Royal Caribbean and Disney Cruise Line ?  We are comparing a whole bunch of specific experiences and ship features across 6 total cruises on these two cruise lines.  See what we thought and use our comparisons to choose the best cruise for your family!

Comparing Royal Caribbean vs. Disney Cruise Line

Our most recent cruise logged my 10th cruise and Bob’s 9th. All of these trips have definitely given us ample cruise experience and we can talk at length about cruise this and that. One question that we are asked most is  what cruise line would we recommend for families ? This is a pretty loaded question because there are so many variables to take into consideration.  My answer would most likely vary based on family sizes, kids’ ages, etc.

You can find all of our cruise-related travel posts under our main travel category , but I will highlight some of my specific Disney and Royal Caribbean review-type posts:

Disney Cruise Lines Review – Magic 3-Night Bahamas from Port Canaveral (with a Kid and a Baby!) Disney Cruise Lines Review – Disney Dream 3-Night Bahamas Disney Halloween Cruise Review – Magic 7-Night Bahamas from NYC Top 10 Best Reasons to Try a Disney Cruise (Parents VS Kids Edition)

Anthem of the Seas Royal Caribbean Cruise Review (8 Night Bayonne, NJ to Bahamas) 10 Total Must-Dos on Royal Caribbean’s Anthem of the Seas

So let’s dig right in!  I am going to share directly from our own experiences and observations.   

Is Royal Caribbean or Disney Cruise Line the best cruise for a family?

Winner: Royal Caribbean

Disney Cruises have become notorious for two things: Mickey Mouse and price tag sticker shock.  It’s true – Disney Cruises are typically more money (sometimes by a LOT) than other major cruise lines. While I do think that the quality you get in return for the Disney price is exceedingly good, I also get frustrated that the cost seems to go up, up, up. Sales are rare and the only discount that we have ever received on a Disney Cruise is the placeholder discount when you basically put money down on a future cruise during a current cruise.  This saves you 10% on a future cruise, but you must take that cruise within 24 months of booking the placeholder. For a balcony cabin on our 5-night cruise to Bermuda, rack rate was $1000/night.  No, that was not concierge or VIP or a suite.  That was just a standard cabin with a balcony. We saved 10% with our placeholder discount, but the bottom line was still a hefty sum at $4500.

Royal Caribbean seems to run booking incentives and other sales almost year-round. If you are patient and especially if your travel calendar is flexible, you could potentially score a pretty great deal. Last fall I caught a Royal Caribbean double dip discount. We booked an 8-night sailing in a balcony cabin on Anthem of the Seas. We stacked a kids sail free promo with a buy one, get one 60% off deal.  Our total, including taxes, for 4 people for 8 nights was $2044.  That’s IT.  Can you believe that?  That’s about the best deal I have ever seen for Royal.  So yes, 3 nights LONGER than our Disney Cruise for LESS THAN HALF of the price.  That is pretty extreme. I will definitely have my eye out for a deal like that one when I go to look for our next Royal cruise.

Kids’ Club and Activities

Winner: Disney Cruise Line

This one is probably a no-brainer, or at least, I  hope it’s a no-brainer. Disney knows a little something about kids and keeping them entertained.  Disney also happens to own the licenses to not just their own characters like Mickey and Minnie, but also Marvel and Star Wars.  This gives Disney Cruise Lines some big-time star power as far as characters and theme-ing goes. Also incredibly impressive on Disney Cruise Ships – the actual kid club space.  Disney has invested so much money and effort into its children’s areas and it shows. Disney’s Oceaneers Club, Oceaneers Lab and even the nursery for babies and toddlers are impressive to say the least.  They take up vast amounts of deck space on each ship. The clubs are big, open, bright, and boast lots of interactive fun. Another big plus is the RFID bracelet system that they use for the check-in process.  Upon boarding the ship and registering for the Youth Activities, each child on a Disney Ship is given a bracelet that very closely resembles the Disney Magic Bands used in Disney theme parks. Not only do these bands make checking kids in and out of kids’ club a breeze, they also allow the staff to locate children in just a few seconds from their computer.  It is impressive to show up to check your kid out of the club and be told instantly where you can find your child within the large play area.

Royal Caribbean’s youth area fell pretty flat for us.  Now, let me back up a few steps to say: my kids had a great time participating in the activities and the staff was fantastic. But after 4 Disney Cruises in a row, we were incredibly underwhelmed with RC’s youth space.  Their space is actually broken up into rooms based on kids’ ages. Landon (age 5) was in a room for 3-5 year olds, while Lily (10) was in a room for 9-11 year olds.  We thought the rooms were way too small for the number of kids inside. In Lily’s group, they were constantly playing ball games and the space simply wasn’t big enough. She came back to our cabin with a new injury almost every time she joined an activity – mostly getting hit too hard with a ball.

Another glaring difference – when Disney’s kid clubs open in the morning, they stay open allllll day and into the night.  They close up around 10 or 11 pm each night.  This open schedule made it SO easy for us (and the kids) to pop in and out of the club whenever it fit OUR schedule.  Royal Caribbean’s kid clubs had set sessions/hours each day and closed over meal times. You had to constantly stop and think, “Wait – is kids’ club even open?” before telling the kids that yes, they could go play. On Disney ships it is much easier to let the kids enjoy the youth space anytime.

Winner: Tie

I cannot think of a single time on either cruise line when we encountered anything other than exemplary, incredible, personable employees who consistently went above and beyond.  Our expectations were exceeded on all levels – from dining to housekeeping to activities directors and customer service – Disney Cruise Line and Royal Caribbean ships both had amazing employees who took wonderful care of us!

From our first Disney Cruise, we were blown away by Disney Cruise Line food. Every meal was something to brag about and even the buffet was incredible. Our first Royal Caribbean cruise was in 2007 and the food was very very good but not as good as Disney’s.

However, on our last Disney Cruise (October, 2018) the food was still very good, but not  as good as previous Disney Cruises.  On our most recent RC cruise, the food was significantly better than we remembered on the last RC sailing.

Room Service Note:  Disney offers room service for free 24 hours a day and we loved this feature and used it at least daily. RC now allows for a free breakfast room service delivery when you choose your food from a limited, continental fare menu. Any additional breakfast items or food delivered any other time of day comes with a $7.95 service charge for each occurrence.  Needless to say, we got continental breakfast delivered almost every day on RC but that’s it – no other room service.

Specialty Dining

Specialty Dining for this post’s purpose refers to optional dining on a ship that is available for an additional charge (ie not included with your cruise fare). Disney is going to lose this category simply for lack of options.  Disney’s larger ships (currently Dream and Fantasy) have 2 specialty restaurants (Palo and Remy). We have eaten dinner at Palo twice and brunch at Palo once. All of our meals there were absolutely exceptional. The food, the atmosphere, the waitstaff were incredibly top notch.

RCCL ships vary by ship, but for example Anthem of the Seas had, I believe, 5 specialty restaurants (not including Coastal Kitchen which is ONLY available for suite guests). We dined at two of the five restaurants – Wonderland and Jamie’s Italian. They were wonderful meals and I can only imagine that the same can be said for the restaurants we didn’t get to try. My best guess is that Chops Grille on Royal would compare to Palo on Disney ships, but again, we did not get a chance to eat there.  Next time!

Shows/Live Entertainment

When you go to a show on a Disney ship, you can expect a Broadway caliber spectacular.   Tangled: The Musical on Disney Magic and  Disney Dreams (I believe on all Disney ships) are my top favorites, but I have never ever caught a show on a Disney ship that wasn’t fantastic. The main dining rooms all have themes and in two of the three (Animator’s Palate and Rapunzel’s Royal Table on the Magic), guests are treated to entertainment while dining. All are amazing and wonderful.

RCCL has a couple of different stage shows on Anthem and we went to one – the musical  We Will Rock You  based on the music of Queen.  It was very entertaining, and perhaps if I was a huge Queen fan I would give it higher marks. The other shows on our ship/sailing (Spectra’s Cabaret and The Gift) just did not sound appealing to us so we skipped them.

Winner: Disney Cruise Line but Royal Caribbean is not far from tying

Suites aside, I will compare the size of a standard balcony room on both a Royal ship and a Disney ship. We have always found the Disney balcony cabins to be very spacious, plenty of room for our family of four. We love the rooms that have a bunk that comes out of the ceiling.

Our friends who cruise RC frequently warned us that the rooms on RC were significantly smaller than the Disney accommodations.  I have to tell you – we did not think the Royal Caribbean cabin was as small as we were expecting!  It was definitely a little smaller than our Disney cabin.  And it did not have the bunk so both kids had to sleep on the pull-out sofa bed.  When the bed was pulled out it was almost impossible to get past the bed to the balcony door. But during the day, when the sofa bed was NOT pulled out, we had plenty of room to move around.

Disney cabins have a split bathroom – one room has a sink/toilet and the other room has a sink/tub. While it’s nice to have two sinks while you’re getting ready for dinner, we actually really loved the bathroom setup on Anthem of the Seas.  That corner shower was downright luxurious!  So spacious! Keep in mind, not all RC ships will have this bathroom setup. In fact, our ’07 sailing on RC’s Vision of the Seas had a smaller bathroom with a standard non-corner shower.

Maybe a silly thing to compare, but those of you who have been reading my blog for awhile now know that I am borderline obsessed with Disney Cruise Line’s H2O+ product line .  The smell of these products literally transports me to a happier mood.  The scent is beachy, fresh, salty, ocean, happy memories.  I love it SO much and always do my best to stock up while we are on board.

Royal’s toiletry line was so  MEH that I don’t even think I brought any home.  Actually our cabin steward never restocked our toiletries ONCE during an 8 night cruise. If I had loved the products the way I love the Disney products, I would have been stalking him for daily restocks.  I just wasn’t impressed.  It was a standard scented shampoo/conditioner that was nothing to write home about.

Overall Ship Upkeep

This one is a little harder to compare between two cruise lines because understandably, older ships are going to show their age a little more.  That being said, we have been on an older and newer ship on both lines.  We thought that both cruise lines do a great job maintaining the overall ship appearance.  Fresh paint, clean rugs, upgrades and refurbishments are always happening and are noticeable.

Adventure-Type Activities

Watch the video below for highlights of some of the adventures we found on board Anthem of the Seas.  RCCL ships are notorious for their adventurous fun on board – from rock walls to Flow Rider to iFly and bumper cars.  Of course, activities will vary by ship, but even the smaller RC ships typically have  something  similar on board.  Disney ships have… a pool.  Well, a few pools. There is a water feature (like a slide) on each ship, and of course the kids’ club that I mentioned above. It will be interesting to see if any of the three new ships joining Disney beginning in 2021 include some of the activities that RC ships have.

Activities for Tweens/Teens

RC has dedicated spaces for teens, as does Disney.  However because of the adventure activities that I described above, we felt that the RC ships had more activities to entertain this age set.

Activities for Babies/Toddlers/Young Kids

While young kids and babies will certainly enjoy a Royal Caribbean ship, Disney is where it’s at for this age.  Landon was just five months old when we took him on his first Disney Cruise. Babies are not just welcomed on Disney Cruises, they are  expected ! It was so great to see how seamlessly the youngest travelers can enjoy things on a Disney Ship.  From the character meet and greets to the Disney theme-ing all around to the shows and kids’ club activities, everything is designed for the little kid crowd. There is a kid’s pool and even a toddler splash area. Disney Cruises were the perfect way for my family to enjoy an incredible cruise vacation during the years when we had a baby and/or preschooler.  I will always be so grateful for that!

Activities for Adults

We had a great date night at Palo on the Disney Dream and Disney Magic.  On Disney ships we were always able to find a quiet spot on the deck to enjoy a nightcap or read a book with a fresh latte. But unless we wanted to head to one of the few bars or attend a seminar on cooking or buying a Disney Vacation Club timeshare, the adult activities were a little lame on Disney Ships.

Royal ships have more bars (again, not really our thing), but many many other activities and entertainment spots happening into the wee hours of every morning all over the ship. We spent a couple of nights losing a few bucks in the casino, watched some hilarious karaoke, listed to some great live music, watched more than one art auction and more.  It’s hard to be bored on a Royal Caribbean ship – no matter what age you are!

Again, I think this category just comes down to volume.  On Disney ships, there is a central area on one deck where you can shop in about two shops.  Most of the merchandise is Disney/Disney Cruise Line themed.

Many of the Royal ships have an entire Esplanade of shops.  Jewelry and watches seem to be the most popular items for sale and every day the central walkway between shops turned into a marketplace of sorts with all sorts of “specials” and “deals.”  People were most definitely shopping and buying and loading up their arms with lots of duty-free merchandise. There were some good alcohol deals as well, but you always have to be mindful of what you buy because when you purchase more than a specific amount, you have to pay taxes upon returning to port.

Final Thoughts

I know what you want to ask me now: WHAT CRUISE LINE WAS THE OVERALL WINNER?   And I promise that I am not taking the easy way out when I say: I do not believe there is one clear cut winner.

What I do think:  I do think that both Royal Caribbean and Disney Cruise Lines offer an incredible value for your hard-earned dollar.  I think that they have customer service down and they take extraordinary care of their guests.  I would (and will) sail on both cruise lines again, and then some.

I hope that my breakdowns have helped you to decide which choice might be the best one for  your family.  Take a look at the categories above and determine which specific things are more important for your vacation.

We love Disney and Disney Cruises were the perfect vacation for us when the kids were really young. We will cruise Disney in the future when we need our dose of Disney magic. As the kids get older and want ships that have more “stuff” (like the adventure activities), we are going to turn to Royal Caribbean who can offer us an incredible value and more activity than we can possibly cram into a week-long vacation.

Both of these cruise lines have been so good to us over the last, oh, 12 or so years, and for that I am very grateful.  I also need to go on another cruise because writing this post has definitely put me in withdrawal.

I would love to hear from you!  What cruise lines are your favorite?  Why? What aspects of a cruise or cruise line are important to your family when you decide which vacation to book? Have you been on any ships that were so absolutely amazing and you think we should try them?

PIN THIS POST TO PINTEREST!

Check out many of my other cruise-related posts right here:

2 thoughts on “Comparing Royal Caribbean vs. Disney Cruise Line – Our Pick for Best Family Cruise”

Do you book with a travel agent? If no, why not? If yes, why?

I did not book with a TA for the RC trip. It was pretty cut and dry, easy to book directly through RC… didn’t need airfare or any other travel accommodations… Disney trips I do usually book through a TA. Not so much because I need the help (I love trip planning) but because I like to help my TA friends earn some commission on my booking. I’m definitely not opposed to using a TA! Just depends on the trip. :)

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.

Fairytale Wonders

Sharing our love of Disney & Travel

How Royal Caribbean Compares to Disney Cruise Line

In this post, we’ll be comparing Royal Caribbean to Disney Cruise Line and talking about some of the similarities and differences.

As lifelong Disney travelers (and travel agents specializing in Disney vacations), we have taken a lot of Disney cruises over the years. In fact, it’s our favorite way to vacation! I have been on 15 Disney cruises, while Josh has been on 22. Even as adults without kids, we have loved sailing with Disney Cruise Line as a couple, or with friends and family. We actually met onboard a Disney Cruise, and we love it so much we had a Disney Cruise wedding too. We had all that cruise experience, but had never tried sailing with another cruise line. When the opportunity came up (through our job) for us to sail with Royal Caribbean, we knew we had to try it! Here’s what it was like for avid Disney cruisers to go on our first Royal Caribbean cruise!

Our FIRST Royal Caribbean Cruise

Our Royal Caribbean cruise was a 7-night sailing aboard the Harmony of the Seas. The Harmony of the Seas is an Oasis class ship, and one of the biggest ships in the world! We sailed out of Port Canaveral to the Eastern Caribbean. Our cruise sailed to St. Maarten, St. Thomas and Perfect Day at CocoCay, Royal Caribbean’s famous private island.

Harmony of the Seas

Royal Caribbean has the biggest cruise ships in the world. Harmony of the Seas is not quite the biggest (the biggest is the brand new Wonder of the Seas ) but it is VERY big! Being so large, it has space for a lot of unique things you won’t find on any other ship. You’ll find unique things like an ice skating rink, an AquaTheater, a Zip Line and more! The ships has its own Central Park and a Boardwalk. Both these areas are open area (Central Park from Deck 8 up, and the Boardwalk from Deck 6 up) so the ship has a unique shape to it with its big open sections in the middle. Despite the size, we found we got used to it very quickly and were easily navigating it by the second day.

Comparing our Royal Caribbean to Disney Cruise Line

Since posting about our Royal Caribbean cruise on TikTok and Instagram , we have gotten a LOT of questions asking how it compares to our Disney Cruise experiences. It felt impossible to fit our thoughts into a short TikTok video, or even the caption of an Instagram post, so we thought a blog post was the best way to share our answer.

The short answer is that for us personally, we found the two cruise lines to offer very different experiences. While there are similarities, each cruise line will offer something different. Both offer an experience that will appeal to different types of people! Or, they may even appeal to the same person at different times, depending on what you’re looking for on a particular vacation. Even though we may prefer one over the other, it doesn’t mean we wouldn’t ever sail with the other again.

And for the long answer….

Royal Caribbean Compared to Disney Cruise Line: Similarities & Differences

When comparing two different cruise lines, we’re going to start with the similarities. Obviously, they are both cruises! On all cruise ships, you’ll experience the amazing feelings of being at sea and the incredible ocean views. They both offer an experience that combines your hotel, entertainment, dining and more, all in one vessel. On both cruise lines, you can also expect to be enjoying a lot of really delicious food!

Another similarity is that they both offer the opportunity to sail to multiple destinations while only unpacking once. They sail to many of the same regions, and will visit the same ports on similar itineraries. For example, if you are comparing a Western Caribbean cruise between the two, the ports/itineraries will likely be similar.

Now, onto what you’re really interested in – the differences. If you’re torn between the two, hopefully these comparisons will help you in making your decision!

As I mentioned, both cruise lines offer a lot of really delicious food. No matter the cruise line you choose, be prepared to EAT! It’s hard to choose which cruise line was better because we felt they each had different strengths.

Our favorite place to eat on the Harmony of the Seas was the buffet, Windjammers. This was where we really felt that Royal Caribbean had the edge over Disney. We both agreed Windjammers really impressed us (much more so than Cabanas on the DCL ships)! Windjammers had a superb variety of offerings, and the food was always hot and fresh. We really loved it and ended up eating there almost every day! We also loved that they had a themed dinner night each evening like Chinese, Indian and Caribbean night.

Main Dining

Alternatively, when it came to the Main Dining Room on RCCL, it couldn’t compare to the main dining on Disney Cruise Line. We had a pretty negative overall experience in the Main Dining Room on the Harmony (more on that later), but the food was still very good. Disney has amazing rotational dining , while on Royal Caribbean you are eating in the same Main Dining Room each night. The restaurant is also much less themed. About half the menu was the same each night, while the other half changed out daily. The menu selection we found to be less ‘fine dining’ than Disney’s main dining. They had some casual options on the menu like spaghetti or fish & chips, which are just less ‘fancy’ than we expected. There were also certain premium entrees that cost extra. Overall though, almost everything we had was delicious!

Specialty Restaurants

On Disney, the main dinners feel like a key part of the cruise experience. On Royal, we felt like the Main Dining Room is very similar each night to encourage you to pay extra for the specialty restaurants. The specialty restaurants onboard cost extra and there are a lot to choose from. We were trying to keep costs down, so we only ate at one – Jamie’s Italian. The food at Jamie’s was very good and we enjoyed it! We didn’t love that you have to pay extra for so many of the restaurants, though.

Disney Cruise Line has specialty restaurants too, but it’s only 1-2 per ship and they are adult-only dining. Those restaurants (Palo and Remy) feel like optional experiences to us – definitely not a must-do because the main restaurants are so fantastic. But on Royal Caribbean, the specialty restaurants feel more like a common thing and you should expect to pay more for those or feel like you are missing out.

Casual Dining

For quick service/grab-and-go meal options, we found both fairly equal. Both offer a variety of casual dining options. There are definitely quick options on both cruise lines that we liked and others that we liked less. One thing we really liked on the Harmony was Sorrento’s pizza, which was open until 1:00 AM and was delicious! One that we didn’t care for was the Boardwalk Dog House; for a place that only has hot dogs, we thought the hot dogs would be better. Overall though, there was a lot to try and for the most part was great!

Room Service

Finally, room service! We only got room service once on the Harmony of the Seas because there is an extra fee. While the food is free, there is an $8 fee per order plus a service charge and gratuity. However, the food was very good quality! The salmon and cheesecake I had were really delicious. The room service food quality was better than Disney Cruise Line, however Disney’s is free. On Disney we usually get room service most nights – but on Royal the fee deterred us from doing that.

As you can see, it’s a trade-off because both cruise lines did better in certain areas. Overall though, they do both have great food so your taste buds will definitely be happy on either one!

Entertainment

For entertainment, we didn’t go in with the highest expectations because we are used to the phenomenal entertainment on DCL. Disney is an entertainment company first, and a cruise line second. They are an entertainment company with a cruise ship , while Royal Caribbean is a cruise line with entertainment. We’ve heard that before, and found it to be an accurate assessment about the quality of the shows. That doesn’t mean the shows were bad, and there was definitely a good variety, but for us overall it just wasn’t up to the level we have experienced with Disney.

Unique Shows

One of Royal Caribbean’s biggest assets is the unique variety of entertainment. They had shows in both the ice skating rink and the AquaTheater in addition to the Royal Theater and smaller venues around the ship. We really enjoyed the ice skating show (iSkate)! If you’re sailing on the Harmony of the Seas, that is definitely a must-do. In the AquaTheater, they we’re running a show called Big Daddy’s Hideaway Heist. The stunts involved in the show were great and the performers were very talented. However, we found the actual plot of the story very strange and hard to follow. We would have honestly preferred if the cast just came out and did cool tricks, rather than try to work it into this storyline.

Royal Theater

In the main theater, they had different shows throughout the cruise. One thing we didn’t like is that you have to make reservations in advance. On Disney Cruise Line, we are used to having our set show time and no reservations needed, so that was an adjustment for us. We went to 3 different shows – Grease, a comedian and a game show called Love and Marriage (adults only). The other main performance was a Journey cover band, which we didn’t go to see.

Grease was the musical aboard the ship. It was shown 3 times (one afternoon, one evening and one late night) throughout the cruise. It was well done, the performers were talented and the production quality was good. Our biggest complaint was with the show itself – it was not family-friendly in the slightest. While the movie Grease is already not very kid-friendly, this show was far beyond that and much more vulgar than we expected, especially for a family cruise line. I wouldn’t recommend this show for teenagers, let alone kids, due to the crude and sexual nature (note: we aren’t parents, this is just our opinion). For a family cruise line, we wish they had a show that was more designed for the entire family or at least toned it down a bit to it was more suitable for all audiences.

Love and Marriage

Love and Marriage was the piece of entertainment that most surpassed our expectations. If you’ve sailed with Disney, you are probably familiar with Match Your Mate. Love and Marriage was the exact same concept – a couple’s game show like the Newlywed Game. This adult-only show was hosted by the cruise director in the Royal Theater and was super fun. It was very funny, the host was great and the couples who participated were hilarious. We also loved that they had a Kiss Cam in the theater while waiting for the show to start! This is a must-do for adults on Royal Caribbean.

Variety Show (Comedian)

The comedian we saw did Action Comedy like juggling and unicycling! He did some very cool tricks like juggling machetes, climbing a free-standing ladder and doing some very cool unicycle stunts. While it wasn’t the best cruise ship performer we’ve ever seen, it was definitely not the worst either. This was pretty on par with the quality of performances we would expect to find on a Disney cruise. We enjoyed it and were glad we went to see it.

Disney Characters

A key component of Disney Cruise Line’s entertainment that you won’t find on RCCL is of course the characters. We enjoy seeing the characters around the ship, but we aren’t super into meeting them like some people are. If you are a big Disney fan and especially if you have kids with you who are really into characters, this may be something you would really enjoy about a Disney cruise.

One area they also did very well was the live music. They had so much live music happening around the ship! Musicians were playing in a lot of venues and doing all kinds of different genres. While Disney Cruise Line has live music around the ship too, I feel it’s rare to see people really dancing and enjoying it like we saw on the Harmony.

Unique Activities

In terms of activities, there’s no comparison when it comes to the sheer amount of unique activities onboard Royal Caribbean! Ice skating, rock climbing, casino, a zip line, a Bionic Bar, the Ultimate Abyss (giant slide), the FlowRider – there were just so many unique things to do. We were able to try some of them during our trip and it’s cool to be able to say we’ve been zip lining on a ship! The closest Disney Cruise Line has to that would be the water coasters and mini golf on some of the ships, it’s nowhere close to the amount that Royal Caribbean has. The sports facilities on the Harmony of the Seas were also numerous and we constantly saw people using them.

Scheduled Activities (like Trivia)

Both Royal Caribbean and Disney Cruise Line also offer activities like trivia and crafts that happen throughout the day. For these types of activities, we’d say Disney offers more variety and more of a mix of adult-only and family friendly offerings. We only went to one trivia session on the Harmony (we saw Disney trivia scheduled and knew we had to go)! It’s hard to compare the quality of a trivia session, but bear with me. Just in simple things like the paper and pencils provided, the way the trivia was run and the seemingly random photos on the powerpoint of questions (unrelated to each particular question), we would say the production quality was lower.

We didn’t attend as many activities on Royal Caribbean because we spent most of our time enjoying the hot tubs and relaxing in day beds. The sheer number of hot tubs onboard was so impressive for us! We really enjoyed that. While Disney Cruises have a great adult-only pool area, we always have felt the lack of enough hot tubs was a major downside. On the Harmony, we also loved the Solarium area. A beautiful relaxing space (for guests 16+) with tons of lounge chairs and day beds. That was definitely a win for us! In terms of pools, the Harmony’s were definitely bigger but of course it’s a much larger ship with many more people. I would think the guest to pool ratio was fairly similar. I do wish they had an adult-only pool but overall, the pool areas were really great!

We really loved our stateroom on the Harmony! The staterooms on Disney ships are a bit more homey, while our room on the Harmony was very modern and stylish. We really appreciated the color scheme and the theming of the room. When we first walked in, we were SO impressed by our room. It definitely exceeded our expectations in terms of the design.

Our room had beds that could be arranged as two twins or as one Royal King (double). I believe our particular room could only sleep 2. For families, I believe rooms that can sleep 4 are available with the exact same layout, but the sofa pulls out to make additional sleeping space. Some Royal Caribbean ships/rooms have pullman beds that come down from the ceiling over the main beds, so it can really vary depending on your ship and room type. The Disney ships have more similar layout across the board, with a queen bed (a true queen, it can’t convert to twins; we find this way more comfortable) and a sofa that converts into a single-size bed. In additional, the vast majority of DCL rooms have another single size bed that pulls down from the ceiling over the sofa, forming bunk beds. Kids seem to love the bunk beds and it’s a very functional design for families.

In regard to the size, the staterooms on Disney Cruise Line are larger than the our room was (we had a regular Oceanview stateroom). A regular Oceanview stateroom on the Disney Fantasy is 204 square feet, while on the Harmony of the Seas it’s 179 square feet. With the layout, the main area of the room didn’t feel that much smaller than we are used to on Disney ships. When you walk into most Disney staterooms, the first part is narrow with closets and the split bathroom. When we walked into our room on the Harmony, it was right into the main area, so it felt more open.

Unlike Disney’s split bathroom layout, our bathroom was a more traditional layout with a toilet, shower and sink. As you would expect from a cruise ship, the bathroom is quite small. Overall, it was functional enough for the two of us and the design was nice. It had shelves for storage which helped make up for the lack of counter space. With a family sharing the room, I think I would miss DCL’s split bath design more but with just the 2 of us it was fine. The water pressure in the shower could have been better, but it wasn’t too bad. I take long showers, which did cause the bathroom floor to flood on two different days but I don’t think most people would have that happen.

A few additional notes about the stateroom:

• We found the bed was not comfortable; both our backs were getting sore by the end of the week.
• The big TV in front of the bed was really nice, but we didn’t end up using it because the movies cost about $12 each for on-demand.
• One thing we liked was that the desk could be moved very easily. When we got room service or late night pizza, we could slide the desk to the sofa and use it to eat!
• The amenities could definitely use some improvement. There was one pump in the shower that had a hair/body wash combo, and bars of soap. There was no lotion and no conditioner. For most of us with long hair, a soap/shampoo combo is not enough, and I can’t imagine how tangled it would be without conditioner! Luckily, I had heard about this before and brought my own shampoo and conditioner.

Cruise ships are known for having fantastic service, so our expectations were high. Overall, we had very good service from the vast majority of the crew we interacted with on our Royal Caribbean cruise. Disney is also known for having amazing service, so I think on Disney Cruise Line you get the combination of both stellar Disney service and stellar cruise ship service for the best overall.

While overall service on Royal was good, I did allude earlier to a very negative experience we had during our cruise. After getting a terrible table location and bad service in the Main Dining Room, we asked to be moved to a new table. We talked to someone and thought everything would be fine. However, when we arrived the next night they put us back at the same table again even after we told the hostess that we had talked to a manager already about moving.

Nobody wanted to help us and they kept passing us off to someone else. There ended up being at least 4 crew members involved who all acted like they were too busy to help us. It literally felt like nobody cared at all that we were unhappy, and like we were an inconvenience to them. We were polite the whole time and maybe that was why they didn’t take our request seriously; but the entire thing was SO awkward and uncomfortable. Even though they eventually moved us, after that experience we both agreed there was NO WAY we were going back to the Main Dining Room again, so we ate in the buffet the rest of the cruise.

Just a fluke?

That one negative experience really put a damper on things for us and impacted our enjoyment of the cruise. I truly hope that it was just a rare fluke and that the vast majority of guests would not experience something like that. It’s hard to give a fair judgement on that when this is the only Royal Caribbean cruise we’ve been on. From friends and clients who have sailed Royal, we haven’t heard of bad experiences like this. But, compared to a Disney Cruise Line cruise – I’ve been on 15 and never had an experience anywhere even close to this. It’s rare for us to have problems because we are very easy going, but I have not felt so disregarded before and that nobody cared and everyone was too busy to help us.

We try not to let that one experience damper our view of the service for the whole cruise. We interacted with a lot of really wonderful crew members, especially in the buffet. They definitely wouldn’t deserve us giving a bad rating of Royal’s service overall. But, we can’t say we had wonderful service the whole time when we also had such a negative experience, and we always want to be honest with you on here.

“What’s Included?” on Royal Caribbean vs Disney Cruise Line

It’s important to remember that these two cruise lines do typically come at different price points, with Royal Caribbean being less expensive than Disney Cruise Line. Many travelers choose Royal Caribbean over Disney for that reason alone. That will definitely reflect in the amount of things that are included on each. Overall, Disney Cruise Line includes a lot more things. For us personally, we like for things to feel more all-inclusive and not feel like we are being nickel-and-dimed. For others, they don’t care about paying as they go for things, especially if the final total still may come out less than a Disney cruise would.

Optional Extras

There are things that are not included on Disney Cruise Line as well. However, we feel like on Disney we could easily go the whole cruise without paying for those extra items as they all feel ‘optional’ for us. On our Royal Caribbean cruise, we felt more like we were missing out if we didn’t pay for some of the extras. I touched on that when discussing the Main Dining Room. On Disney, the specialty restaurants are an optional extra (just for adults) which don’t feel necessary because the main dinners are so spectacular. On Royal, the Main Dining Room is less themed and much more repetitive, making the specialty restaurants feel more like a must-do.

Here are a few things that cost extra on our Royal Caribbean cruise that we wished were included:

• Chat feature on the Royal Caribbean app ($2 per person per day)
• On-demand movies on our stateroom tv (about $12 per movie)
• Soda (beverage packages available)
• Room Service ($8 fee per order, plus service fee/gratuity)

Another example of this is the beverages onboard. On Disney Cruise Line, alcoholic and specialty drinks (like smoothies or specialty coffees) are extra. Soda is included though, both at the 24-hour soda fountains and in the restaurants (not at bars though). Juice is also included in the restaurants as well.

On Royal Caribbean, they offer soda packages at about $9 per person per day. I don’t drink soda, so I mostly drank water with the occasional lemonade (which was free in the restaurants). Josh likes soda but didn’t think he would drink enough to make the soda package worthwhile ($63 + gratuity is a lot of soda). He decided not to get it, but then ended up not even buying any soda throughout the cruise. They also offer beverage packages that include specialty drinks (like smoothies or specialty coffees) for about $30 pp/pd, or an alcohol package that was about $90 pp/pd. All the beverage packages also have an automatic gratuity added as well.

Guests wishing that Disney Cruise Line had an alcohol package option will likely be happy to know that Royal Caribbean offers that! Disney Cruise Line of course has alcohol available for purchase, but they do not offer unlimited drink packages. This helps them keep more of a family-friendly environment. For those who want to drink more while on vacation (enough to get good value out of the $90 per person/per day alcohol package), Royal Caribbean will likely be more your speed.

Neither Royal Caribbean or Disney Cruise Line includes Wi-Fi in the cost of the cruise. If you want Wi-Fi to share your vacation photos or (like us) typically have to work while you travel, Royal Caribbean has the superior Wi-Fi option. On Disney Cruise Line, they offer internet packages by the megabyte or by the minute. With slower internet speeds at sea, that goes quick! On Royal Caribbean though, their VOOM internet is available for a set daily price and worked perfectly for us the entire cruise. We wish DCL offered an internet service like that!

Comparing Royal Caribbean’s Private Island to Disney Cruise Line’s Private Island

It’s honestly hard to compare the private islands we’ve visited because they are so different. Castaway Cay (Disney’s private island) is designed to seem as though you have stumbled across a lost paradise. For this reason, it’s not very built up. Perfect Day at CocoCay, the Royal Caribbean private island we visited, is almost the opposite. It’s very built up with unique and exciting adventures to experience! A water park, zip lining, a hot air balloon, over the water bungalows (in addition to cabanas and daybeds to rent)…. the list goes on. For those wanting a day of thrills, CocoCay offers things no other private island does!

Similar to how we felt on the ship, it seemed that in order to get the full experience on CocoCay you should consider opting to pay extra. On Perfect Day at CocoCay, guests can choose chill or thrill. The thrilling activities like the water park, zip line and hot air balloon ride cost extra, each was about $100 per person on our cruise. If you’re planning to go that route, be sure to factor in the costs for your planned activities. The ‘chill’ option is more easily done for free; though there are options for guests to pay extra to have access to the Coco Beach Club. Guests can chill at the Oasis Pool or one of the beaches for free, though; that’s what we did.

Perfect Day at CocoCay: Our Experience

Our day at CocoCay was extremely windy, which unfortunately caused some issues. Many of the activities were cancelled or unavailable, like the zip line, hot air balloon, kayaking, and swimming with the pigs excursion . We spend the first part of our day exploring the island, just walking around and taking it all in. We basically did a loop of the entire island seeing all the unique things and taking photos and videos!

Once we arrived back where we started, we went to find a beach chair to relax in. Due to the wind, the first beach we went to, Chill Island, had sand blowing up so much (getting in our eyes) that we decided to go to a different beach. Of course, the wind is not something Royal Caribbean can control! We walked to Harbor Beach, which was completely full; not an open chair in sight. We then walked to the Oasis Pool; again, not an open seat anywhere. We walked to South Beach, and again found it completely full. After all this walking, we decided to grab some food from the Snack Shack.

As we ate, we eyed the beach chairs and just after we finished eating, we finally saw one open up. We instantly snagged it so we could lay out and relax. However, after a few minutes there, we figured with the island so busy there were probably a lot more open chairs on the ship. So, we just decided to go back.

Crowd Levels

If we had known how busy it would be, we definitely would have been sure to go EARLY and stake out a spot. For how crowded it was, it likely would also be worth it for a lot of people to rent a cabana or daybed (or an over-the-water bungalow if you wanna be fancy!). For comparison of crowds, there were two ships at CocoCay on our day, one large (ours) and one smaller ship. Our ship was sailing a little over 50% capacity, but I’m not sure about the other ship. So, the crowding wasn’t because there were two ships since it’s very common to have two ships there, and we weren’t even at full capacity!

Private Island Food

The food situation on the island felt very similar to the ship. There were some complimentary options, but there were also other options that cost extra. We partook in the complimentary option, one of the Snack Shacks. We had chicken sandwiches, fries, mozzarella sticks and funnel cake. Everything was pretty good, we especially liked the mozzarella sticks and the funnel cake. For comparison, all the food on Castaway Cay is included.

Conclusion: Comparing Royal Caribbean to Disney Cruise Line

As you can probably surmise from the things we highlighted in this post, there were definitely some things we really liked about Royal Caribbean but also some things we didn’t like. On Royal Caribbean, we especially loved the buffet, the Solarium/day beds, the hot tubs and the Wi-Fi! For the entertainment (overall), the main dining, attention to detail and the level of service, we prefer a Disney cruise.

For our own personal travel style, we both feel that Disney Cruise Line is still our preferred choice. It’s been our favorite way to vacation for years now, and that hasn’t changed. However, we still had a great time on Royal Caribbean! We can definitely see that there would be circumstances where we might choose Royal Caribbean for a particular vacation over a Disney cruise. For example, a trip with young adult friends who maybe aren’t as big Disney fans.

Though we may have a personal preference for DCL, we also know people who have a personal preference for Royal Caribbean! There definitely isn’t a wrong choice, only differences! Some things will work better for certain people than others. We hope this post helps you compare the differences and make a more educated decision on which one may be best for you. If you’ve sailed on either of these cruise lines, let us know your experience and which one you prefer!

fairytalewondersfamily

Recent Posts

• New Chase Southwest Offer for 2024 – The Companion Pass Sign-up Bonus is Back!
• Disney Cruise Line Insurance Costs & Things to Know
• Amazon Prime Day: Musts Have Items for Walt Disney World
• Magic for Adults: Adult-Only Spaces and Activities on Disney Cruise Line
• Adventures by Disney River Cruise on the Danube River
• We Sailed on the Brand New Disney Wish

Disney Cruise vs Royal Caribbean Cruise

If you’re considering embarking on a memorable cruise vacation, you might find yourself torn between Disney Cruise Line and Royal Caribbean. Both cruise lines offer an array of destinations, experiences, amenities, and fun for all ages. But how do you determine which one is the right fit for your next getaway? To assist you in making the best decision, we’ve put together a detailed comparison of Disney Cruise vs Royal Caribbean Cruise, highlighting the key differences and helping you select the perfect cruise experience for your needs.

What Is a Disney Cruise?

Disney Magic | Image © Disney

A Disney Cruise is a magical vacation experience that captivates the entire family. As a subsidiary of the Walt Disney Company, Disney Cruise Line expertly combines the enchantment of Disney’s world-famous entertainment with the adventure and relaxation of a cruise vacation. Onboard their uniquely designed ships, you’ll find a wealth of activities, world-class entertainment, award-winning dining options, and fun for all ages – from children’s activities to adult-only areas. There’s something for everyone when you cruise with Disney !

Sailing to popular destinations such as the Bahamas, the Caribbean, Alaska, and Europe, Disney Cruise Line offers a variety of itineraries that create unforgettable journeys. Guests can expect character meet-and-greets, Broadway-style shows, themed deck parties, and VIP access to local attractions through the Port Adventures program. With an emphasis on family-friendly entertainment and exceptional service, Disney Cruise Line ensures that every voyage fills your heart with lasting memories and a sense of wonder.

What Is a Royal Caribbean Cruise?

Icon of the Seas | Image © Royal Caribbean International

Royal Caribbean Cruise Line is a leading cruise operator known for its innovative ships and exhilarating onboard experiences. From the moment you embark on one of their state-of-the-art vessels, you’ll be swept away into a world of adventure, excitement, and relaxation. Royal Caribbean’s commitment to providing an extraordinary vacation is evident in its diverse range of activities and immersive experiences, ensuring that each day is filled with unforgettable memories for every guest.

Aboard a Royal Caribbean Cruise, there’s no shortage of opportunities to delight and entertain passengers of all ages. Whether you’re soaking up the sun on their beautifully designed decks, browsing the selection at duty-free shops, or savoring delectable dishes at their world-class restaurants, there’s something for everyone to enjoy. Beyond the array of onboard entertainment and activities, guests can expect spacious, comfortable staterooms complete with top-notch service and mesmerizing ocean views.

Comparing Disney Cruises and Royal Caribbean Cruises

When choosing between Disney Cruise Line and Royal Caribbean for your next vacation, it’s crucial to understand the key differences between these two renowned cruise lines. We’ve prepared a comprehensive comparison of their fleets, pricing, itineraries, destinations, activities, dining, suitability for kids and adults, and overall experience to help you make an informed decision.

Disney Cruise Line operates a smaller, more intimate fleet of  five ships : Disney Magic , Disney Dream , Disney Fantasy , Disney Wish , and Disney Wonder . Each ship is designed with the signature Disney touch, creating a magical and immersive atmosphere for guests of all ages. On the other hand, Royal Caribbean boasts a larger and more diverse fleet of  27 ships , offering a vast range of amenities, experiences, and styles to cater to different tastes and preferences.

Disney Cruise Line is often regarded as a more premium experience than Royal Caribbean, resulting in higher Disney Cruise costs per person . For example, we compared prices for two nearly identical cruises: an interior stateroom on a 3-night Bahamian cruise sailing from Port Canaveral on July 7, 2023, with stops at Nassau and the cruise line’s private island, Disney’s Castaway Cay. Aboard the brand new Disney Wish , the cost per person per night was around $480, while on Royal Caribbean’s Independence of the Seas, the cost was about $395 per person per night.

It’s important to consider the inclusions in the price of each cruise line when comparing costs, as they add value to your vacation experience. Disney Cruise fares include a wide array of dining options, entertainment, and activities for all age groups. On the other hand, Royal Caribbean’s pricing also encompasses various amenities, including onboard activities, entertainment, and dining choices, which contribute to the overall value of their cruise offerings.

To secure the best pricing for Disney Cruises or Royal Caribbean cruises, consider using an experienced and highly-rated travel agency like The Vacationeer . They can answer questions, provide advice, help find the perfect itinerary, and ensure you get the best pricing available for either cruise line. As a Diamond-Level Disney Authorized Vacation Planner, they can offer top-notch service and competitive prices, including up to $1000 in Disney cruise onboard credit . Contact them today for more information – their expert services are free of charge!

Itineraries

Both Disney Cruise Line and Royal Caribbean offer short and long-term trips, with cruise durations ranging from three to eleven days and occasional extended itineraries exceeding eleven days. Each cruise line provides a unique selection of routes and stops, so it’s essential to consider your desired destinations when choosing the right option for your vacation.

Moreover, this will determine the necessary travel documentation, such as whether you need a passport for a Disney Cruise or a Royal Caribbean cruise. Being aware of the destinations for your chosen cruise is vital to have all the required documents, including passports, visas, and vaccination certificates, depending on the locations visited. Work with The Vacationeer to ensure a seamless process from start to finish.

Destinations

Disney Cruise Line primarily focuses on popular and family-friendly destinations, including the Bahamas, the Caribbean, Alaska , Hawaii , and Europe . In recent years, Disney has expanded its offerings to encompass more exotic locations such as Australia and New Zealand. Additionally, Disney Cruise Line guests have access to exclusive destinations like Disney Lookout Cay at Lighthouse Point and Castaway Cay, Disney’s private island , where they can immerse themselves in a tropical paradise infused with Disney magic.

In contrast, Royal Caribbean offers a more extensive range of destinations, catering to various interests and preferences. Their itineraries cover not only the popular cruise spots but also more remote and exotic locales, such as Asia, the South Pacific, the Middle East, and South America. This diverse selection of destinations provides seasoned and adventurous cruisers with a wide array of unique experiences and opportunities to explore different cultures around the world.

Disney Cruise Line is renowned for its family-oriented activities and immersive Disney-themed experiences. Onboard, guests can enjoy character meet-and-greets, Broadway-style shows, themed deck parties, and various interactive experiences, such as themed trivia, scavenger hunts, and animation workshops. Disney Cruise Line also offers a wide range of age-appropriate activities for children, including kids’ clubs, teen lounges, and designated spaces for adults to relax and unwind. 

Train to save the world at Marvel Super Hero Academy

The activities are designed to appeal to the Disney enthusiast, creating a magical and enchanting atmosphere that leaves a lasting impression on guests of all ages.

Alternatively, Royal Caribbean is known for its extensive array of activities that cater to both thrill-seekers and those looking for more leisurely pursuits. Their ships boast state-of-the-art features, such as surf simulators, zip lines, rock-climbing walls, and ice-skating rinks, providing an adrenaline rush for the adventurous. Additionally, Royal Caribbean offers more traditional cruise activities, including poolside relaxation, spa treatments, and fitness classes. 

Guests can also enjoy various entertainment options, such as live music, Broadway-style shows, and comedy performances. With a broad selection of activities, Royal Caribbean appeals to a wider range of interests and preferences, ensuring there is something for everyone to enjoy.

Dining on both Disney and Royal Caribbean cruises is designed to cater to a variety of tastes and preferences, with options ranging from casual bites to upscale, fine dining establishments. Disney Cruise Line features a distinctive rotational dining system that lets guests enjoy multiple themed dining experiences during their voyage, including character meals that captivate younger travelers. 

Some of Disney Cruise Line’s notable restaurants include Animator’s Palate, Enchanted Garden, and adult-exclusive dining options such as Palo and Remy, which offer sophisticated dining experiences. In addition, Disney is known for its excellent food quality and presentation, ensuring that every meal is a memorable one.

On the other hand, Royal Caribbean offers an even more extensive selection of culinary choices, with an impressive array of onboard dining venues, including partnerships with celebrity chefs and specialty restaurants that serve a wide range of international cuisines. From sushi to Italian, guests can indulge in diverse culinary experiences throughout their journey. 

Royal Caribbean also provides flexible dining options, such as My Time Dining, which allows guests to choose their preferred dining time and seating arrangements, making it a convenient choice for travelers seeking variety and flexibility in their dining experience.

Best for Kids: Disney Cruise vs. Royal Caribbean Cruise

Disney Cruise Line is the undisputed leader when it comes to catering to children, offering age-specific kids’ clubs, character interactions, and entertainment that focuses on creating a magical experience for younger guests. Disney’s Oceaneer Club and Oceaneer Lab provide a vast range of activities and themed play areas featuring favorite characters from Disney, Pixar, Marvel, and Star Wars, ensuring children of all ages are engaged and entertained. Additionally, Disney Cruise Line offers kids-only events, such as themed dance parties, scavenger hunts, and interactive shows that immerse them in the world of Disney. 

While Royal Caribbean also offers kids’ clubs, family-friendly activities, and dedicated spaces for teenagers, such as the Adventure Ocean program and teen lounges, the cruise line’s offerings cater to a broader age range, and the focus is not solely on younger children. Disney’s emphasis on enchanting experiences and the familiarity of beloved characters make it the top choice for families with younger children who want to be fully immersed in the magic of Disney throughout their cruise experience. There is no doubt that Disney Cruise Line is the best cruise line for kids !

Best for Adults: Disney Cruise vs. Royal Caribbean Cruise

For adults seeking a diverse array of onboard experiences, dining options, adventurous activities, and a more extensive range of nightlife and entertainment choices, Royal Caribbean may be the more appealing option. The cruise line’s ships feature numerous bars, lounges, and clubs, providing a wide variety of atmospheres and experiences to suit different tastes. In addition, Royal Caribbean offers an impressive array of entertainment options, such as Broadway-style shows, live music, comedy clubs, and even outdoor movie nights under the stars.

While Disney Cruise Line also offers adult-only areas, lounges, and entertainment, including upscale dining options and exclusive adult-only sections on their ships, Royal Caribbean provides a broader variety of options that cater to a wider range of preferences and interests. Furthermore, Royal Caribbean’s itineraries include more exotic and remote destinations, such as Asia, the Middle East, and South America, which may be more appealing to adults seeking unique and culturally enriching travel experiences. This makes Royal Caribbean the best choice for adults who want to combine the excitement of a cruise vacation with the opportunity to explore new and diverse locations.

Best For Families: Disney Cruise vs. Royal Caribbean Cruise

Selecting the ideal cruise for your family vacation involves careful consideration of various factors, including your budget, desired destination, preferred activity level, and the interests of each family member. For instance, if you’re seeking a kid-friendly experience infused with that extra touch of Disney magic, a Disney Cruise is likely your best bet. Many people consider Disney Cruise Line the top choice for families with children, thanks to its captivating character interactions, enchanting entertainment, and age-specific kids’ clubs.

Conversely, if your family is in search of a more adventurous and diverse experience with a broader range of destinations, including exotic and remote locations, a Royal Caribbean cruise might be the better option. Royal Caribbean’s extensive array of onboard activities, such as rock climbing, zip-lining, and surfing simulators, appeals to thrill-seekers and active families. Additionally, their wide variety of dining options and partnerships with celebrity chefs cater to diverse culinary preferences, ensuring that there’s something for everyone to enjoy.

When choosing between Disney Cruise Line and Royal Caribbean for your family vacation, take the time to assess the specific interests and preferences of each family member, as well as your overall vacation goals. You may want to involve your family in the decision-making process to ensure everyone’s needs and desires are taken into account. By carefully evaluating these factors and considering the unique offerings of each cruise line, you can confidently choose the perfect cruise experience that will delight your entire family and create cherished memories to last a lifetime.

Best Overall: Disney Cruise vs. Royal Caribbean Cruise

Deciding between Disney Cruise Line and Royal Caribbean ultimately hinges on your priorities, preferences, and expectations for your vacation. Both cruise lines provide exceptional experiences for cruisers of all ages but with distinct differences in fleet size, pricing, itineraries, destinations, activities, and dining options.

If your heart is set on a family-centric experience, complete with the enchanting ambiance of Disney-themed entertainment and a strong focus on creating lasting memories, Disney Cruise Line is likely the better option. Renowned for its magical atmosphere, captivating entertainment, exclusive destinations, and family-friendly focus, Disney Cruise Line is perfect for families with younger children or die-hard Disney fans.

On the other hand, if you’re in search of a more diverse range of activities, dining options, and destinations, with choices that cater to both families and adults, Royal Caribbean may prove to be the more suitable choice. As a luxury cruise line, Royal Caribbean offers a more standard type of cruise experience while still providing a wealth of upscale amenities and activities. With a broader selection of destinations, including exotic and remote locations, Royal Caribbean can be an excellent option for well-traveled families or those looking for a more adventurous and varied cruise experience.

Final Thoughts

To choose between these two cruise lines, take into account your budget, the destinations you want to explore, the type of activities you prefer, and the overall atmosphere you desire during your vacation. Additionally, consider the age range and interests of your travel companions. It’s essential to research the itineraries, onboard activities, and accommodations offered by each cruise line, as well as read reviews from fellow travelers. It’s always wise to consult with a travel agent specializing in cruises to gather further insights and recommendations. By carefully weighing these factors, you can confidently select the cruise line that best matches your needs and preferences. This will ensure an unforgettable and enjoyable cruise adventure for everyone involved!

Why Wait? Book your Next Cruise Today!

Both cruise lines are great, but when it comes to the Disney Cruise vs Royal Caribbean Cruise debate, we lean slightly towards Disney Cruise Line due to the fantastic level of service and amenities. If you’re ready to book your Disney cruise , contact the Disney experts at The Vacationeer ! Their planning services are provided at no additional cost to you, and there’s never any obligation to book. Plus, they offer up to $1000 in onboard credit as a booking bonus to be spent on extras not included in the cruise fare.

Should you be interested in exploring Royal Caribbean options, The Vacationeer would be more than happy to help you compare pricing and find the best itineraries at the lowest price. Whatever your choice may be, contact them now for a free instant price quote and start planning your dream cruise vacation today. With their assistance, you’ll be able to navigate the Disney Cruise vs Royal Caribbean Cruise decision and find the perfect match for your unforgettable getaway. They can even help you compare Disney Cruises against other cruise lines such as Norwegian , Princess , and Carnival .

Related Posts:

Share This Page: Choose Your Platform!

Related posts.

Leave A Comment Cancel reply

Family Travel with a Celiac Momma & a Sprinkle of Pixie Dust

A Comparison of Disney Cruise Line vs. Royal Caribbean

This past winter (2015) I was able to cruise Disney Cruise Line (DCL) and Royal Caribbean Cruise Line/Royal Caribbean International (RCI) within 6 weeks of each other. Cruising so recently makes a comparison that much easier. This comparison of Disney vs. Royal Caribbean will go through many of the main components of each cruise.

Cruising were myself, my husband, our 21/22 month old and his grandmother (my mother). The first cruise was on the Disney Magic and the second was on the Freedom of the Seas, a Royal Caribbean International ship. We all really enjoyed ourselves on both cruises but there were some standouts to each. [My family cruised the Disney Fantasy a year ago so that experience comes into the review as well.]

Let’s get down to my comparison of  Disney Cruise Line versus Royal Caribbean

Let’s start with a comparison of the most important aspect of a cruise- the food!  All joking aside, food likes are very subjective. For the most part we enjoyed our meals on both cruises.

Meals in the dining room. The food quality was slightly better on DCL, but we still very much enjoyed our RCI meals. My mom thought the lobster she was served on RCI was some of the best she had ever had, and she had several pieces. The service in the dining room for dinner was better on RCI. I have celiac and thus have to eat gluten free (GF). I had less problems for the most part with delays with my meal on RCI. One dinner, I waited over 45 minutes to receive my first course on Disney. There was one lunch at RCI that I had some gluten contamination in the dining room no less. [What makes this interesting is RCI told me to eat in the dining room in order to avoid cross contamination with gluten.]

Meals in the buffets. The service on Disney was better. They were really happy to walk me through to look for GF options. RCI tended to want to push me to the GF section that had one bland looking entrée and an even worse side dish (think plain white rice.) [I’m not sure why people confuse gluten free with no taste or seasonings.] My picky eater husband felt that he had more choices on DCL. The drink service at the buffet was better on RCI. They were terrific at getting you drinks while you were you dining in the buffet.

Other dining venues. RCI wins for the average eating with options for food throughout the day. One of my biggest complaints about DCL is the limited hours of operation of the buffet and the dining choices when the buffet is not open. The “quick service” on DCL is usually mediocre at best. RCI has several dining choices on the promenade as well as longer hours with offerings at the buffet. Disney wins however for gluten free pizza. It was fresh and amazing. Sbarros on RCI served me a “soggy mass”, as my husband described it.

As for the specialty restaurants – our experience was definitely effected by my need to eat gluten free. Disney was amazing. It was almost as if the chef at Palo made it his personal mission for the week to find me amazing food to eat. On RCI we dined at Giovanni’s Table for our specialty meal. I had to ask 3 times if something was GF only to find out that what they served me was not. We were also very unimpressed with the service at Giovanni’s which tainted the whole experience.

Room service. Neither line is great, but both were okay. You can get Mickey bars on Disney, and at one time, rice crispy treats (I don’t know if they are still offered though.) Both offer cheese plates. Neither offer gluten free crackers. Royal Caribbean is starting to charge for some items, but Disney offers less in the first place.

The cabins. People LOOOVE the split bathrooms on Disney. There is a shower (with a little tub in most categories) and sink in one room, and a toilet and sink in another. My family is not big enough, nor is my son old enough, for the split bathroom to matter. But I can see why people get excited about that. The little tub provided by Disney is awesome for those with little ones. To get a tub on RCI you need a suite. And those tubs are the large soaking tubs which does tend to make it more difficult to bathe a little one. The cabins are larger on Disney. In fact, the cabins on Royal Caribbean’s newest ships keep getting smaller and smaller. Disney also has a curtain to separate the kid’s sleeping area from the parents.

As far as amenities provided- in my opinion, Disney has the best body lotion of any line. They also provide every cabin with bar soap and a separate shampoo and conditioner. RCI does the combined bulk shampoo/conditioner attached to the wall in the shower. For the price point, I think this is a little cheap of them. [Suite guests are provided with a separate shampoo and conditioner.] I would say the cabins are close on both lines, but ultimately Disney slightly edges out RCI.

On to entertainment and activities. Both lines offered evening shows each night. The shows were past my son’s bedtime so we didn’t watch any in the theatres. We did watch the Disney productions on the TV in our cabin. For child orientated entertainment, Disney obviously wins by a landslide. Each evening there are shows that would be entertaining to both children and adults. RCI’s entertainment is not created with children in mind. I am sure older children will find the shows enjoyable but your typical toddler would not likely sit through it. Royal Caribbean does have an ice show on its ships with a rink. My son was mesmerized by the show. He sat through the entire 45 minutes. Both lines offered a Love and Marriage (Newlywed) show for adults that were equally entertaining.

Toddler organized activities. RCI has a great toy lending program where you can sign out a bag of toys. Disney didn’t have anything like that. Royal Caribbean also offered an open play with toys and books. It was in located in the teen night club. Disney takes the win though for organized toddler activities. They have staff there to play with the kids. They offer different activities at various times of the day. It is a scheduled event so some people may not prefer that, but we preferred it over just open play for the whole day. Disney also offered dance parties with the characters which were SO MUCH FUN. My son LOVED it. The characters would come out and dance to about 3 songs. Disney definitely wins on this area for us.

Kids Clubs. To get to the kids club or the toddler play areas on RCI you had to walk through the arcade. This is VERY irritating to me. Of course your child will want to play with the brightly colored arcade games while walking through. And then even if you limit charging privileges for your kids in other areas of the ship, those limits apparently do not apply in the arcade, per the sign on the machines.

Toddler outdoor water areas. The smoking section is very close to the toddler/infant wading pool on RCI. And the brightly colored splash pad for non-diapered kids is right next to and in full sight of the toddler section. This is a problem with older toddlers that can clearly see the fun brightly colored splash pad for bigger kids. DCL has a dedicated splash pad for toddlers. On the newer ships there is even a little slide in the Nemo’s reef area. On the Magic Donald’s nephews have a little splash pad that is adorable. The splash pads on Disney are definitely designed for toddlers and infants in mind. The theming is terrific. The win goes to DCL for sure, even on the smaller older ships.

Shore excursions: Cabanas. The only ‘shore excursion’ that we did on both cruises were renting cabanas for the day on the private islands. Disney’s cabana is 3 times the price of RCI, but there are so many extras and that was worth it to us. The main difference was that the beach was just for people in the cabana. Royal Caribbean allows the beach to be used by those in the cabana and everyone else. There was a lot of smoking on RCI’s beach (we were at Labadee). It was just crowded and people put their chairs everywhere! Just below the stairs of the cabana were people’s chairs we would have to walk around to get out of the cabana. This was not ideal. The definite nod goes to DCL.

Shopping. The shopping was all around better on RCI. We loved the promenade. There were many choices of things to purchase. Disney basically just had their own items for sale. The ship’s salespeople on the Freedom (RCI) in the jewelry shop were very PUSHY. That was the only real disadvantage of RCI. Overall though RCI definitely wins for shops.

Character Experience. RCI has the DreamWorks characters on board. Disney, hands down, is just better with the whole character experience. RCI offers a DreamWorks parade, which in concept is a great idea, it is just not executed very well. Disney wins with characters.

Taking our toddler out of the mix for entertainment, then RCI would be more competitive. The rock climbing wall is awesome and the ice skating rink is unique. They also offer a surfing experience. All of those neat extras are included in your cruise fare.

Extra miscellaneous comparisons. Royal Caribbean offers a drink package where you can prepay for your alcohol or coffee drinks. Disney allows you to carry on as much alcohol as you’d like to consume for the week (see the end of this paragraph for an update on this information), but it isn’t comparable. People don’t want to run to their room to get a drink; they want to drink by the pool, and drink at dinner, etc. The prices though to pay out of pocket for a drink on RCI seemed a little high this last cruise – it was $9 for a gin (Tanqueray) and tonic. On RCI, you can bring on 2 bottles of wine, but no liquor. [Edited in September 2015 to note that Disney has changed their alcohol policy for sailings after approximately Sept. 27, 2015 that liquor is no longer allowed to be brought onboard, beer in limited amounts is okay, and 2 bottles of wine per cabin is allowable. This does even the playing field as far liquor is concerned.]

The thing I disliked the most on Royal Caribbean – smoking in the casino. The smell would waft up from the casino on the 4th floor to the promenade on the 5th floor. According to my mom, the slot machines they offer in the smoke free section of the casino were “dumb.” Such a wordsmith my mother. Either way, she and my husband would have gambled more but for the smoky casino.

We really enjoyed both cruises. In fact we have future cruises booked on both lines. Disney is without a doubt more expensive. But they truly do cater to younger children, toddlers specifically. Please feel free to ask me any questions about the lines in the comments below or share your thoughts comparing both lines.

Happy travels!

To see pictures of both cruise lines, check out my photos on  Instagram . 

Remember to always #packyourpixiedust

Author: Christy P

Christy is a Mom, Wife, Travel Planner, Attorney, Podcast Enthusiast & Co-Host (DCL Podcast) and a sometimes blogger. She writes about family travel, gluten free travel, and life as a travel addict. Her motto is "work hard to play harder!" Whatever you do, don't forget to Pack Your Pixie Dust. View all posts by Christy P

9 Replies to “ A Comparison of Disney Cruise Line vs. Royal Caribbean ”

• Pingback: Summer Vacation! My thoughts on cruising in the summer… | Pack Your Pixie Dust
• Pingback: Fantasy becomes Reality- a trip report of our family cruise on the Disney Fantasy | Pack Your Pixie Dust
• Pingback: Upgrading your Disney Cruise Line Cabin at the Pier | Pack Your Pixie Dust
• Pingback: Concierge Cabin 12000 on the Disney Fantasy | Pack Your Pixie Dust
• Pingback: My dining time is when?? My experience moving from 2nd seating to 1st on Disney Cruise Line | Pack Your Pixie Dust

I’m cruising for the first time with two 17 year olds. I was originally going to book through DCL but I’m the only Disney lover in the group so I’m trying to decide if I should cruise with RCI. The only thing holding me back is dining and the extra costs. After your article I’m starting to sway to RCI. Is there many other extra costs besides soda and room service that I should be aware? What is the tipping procedures for RCI? The 2 bottles of wine, is that person or per cabin on RCI?

Thanks for any help.

The advantages of RCI is that there are all those other activities- like a rock climbing wall, surfing activity, etc. There is no additional charge for those. I doubt you would incur so many additional costs that it would come close to the price of a Disney Cruise. We love Disney Cruises, but they are pricey. The Tipping procedures for the two lines are the same- you will be charged to your account during the cruise an amount per person, per day. You can adjust it if needed at guest services. We usually give extra by cash at the end of the cruise to our waiter and room steward for extraordinary service. Here’s a pretty good break down of what’s included and what’s extra on the cruise – the extras are at the bottom, but they are pretty similar to Disney. https://www.royalcaribbeanblog.com/2018/05/31/whats-included-your-royal-caribbean-cruise-fare . I have a comprehensive cruise guide that I could send you that may explain more and answer more questions. Just let me know and I will email it out. Remember there is not usually a charge to book with a travel agent. It might be to your advantage so you can keep getting advice. There’s really no disadvantage, the Travel Agent makes the payment directly to the cruise line so that is what you will see on your charge card. You can find a local one, or I can always help you as well. Remember when you use a travel agent, you are helping out a small business. Either way good luck making your choice and have fun on your vacation!

I am thinking of doing the Disney Magic Cruise for a 4 night in the Bahamas. But we are also looking at the Freedom of the Seas by RC. Compareing price. Disney Magic is 4k for a window room on deck 2 front of the ship and 3400 for RC balcony. We are just trying to see how much our 5 year old and 6 month old would enjoy disney. obv our 6 month wouldnt really get much from the cruise. But Wondering if you would choose disney?

The quick answer is I have chosen 3 RCI cruises to 24 DCL Cruises. I started cruising with my son with he was 7 months old. With Disney they have character dance parties and actual characters to meet. The price difference is not that much really. The baby wouldn’t be able to go in either pools, but there is a babies and diapers area on the Magic (it is small compared to other ships.) There is also a baby splash zone on the Freedom of the Seas. The cabin on Disney will be larger. I can help my clients do a more detailed deep dive. You can reach out if you would like to use my services for no additional charge to you.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Check here to Subscribe to notifications for new posts

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed .

Cruise line showdown: Comparing Carnival, Disney and Royal Caribbean for families

When I first started cruising more than 25 years ago, the typical ship was heavy with honeymooners and retirees — the "newlywed and nearly dead," as the old joke goes. The most exciting thing for families on the top deck of many vessels, other than a pool, was a shuffleboard court. The line perhaps most associated with family cruising, Disney Cruise Line , didn't even exist yet. Things sure have changed.

Among the lines that dominate the industry, the game increasingly is all about families. The world's two biggest cruise operators — Carnival Cruise Line and Royal Caribbean — now draw hundreds of thousands of families a year and, along with smaller players Norwegian Cruise Line and MSC Cruises, are increasingly packing their ships with every sort of family-friendly attraction imaginable, from massive waterslides and deck-top "sky rides" to go-kart tracks, bumper-car pavilions and laser-tag courses. Carnival is even planning a roller coaster for its next vessel .

In short, ships are becoming floating versions of the most over-the-top family resorts on land and there's never been a more exciting time to try family cruising. That is, if you can figure out the right ship and cruise line for you.

Related: Why now is the best time to save money on a cruise

For a first-timer , booking a family cruise can be more than a bit overwhelming. Each of the aforementioned lines has a different vibe, and no two ships — even vessels from the same series — are exactly alike.

What's more, pricing for family cruises is all over the map. A sailing with Disney can cost two or three times as much per day as a sailing with Carnival, Norwegian or MSC.

Below we offer considerations and pricing comparisons for three of the biggest players in the family cruise market: Disney, Royal Caribbean and Carnival.

Cruise lines overview

You might assume Disney is the Hercules of family cruising — the all-powerful competitor with no rival. But in the cruise world, Disney is still somewhat of a niche player. With just four ships compared to the 52 operated by family cruise giants Carnival and Royal Caribbean, Disney is like the cruising equivalent of Olaf from "Frozen" — a bit secondary to the plot, if still much beloved. In terms of passenger capacity, Disney is currently barely a tenth the size of Royal Caribbean alone, and it doesn't offer nearly as diverse an array of home ports and itineraries.

Note though that Disney Cruise Line plans to launch three new ships in its Triton class with the 4,000-passenger Disney Wish set to premier in January 2022.

What Disney does offer that no one else can is Disney. From Disney tunes piped into cabin hallways and Disney-shaped food items on menus to Disney-themed evening shows and the promise of meeting your favorite Disney princess, Disney ships are mouse bait for the diehard Mickey lover. If Disney is your thing, nothing in cruising quite compares. Just be prepared to pay up big time for the privilege of sailing with Captain Mickey or Minnie (more on that in a moment).

Related: Cruising with a family: Booking two staterooms for the price of one

Carnival long has claimed to be the biggest cruise line for families, with more than 800,000 children a year traveling on its 26 ships (out of 5.2 million total passengers). Known for its affordability as well as its lively, unpretentious, fun-focused vibe, this is the most budget option of the three lines we are comparing. You're likely to pay considerably less to sail with Carnival than Royal Caribbean or Disney.

For families craving the mega-resort experience, there's nothing quite like a Royal Caribbean vessel. The biggest of the line's 26 ships are more than 70% bigger than the biggest Disney and Carnival ships afloat and feature a lot more "stuff" that will get your kids' hearts racing — everything from rock-climbing walls and surfing pools to skydiving simulators and ice-skating rinks. Royal Caribbean also will offer you a lot more choices when it comes to itineraries. The line will have seven ships in Europe this summer, for instance, compared to one for Disney and three for Carnival. (Carnival, it should be noted, is a line that primarily focuses on cruises out of U.S. ports that are easy for its budget-conscious customers to reach by car or with a short, inexpensive flight.)

Related: How to book a cruise using miles and points

Comparing prices: A specific example

In general, on very similar itineraries, you'll a pay a premium — sometimes a huge premium — to take your teens and toddlers on a Disney ship instead of a Royal Caribbean ship, and both of those lines will cost you more than Carnival. Just how much more? We priced similar summer sailings to the Caribbean on the three lines and found a hypothetical family of four would pay about 2.6 times more to get aboard a Royal Caribbean ship than a Carnival ship and more than four times that to sail with Disney.

For the comparison, we looked at specific seven-night Eastern Caribbean sailings offered by each line out of Port Canaveral, Florida, at the beginning of August. We chose this routing because it allowed for one of the most apples-to-apples matchups you can make between the brands. All three of the companies have positioned one of their newest, snazziest vessels in Port Canaveral for seven-night Caribbean sailings.

In Carnival's case, it's Carnival Breeze, which debuted in 2012 and is one of the line's newer Vista-class vessels. For Royal Caribbean, it's Harmony of the Seas, which began sailing in 2016 and is part of the line's popular Oasis class. Disney's contender in the market is Disney Fantasy, the line's newest ship. It debuted in 2012, just two months before Carnival Breeze.

Related: Which Cruise Ship Cabin Category Should Your Family Book?

When pricing, we assumed we were booking a family with two adults and two children ages 8 and 12 who would share a single cabin. We found:

• The least expensive cabin available for Carnival Breeze at the time of our pricing would have set our family back $2,020.56 (an average fare of $562 per person, plus $139.64 per person in taxes and fees). For that, our family would have gotten an Interior cabin measuring 185 square feet. Such rooms have two twin beds that convert into a king bed, plus two beds that pull down from the wall.
• The least expensive cabin on Royal Caribbean's Harmony of the Seas costs $5,310.80 (an average fare of $1,213.75 per person, plus $113.95 each in taxes and fees). Notably, that higher price would have gotten our family a cabin measuring just 149 square feet — nearly 20% smaller than the cabin on Carnival Breeze. As with Carnival, it was an interior cabin — in this case with two twin beds that convert into a king bed and a double sofa bed.
• The least expensive cabin on Disney Fantasy costs a relatively sky-high $8,259.16 (an average fare of $1,959.44 per person, plus $105.35 each in taxes and fees). For that, our family would have gotten a Standard Inside Stateroom that measures 169 square feet — a bit bigger than the comparable cabin on Harmony of the Seas but smaller than the one on Carnival Breeze. Such rooms have a queen bed, a sofa that converts into a single bed and a pull-down bunk.

Trading up to a balcony cabin: The differential stays the same

Sometimes the cheapest cabin on a ship just won't do, so we also priced the cost of trading up to a balcony cabin on each of the vessels — an exercise that helps to illustrate two big things.

First: A "splurge" on a balcony cabin versus an inside cabin isn't nearly as costly as many people think. In our pricing test, passengers would only have to pony up 1% more for a balcony cabin on Royal Caribbean and just 4% on Disney Cruise Line. Carnival was the outlier with its balcony cabin pricing out 26% more expensive than an interior (which isn't always the case).

Second: The premium you'll pay for a Disney or Royal Caribbean ship versus a Carnival ship is roughly the same when booking a balcony as it is when booking an entry-level cabin. In this case, we found our family of four would pay double to get on Harmony of the Seas than Carnival Breeze and four times more to get on Disney Fantasy. Specifically:

• The least expensive balcony cabin on Carnival Breeze would have cost our family $2,554.56 (an average of $499 per person, plus $139.64 per person in taxes and fees). For that they would have gotten a Cove Balcony that has basically the same footprint as the previously priced interior cabin (its interior space is an identical 185 square feet) with the addition of a 45-square-foot balcony.
• The least expensive balcony cabin available on Harmony of the Seas costs $5,363.80 ($1,227 per person, plus $113.95 each in taxes and fees). For that, you get a cabin overlooking the ship's Boardwalk amusement area with 182 square feet of interior space and a 52-square-foot balcony.

• The least expensive balcony cabin on Disney Fantasy costs $8,609.16 ($2,046.94 per person, plus $105.35 per person in taxes and fees). This for what the line calls a Deluxe Oceanview Stateroom with Extended Veranda — Mickey sure has a fondness for long names. These cabins have 204 square feet of interior space, plus a 43-square-foot balcony. The room has a queen bed, single convertible sofa, upper bull-down bed (in some) and a split bath design with tub and shower (in most).

Related: The Best Credit Cards for Booking Cruises

Going big with suites and concierge-level service

For those willing to splurge on even bigger cabins and upgraded service, the comparisons between the ships get more complicated.

Carnival offers relatively few suites on most of its vessels. Fewer than 75 of the 1,845 cabins on Carnival Breeze are suites. The line also lacks a premium "concierge class" of cabins that come with dedicated concierge service and other extras.

Royal Caribbean's recent vessels, by contrast, are awash with suites in a wide range of sizes, including enormous (and super-pricy), two-deck-high complexes that are among the most luxurious accommodations at sea. Royal Caribbean, in recent years, also has added a concierge-class-like program for suite passengers on some of its vessels (Harmony of the Seas among them). Called Royal Suite Class, it offers more polished service and exclusive access to shipboard restaurants, lounges and attractions.

Like Carnival, Disney offers relatively few suites on its ships. Just 21 of the 1,250 cabins on Disney Fantasy are suites. But the line does offer exclusive Concierge cabins that come with access to a concierge team that can help arrange onboard activities and services. On Disney Fantasy, the Concierge service is available with all 21 suites, plus 20 nonsuite Concierge Family Oceanview Stateroom with Verandah cabins. In addition to concierge service, all 41 rooms come with access to a private concierge lounge and sun deck. Other perks include priority boarding.

For our hypothetical family:

• The least expensive suite on Carnival Breeze — a 340-square-foot Ocean Suite — priced at $3,934.56 (an average of $844 per person, plus $139.64 in taxes and fees). This is, notably, still half as expensive than even the least expensive cabin available on Disney Fantasy.
• For the suite life on Royal Caribbean, our family would pay at least $7,538 ($1,884.50 per person, plus $113.95 in taxes and fees). That's for a Junior Suite, which measures 287 square feet plus an 80-square-foot balcony.
• The least expensive suite on Disney Fantasy priced at a stratospheric $23,546.60 ($5,781.30 per person, plus $105.28 per person in taxes and fees). That's for a 622-square-foot Concierge 1-Bedroom Suite with Verandah. That said, you can get into one of the nonsuite Concierge cabins for about half that cost. Disney doesn't call those cabins suites, but they measure a respectable 306 square feet. That's not much smaller than the smallest suites on the other ships.

Related: Alaska cruise tips: best itineraries, ports and ships

What's included and what's not

As regular cruisers know, the fares that lines quote for sailings include more than just your lodging. For all the ships in our comparison, the price also includes breakfast, lunch and dinner (at main restaurants and buffets); nightly entertainment in showrooms; and a significant swath of onboard activities. What's not included are alcoholic and, in some cases, nonalcoholic drinks (Disney offers free sodas on its ships; the others don't); meals at "specialty" restaurants; spa and salon services; shore tours and some onboard activities.

We won't run through every extra charge here. But consider that you'll pay around $6 to $7 for a beer on all three ships, and a cocktail can run anywhere from $7 to $14 (in general, Harmony of the Seas has the highest drink prices). Among extra-charge restaurants, you'll find a flat fee of $38 per person at the signature steakhouse on Carnival Breeze, a tad less than the $43-per-person charge for the Chops Grille steakhouse on Harmony of the Seas. Disney Fantasy doesn't have a steakhouse, but its signature, adults-only Palo eatery is in the ballpark at an additional $40 per person.

You'll also pay extra for the service charges that have become commonplace on ships. For most cabins on Carnival, Royal Caribbean and Disney vessels, a family of four would pay $391.72, $406 and $378 per week, respectively, in such fees. Passengers in suites pay more.

The bottom line: It's frustratingly easy for a family of four on any of these ships to run up $1,000 or more in extra charges.

Family attractions

Each of the ships in our comparison is among the most alluring in their respective fleets for families. You'll find watery play zones, family pools and other kiddie lures on the top decks of all three vessels, and plenty of supervised kid zones in their interiors.

Specifically, Carnival has loaded the top of Carnival Breeze with one of its signature, family-focused WaterWorks waterpark areas that has two giant waterslides, a soaking "dump bucket" and other get-you-wet features; a suspended-in-the-sky ropes course; a miniature golf course; and a basketball court. Family attractions on the inside of the vessel include a 3D theater with moving seats and special effects (a cruise ship rarity).

Not to be outdone, Disney has given Disney Fantasy one of the most innovative deck-top attractions at sea, the 765-foot-long AquaDuck "water coaster." Disney Fantasy's top deck also is home to a family pool, kiddie waterslide, kiddie play area, miniature golf course and basketball court. Its insides are loaded with some of the most elaborate children's play areas at sea — all Disney themed, of course.

Still, when it comes to family-friendly attractions, neither Carnival Breeze nor Disney Fantasy comes close to offering the array of options available on Harmony of the Seas.

At 226,963 gross register tons, the ship is about 75% bigger than its two competitors, and all that extra space allows for a crazy array of amusements. You'll find a waterpark area with three large slides; a separate dry slide that plunges nine decks (Royal Caribbean says it's 10, but don't be fooled; it counts a Deck 13 that doesn't exist); three main pools and separate surfing pools; a watery kiddie play zone; two rock-climbing walls; a miniature golf course; a basketball court; and a zip line. There's also an outdoor Boardwalk area that mimics the Jersey Shore with a carousel and arcade. Teens have their own onboard disco, part of interior kid zones spread over parts of two interior decks.

Crowds and service

On all three of the ships in our comparison, you're going to feel the crowds at times (just ask TPG Family founder Summer Hull, aka Mommy Points, who recently wrote about the pool area pileup she saw during a Disney sailing). This is just par for the course on big, mass-market vessels that sail with thousands of people.

Still, when it comes to feeling the jam, there are some significant differences between the three ships in our comparison.

For starters, you'll often find more people packed onto Carnival Breeze than Disney Fantasy, even though the two ships are roughly the same size (about 130,000 gross register tons). Carnival Breeze can hold up to 4,891 passengers if every berth is filled, about 22% more than Disney Fantasy. The differential is even more notable if you look at the "double occupancy" numbers for the two ships — the number of people they would carry if two people occupied every cabin. Carnival Breeze's capacity based on double occupancy is 3,690 — nearly 48% higher than the comparable number for Disney Fantasy. Packing in more people on a similarly sized ship is one of the key ways Carnival keeps it price point low. Another way is by keeping tight controls on staffing. Carnival Breeze sails with a staff of 1,386 — 72 fewer than Disney Fantasy. The result: A crew-to-passenger ratio, based on total occupancy, of about 1 to 3.5 for Carnival Breeze versus 1 to 3.2 for Disney Fantasy.

Comparing crew-to-passenger ratios on ships can offer a rough guide to their service levels, though there are caveats to this approach. A significant chunk of the extra staff on Disney Fantasy are involved in the ship's entertainment program, which is far more elaborate. It doesn't necessarily mean Disney is devoting more staff to service positions in restaurants, bars and other areas. Meanwhile, of the three vessels in the comparison, it is Harmony of the Seas — the ship with, by far, the highest passenger capacity — which boasts the best crew-to-passenger ratio. While the ship can sail with up to 6,687 people, it operates with 2,200 crew. That gives it a crew-to-passenger ratio, based on total occupancy, of around 1 to 3.

Related: Which cruise brand is best for you?

Destinations and private islands

As noted above, our pricing comparison for the ships assumes an Eastern Caribbean itinerary out of Port Canaveral, Florida. While roughly similar, the routings that each of the vessels take are not identical:

• Carnival Breeze stops at Amber Cove, Dominican Republic; St. Thomas, U.S. Virgin Islands; San Juan, Puerto Rico; and Grand Turk in the Turks & Caicos.
• Harmony of the Seas also visits San Juan, but substitutes St. Kitts and Royal Caribbean's private island in the Bahamas, Perfect Day at CocoCay , for the other ports.
• Like Carnival Breeze, Disney Fantasy heads to St. Thomas, but combines it with visits to Tortola in the British Virgin Islands and Disney's private island in the Bahamas, Castaway Cay.

When it comes to private islands, Royal Caribbean's Perfect Day is the most elaborate by far. The line is just finishing a $200 million overhaul of the getaway that has brought a major waterpark with 13 waterslides, including the tallest one in North America; the Caribbean's largest freshwater pool; the Caribbean's largest wave pool and a balloon ride that takes you up 450 feet above the island. There's also an exclusive — and expensive — private beach club coming in December.

Related: Best Cruise Line Private Islands for Families

Disney's Castaway Cay is more of a traditional cruise line private island with beach areas (snorkels, tubes and floats are available for rent), a small floating waterslide complex and games such as volleyball. You also can rent bikes for a bit of exploring around the island. Paddleboards, kayaks and aquabikes are also available.

While Carnival doesn't have a private island of its own, two of the stops on Carnival Breeze's itinerary are private port developments built by its parent company that come with their own pool areas and more. The 25-acre Amber Cove development has a sprawling pool with a swim-up bar, waterslides, zip lines and private cabanas as well as bars, restaurants and shops. The 18-acre Grand Turk Cruise Center complex has its own pool area, beach areas and cabanas as well as bars, restaurants and shops.

Bottom line

I've sailed on all these lines many times over the years, and they all offer a lot for families. Which one is right for you? The answer depends on a number of factors specific to you and your family: your budget, the ages of your kids, their personalities and interests in specific activities and the destinations that you hope to see.

For those on a tight budget, Carnival is hard to beat — as the pricing comparison above makes clear. But if you have a little more wiggle room with your pocketbook, there are good arguments for paying up for a week with Royal Caribbean or Disney. When it comes to the quality of service, entertainment and dining, it's a little bit of "you get what you pay for" with the lines.

As noted above, you'll find a higher ratio of crew-to-passengers on Royal Caribbean and Disney ships, and all those extra crew members do make a difference in the experience. The difference is particularly notable when it comes to entertainment offerings, with both Royal Caribbean and Disney fielding much more elaborate shows with bigger casts and name-brand stories. Royal Caribbean's Harmony of the Seas, for instance, features a 90-minute adaptation of one of Broadway's biggest crowd-pleasers, "Grease," in a soaring theater that puts many on Broadway to shame, plus an outdoor "aquatheater" that's home to dazzling aerial performances. Disney's ships are chock full of Disney-themed entertainment that wins kudos for its high production values.

With its greater number of "older kid" amusements, such as surfing pools and rock-climbing walls, Harmony of the Seas is a particularly good choice for families with teens. Disney ships, like many of the Disney parks, aim younger with their attractions and are probably best when your kids are in the 6- to 12-year-old range. Just remember that you're paying a hefty "Disney premium" to get on board. If you're a big Disney fan, it makes sense. If you're not, it probably doesn't.

Is your family thinking about a cruise vacation? Here are some more insights:

• These Are the Best Cruise Lines for 2019
• Interesting Way to Save Money on a Disney Cruise
• Are River Cruises Right for Kids?
• An Overview of Cruise Line Loyalty Programs

Gene Sloan has written about cruising for more than 25 years and for many years oversaw USA TODAY's award-winning cruise site, USA TODAY Cruises. He's sailed on nearly 150 ships.

Featured graphic by Abbie Winters

Disney Cruise Mom Blog

I am a mom who loves all things Disney, but especially Disney Cruises! I enjoy sharing everything I have learned and hope that it will help others plan their own vacations.

Disney Cruise Line vs. Royal Caribbean in Alaska

July 31, 2019 by Disney Cruise Mom 3 Comments

Today I am excited to share with you a guest blogger who recently sailed to Alaska on Royal Caribbean! I met Jody and her family on our Fantasy cruise last fall  where we kept running into each other over and over.  First, it was on our flight to Orlando (I don’t remember seeing them, but my husband does).  Then, we officially met standing in line for a bathroom on a tiny island the day that we stopped in Tortola  when we were eating lunch at the same restaurant. After that we ran into them several more times, and finally we were seated near each other on the flight home after the cruise and had lots of time to talk during the LONG wait at baggage claim.

Jody is just as big of a DCL fan as me (and has sailed on all 4 ships), but she is also a travel agent with much more knowledge of the other cruise lines than me.  So, when I found out that she was cruising on RCCL (for the first time!) to Alaska, I couldn’t wait to hear her thoughts about how it compared to DCL. She was kind enough to write a very detailed report of how the two cruise lines compare (for her particular cruise, of course) on pretty much every subject. Here are Jody’s thoughts:

As veteran Disney cruisers, we decided to “cheat” this time and sail on Royal Caribbean to Alaska. This was an extended family vacation with older cousins and a handful of adults, so the published activity options onboard Royal Caribbean were attractive to our larger group – more so than Disney and characters. As a travel agent, this was also my chance to take notes and, well, compare the two cruise lines.

Our ship, Ovation of the Seas , was an exciting opportunity for us – it is slightly larger than the Disney Fantasy & Dream, boasting large windows and spaces to view Alaska’s amazing vistas.  It was launched in February 2016 and sailing its very first season in Alaska from May through September (then heading back to the South Pacific for down-under travels from Auckland to Dusky Sound, September through April).

Before we get to the comparisons, here are some details from our cruise:

We sailed roundtrip from Seattle, which was a wonderful experience! We enjoyed two full days in Seattle visiting Pike Place Market, the iconic Space Needle, Boeing’s Museum of Flight (a real highlight with the visiting Apollo 11 exhibit through 9/2/19), and nibbling on some unforgettable eats… pastries from Peroshky Peroshky (a Russian bakery with a line out the door and sugary scents to die for!), decadent sipping chocolate from JOE, drip coffee from the original Starbucks in Pike Place, seafood and produce fresh from the Market, and more.  

Our 7-night cruise itinerary was as follows:

Endicott Arm/Dawes Glacier (cruising day)

Victoria, British Columbia  

Seattle  

I’ve heard time and again that cruising to Alaska is all about the destination – the unique ports and unforgettable scenery – and not so much about the ship. The destinations we visited were some of the most beautiful places I’ve ever seen, so I believe this to be true.  But, I also think the ship must be taken into account when you’re sailing on it for 7 nights with 3 full days at sea. So, while I will focus on the key differences our family experienced between Disney and Royal Caribbean, I can’t help but share details of our amazing activities in Alaskan and Canadian ports!    

The very names of the waterways, port towns and experiences of the Alaska Panhandle (the broad region of islands, mountains and saltwater also known as Southeast Alaska) evoke legend. This is Alaska’s famed Inside Passage , about 500 miles long and 100 miles wide. Branches of the Inside Passage connect waterside communities including Ketchikan, Wrangell, Petersburg, Sitka, Juneau, Gustavus and Skagway. Fascinating fact: these communities are not connected to each other by roads! Skilled captains carefully navigate vessels of all sizes from fishing boats to our massive cruise ships, challenged by complex island groups along the way. Our cruise focused on this area of Alaska, visiting the ports listed above. Some cruises sail one way North to South or South to North along Alaska’s coastline (typically you fly into Anchorage or Seward, and sometimes Vancouver). And, unless you separately book an amazing multi-night land package of Alaska through your travel agent in addition to your cruise (often called CruiseTours or Adventures by Disney), you will only be seeing the southeast coast/tip of Alaska, not the interior of the state. For many families, the cruise is sufficient due to the budget and time invested.

Quick thoughts on our ports:

Our 3-hr roundtrip Whale Watch with Dolphin Jet Tours was amazing! The amount of information we learned about whales from this all-girl crew and witnessing whales breach to display their huge tails was unforgettable.

SEE Mendenhall Glacier (and if you can hike to walk on it, do it!)

Plan a helicopter ride over multiple glaciers and walk on them!

Tracy’s Crab Shack  is yummy and the line moves fast. Not a fan of crab legs? The crab bisque, mini crab cakes and butter rolls were to die for.  

Skagway (my favorite port)

Be sure to walk through downtown Skagway , a 10 min walk from the ship.

Purchase the Skagway Street Car Tour excursion: a captivating, storied tour through town with a colorful guide! This was one of the best 1.5 hrs we spent.

The White Pass Scenic Railway that follows the trail of the historic gold rush through Yukon Valley  in the late 1800s (our train ride was 3 hours roundtrip).

Rent a Jeep and drive up the Klondike Highway to Yukon Territory (bring your passports!) to see breathtaking scenery and wildlife.

Have a beer at one of the breweries dotting the marina.

Endicott Arm/Dawes Glacier

(you do not leave the ship this day – just scenic viewing)

Get up EARLY!  We were coming upon Dawes Glacier just after 8:00 am.

The water has a distinct blue-green cast, easily captured in photos. This is due to glacial sediment deposits and long hours of daylight during the summer feeding tiny organisms called plankton. These, in turn, support increasingly larger organisms up the food chain (eventually humpback whales) in the nutrient-rich waters. The abundance of phytoplankton is what gives the water its blueish-green cast.

Have a good pair of binoculars and a GOOD camera. You’ll see seals in the water (and resting on icebergs), waterfalls, and even mountain goats!

Victoria, British Columbia

Butchart Gardens – Victoria’s main attraction and for good reason – lush, colorful, unbelievably beautiful!

Beacon Hill Children’s Farm – A fun petting zoo for kids, don’t need more than a ½ hour there but super cute and very close to the port.

Parliament Building – A great photo op!

The Empress Hotel for high tea – We didn’t have a chance to do this but is a popular activity in Victoria.

Fisherman’s Wharf – Popular for tourists and locals with snack shacks and unique floating homes.

Victoria’s Chinatown – A real highlight for us visiting historical Fan Tan Alley and enjoying lunch at Bao (bao buns and ramen!)

Now, the question most people are probably most curious about:  How Did Royal Caribbean compare to Disney Cruise Line, in our experience?

As with any review, it’s 100% subjective. It depends on what your priorities are and pretty much how you view the world around you. My notes below are also limited to our experience on the Ovation of the Seas (the only Royal Caribbean ship we’ve sailed to date), along with a Carnival cruise to Central America back in 2003. Having sailed all 4 Disney ships multiple times, I am a HUGE FAN of Disney Cruise Line, and it’s through this lens that I critique. Having not sailed to Alaska on Disney, this isn’t an apples to apples comparison.  I’ve been intrigued for some time by Royal Caribbean’s advertising and travel agent marketing & communications, so I was excited to try something new! Remember this is entirely my opinion, everyone tends to have different experiences, and life is all about trying new things!

NOTE:  As of September 2019, DCL has removed the onboard credit from the onboard booking benefits mentioned above.  Now, the only benefits are a 10% discount on base cruise fare and 10% deposit on cruises of 7+ nights (vs. the standard 20%).

Overall, I can’t say that Disney is “better” than Royal Caribbean, or vice versa. It’s really just DIFFERENT. And isn’t life all about seeing new places and embracing differences?  

My family will be booking another Alaskan cruise, and next time we definitely want to visit Sitka and Ketchikan. I would also like to experience Vancouver, British Columbia. Whether we sail Disney, Royal Caribbean again, or even Norwegian Cruise Line, we are excited to be led into territories with unmatched views and exciting experiences.  

At the end of the day, Alaska never disappoints.

From Jody’s very first Disney cruise years ago, she was smitten. Disembarking the ship to claim luggage in the port, she put on her sunglasses to hide tears! That’s when she knew – Disney created vacation magic like no other – and she simply didn’t want it to end.  Jody is a full-service travel consultant specializing in family and luxury travel, including:  

Everything Disney:   Walt Disney World, Disney Cruise Line, Disneyland, Adventures by Disney, Disneyland Paris, and Aulani Resort in Hawaii

Universal (Orlando and Hollywood)

Cruise Lines – larger ships and small luxury lines

Sandals and Beaches Resorts

Caribbean vacation packages at all-inclusive and non-all-inclusive resorts  

With a B.S. from Syracuse University, Jody is also a graduate of the College of Disney Knowledge, Royal Caribbean University (with a Master of Adventure), Norwegian Cruise Line University, and is a Certified Sandals/Beaches Specialist. She keeps up with ALL destinations and new itinerary strategies, and makes it her mission to stay on top of promotions that will earn you the most for your vacation dollar. Whether you prefer the East or West coast, the crystal waters of the Caribbean, or a cruise on an ocean liner, Jody’s attention to detail and white-glove approach to planning will create a special experience just for your family.  With a Mouseketeer of her own, she fully understands the intense amount of detail and time involved in planning a family vacation (particularly for Disney – which truly can be overwhelming). Jody is also a group fitness instructor of Les Mills formats BodyPump and BodyFlow. She lives in Raleigh, NC with her husband (Dana), their well-traveled daughter, (Lily, 8), and their two cats, Grady & Rosie. Jody LOVES talking travel and looks forward to helping you plan your adventure!

Email:   [email protected]

Web:   www.JodyatGoMickeyTravel.com

Phone:   (919) 673-8340

Facebook:   https://www.facebook.com/JodyatGoMickeyTravel/  

Instagram:   https://www.instagram.com/jodyatgomickeytravel/

August 2, 2019 at 3:55 pm

$50 per person for the whole week for the drinks package is a wonderful deal. I thought it was usually that much per day.

December 12, 2019 at 2:25 pm

What was the cost difference if you don’t mind me asking? Did you compare prior to booking?

December 12, 2019 at 3:39 pm

Hi Cristina! I can’t speak for Jody and whether she compared prices or not, but I did a quick comparison between DCL and RCCL prices for Alaska this summer. For the 6/22 sailing on Disney, the prices for a 7 night Alaska cruise from Vancouver, for 2 adults, are $4924 (interior), $6128 (ocean view), and $9180 (verandah). For the 6/21 sailing on RCCL, also a 7 night from Vancouver for 2 adults, the prices are $2550 (interior), $3008 (ocean view), and $5044 (verandah). I hope this helps!

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

To view the Disney Cruise Mom Blog privacy policy, click here .

©Disney Cruise Mom Blog 2020. All Rights Reserved. Disneycruisemomblog does not claim to represent, is not affiliated with, endorsed by or officially connected with Magical Cruise Company, Limited, dba Disney Cruise Line, or their parent company, The Walt Disney Company.

Weddings? Burials at sea? Unexpected things you can do on a cruise ship besides cruising

When thinking of a cruise , we generally imagine sailing away for a relaxing vacation of sun and fun. Lots of food, perhaps a drink with an umbrella in it and the magnificent ocean.

We're lucky in Florida, home to some of the world's busiest cruise ports including PortMiami, Port Canaveral , Port Everglades, Port Tampa Bay, JAXPORT, and Port of Palm Beach. There is also a port in Key West, but this is mainly used for cruise ship calls rather than a homeport.

Most people know cruises offer a great value and are nearly all-inclusive with good food , accommodations and entertainment. Add to that exotic ports of call and shore excursions that strike all fancies, from beach bums to adrenaline junkies.

But there are some lesser-known accommodations available on most cruise ships .

From joyous occasions to celebrations of life, here are some extraordinary services cruise ships offer.

You can get married on a cruise ship

Want to say "I do" onboard a majestic ship or at an exotic location?

You can do that on a cruise ship and be on your honeymoon at the same time.

Many cruise lines, including Disney Cruise Lines , Carnival and Royal Caribbean , offer weddings and wedding renewals aboard the ship or at scenic tropical locations.

Your guests don't even have to cruise with you.

For example, 50 non-sailing guests can take part in weddings aboard Carnival Cruise Line ships before the cruise sails from the port of embarkation.

Royal Caribbean allows for 75 of 150 wedding guests to be non-sailing. NCL permits up to 10 non-sailing guests free of charge, but a reception must be booked if you have up to 50 guests who are not sailing.

Check with your cruise line for availability and details.

Burial at sea: Scattering a loved one's ashes from a cruise ship

A loved one's remains can be buried at sea during a cruise.

Several cruise lines allow for the scattering of cremated remains from their ships, provided the guest can produce the decedent's death and cremation certificates.

The remains are generally required to be in a biodegradable urn and some cruise lines require the entire urn to be tossed into the sea.

Cruise lines work with guests to determine burial time and place. Guests are usually taken to a more secluded part of the ship and given privacy for scattering the remains.

Contact your cruise line before boarding for availability and policies.

Cruise ships have jails. Can you get arrested on a cruise ship?

While there are a lot of perks for traveling via cruise ship, there are some facilities available on most cruise ships that may surprise you.

For example, many cruise ships have a small jail, called a brig. The brig is generally located on one of the bottom decks.

Misbehavior or breaking the law on a cruise ship can see you confined to your cabin or locked up in the brig.

Do cruise ships have hospitals?

Most cruise ships sailing from U.S. ports have medical facilities, including a doctor, on board to treat minor illnesses and injuries, and to stabilize patients with more serious health issues until they can be transferred to land-based facilities.

While available, medical care on a cruise ship is not free . Your land-based health insurance is generally not accepted on board and medical service fees are charged to your sailing account.

Your health insurance may not cover you while you're on the ship and out of the country. Check with your provider before boarding and look into travel health insurance for concerns over recouping any out-of-pocket costs.

Is there a morgue on cruise ships?

Morbidly, yes, there's a morgue on board. It's legally required , according to Readers Digest .

In case of a death, the body is stored in the morgue until it can be transferred off the ship.

Support local journalism by  subscribing to a Florida news organization .

Luxury Cruising

The very latest cruise deals from all lines

Disney Cruise Vs Royal Caribbean: Which Is Best?

• March 14, 2024
• No Comments

Royal Caribbean is arguably the biggest cruise line in the world, while Disney is arguably one of the biggest companies in the world full-stop. They’re two giants of the cruise industry – but how do they compare when you put them side-by-side?

There’s a lot that the two cruise lines share, but even more that separates them too, and if you’re planning a cruise then it’s good to see what makes each of these cruise lines unique so that you can make the right choice for your family.

I’ve sailed on two Disney ships ( Disney Wish and Disney Magic ) and three with Royal Caribbean (Allure of the Seas, Mariner of the Seas and Anthem of the Seas) so as well as the factual differences, I’ll share my own experiences too.

So let’s take a look!

One of the biggest differences between the two cruise lines is the size of their respective fleets.

Disney has just five ships , with three more currently under construction ( Disney Treasure , Disney Adventure and one yet to be named).

Royal Caribbean has a huge mammoth fleet of 27 ships , with another three on the way for now ( Utopia of the Seas , Star of the Seas and one TBC).

Disney Cruise Line Ships

There are currently three classes of ship in the Disney fleet:

• Triton Class – the biggest ships for Disney, accommodating a maximum of 4,000 guests
• Dream Class – two ships that can accommodate 4,000 guests
• Magic Class – two ships that can accommodate 2,700 guests

A fourth class is on the way, currently named the Global Class though this may change. Disney Adventure will be the first of these, capable of hosting up to 6,000 guests.

Read more: Disney Cruise Line Ships By Age

Royal Caribbean Ships

Royal’s ships all fall into one of eight classes:

• Icon Class – the biggest cruise ships in the world accommodating up to 7,600 guests
• Oasis Class – six mega ships that can accommodate around 6,800 guests
• Quantum Ultra Class – two modern ships accommodating 5,500 guests
• Quantum Class – three ships accommodating 4,900 guests
• Freedom Class – three ships accommodating 4,400 to 4,900 guests
• Radiance Class – four ships accommodating 2,500 guests
• Voyager Class – five ships accommodating 4,000 guests
• Vision Class – four ships accommodating 2,400 to 2,700 guests

The oldest ship in the fleet is the Grandeur of the Seas, part of the Vision Class. She was built in 1996. The newest ship launched in January 2024 and is Icon of the Seas, the biggest ship in the world .

Read more: Royal Caribbean Ships By Age

Which to Choose?

While the size of the fleets for each cruise line is very different, it shouldn’t influence your choice of cruise line too much as this stage. 

Disney’s fleet includes ships similar to Royal’s smallest and to many of Royal’s larger ships – it’s only the Oasis Class and Icon Class that really stand out, so if you want to experience the biggest ships in the world then Royal Caribbean would be the way to go.

• Destinations

Both cruise lines sail to a range of destinations, although Royal Caribbean certainly has more variety – helped with the size of the fleet. Understandably, the Caribbean is the key destination for both cruise lines, though both offer a range of European cruises too.

Disney Cruise Line Destinations

Disney’s range of destinations is more limited than with other cruise lines, but if you want to cruise to the Caribbean or Bahamas then you certainly won’t struggle to find a date to suit you!

The cruise line has 15 embarkation ports around the world, with around half of all cruises departing from Port Canaveral – understandable considering the close proximity to Disney World, with many guests choosing a cruise and stay vacation that incorporates a cruise and a trip to the theme parks.

A limited selection of cruises are available from Southampton for UK guests.

Disney has two private resorts in the region for cruise guests, including Castaway Cay and the new Lighthouse Point , due to open in 2024.

Royal Caribbean Destinations

Royal Caribbean sails from 35 embarkation ports around the world, giving guests plenty of choice when it comes to their cruise departure point. 14 of these are based in North America, while there is always a ship based in Southampton during the summer months – in 2024 it’s Anthem of the Seas, while Independence of the Seas returns to the UK for 2025.

Royal Caribbean also has private resorts, including Perfect Day at CocoCay, offering guests a wealth of fun activities to enjoy ashore.

Royal Caribbean has more variety when it comes to destinations, so if you wanted to try a cruise to the Middle East, to Asia, through the Panama Canal or to Canada & New England, then you’d want to pick Royal Caribbean.

But if you’re looking for the more popular destinations in the Caribbean and Europe, it’s a much tougher decision. Both Castaway Cay and CocoCay are excellent private resorts, so it may come down to finding a date and sailing length that suits you.

Staterooms and Suites

Once you’ve settled on a cruise line, one of the biggest decisions becomes which stateroom you want to book. So it’s natural that this should form part of your decision when choosing a cruise line, too.

As you’d expect, both Disney Cruise Line and Royal Caribbean offer the ‘standard’ range of accommodation options. If you want to save money, you can choose an Inside cabin, or if you want to see the ocean you can choose an Ocean View or Balcony Stateroom, or a Suite.

One key difference is in solo rooms – Royal Caribbean has a limited selection, but you won’t find specialist solo rooms on a Disney ship. It’s not a cruise line aimed at the solo traveller. You can sail alone, but you’ll be in a regular stateroom and you’ll pay for two guests.

Let’s look at some of the specialist accommodation options on each cruise line:

Disney Cruise Line Staterooms and Suites

Split bathroom staterooms.

The majority of cabins on Disney cruise ships have split bathrooms – this means they have a separate toilet and shower room, rather than one bathroom with everything in. If you’re a family, you’ll know how valuable this is – being able to have a shower with your little one bursting in for a surprise toilet visit is a luxury on a cruise ship!

Magical Porthole Staterooms

Some Inside cabins on Disney cruise ships have a ‘Magical Porthole’. This is a fake porthole that has a live view of the outside of the ship, so you can at least see whether it’s daytime or not.

But even better, the screen will occasionally have character visits, such as Scuttle and Flounder from The Little Mermaid. It’s a nice touch and one that the kids will love.

Deluxe Family Rooms

On most cruise ships, if you want to book five guests in one cabin, you’ll need to book a suite. But on Disney ships, it is possible to book a stateroom with space for five guests, so you don’t have to split your party between two connecting rooms. Worth considering when we get onto the prices later…

Concierge Staterooms & Suites

Concierge is a premium category of staterooms and suites across the Disney fleet. You’ll get a list of extra perks , including priority boarding, free WiFi, and access to the Concierge Lounge and Concierge Sundeck. The best Concierge Tower Suites are even located in the ship’s funnel, which is very exciting!

Royal Caribbean Staterooms and Suites

Virtual balcony staterooms.

Similar to Disney, you can book an Inside room with Royal Caribbean and still get a view thanks to Virtual Balconies, which are on the Icon Class, select Oasis Class, and Quantum Class ships. These are much larger screens, taking up a wall rather than a small porthole, but you don’t get the Disney character visits, just the live view of the ocean.

Interior Balcony Staterooms

The Oasis Class and Icon Class have the option of Interior Balcony staterooms. These are balcony cabins, but rather than facing the ocean, they face in the inside of the ship, overlooking the Boardwalk or Central Park. It’s a cheaper way to enjoy a balcony, but it does mean you’re facing another balcony opposite, so there is less privacy.

AquaTheater Suites

Some of the coolest suite options on any ship, the AquaTheater Suites on Oasis-class ships have a direct view over the AquaTheater at the aft of the ship, letting you relax on your balcony with an amazing show performed by incredible acrobats each night.

Hardly cheap, these suites are also very spacious. But they aren’t the biggest and best…

Ultimate Family Accommodations

Some of the Oasis-class ships, and the Icon-class ships, have either Ultimate Family Suites or Ultimate Family Townhouse accommodations. These are the best family suites at sea, including a host of features to keep kids entertained including piano staircases, slides between floors, games consoles, karaoke and a whole host more. But for £20,000 per person, per week you’d expect something special.

Both Disney Cruise Line and Royal Caribbean have great accommodation options. Royal Caribbean’s are more unique and innovative but you’ll pay an additional premium for those options – Disney’s cruises might be expensive but even a regular stateroom has a lot going for it.

Another big part of cruising is the food, and the two cruise lines offer a very different dining experience.

Disney Cruise Line Food

On a Disney cruise ship, there isn’t just one main dining restaurant. Instead, there are three themed dining rooms, and you’ll rotate between them during your cruise so that you (and all other guests) can try them all, and experience the different entertainment during them.

Some restaurants have live shows that happen around your dinner, so it’s a lot more fun and family-oriented than a typical dining room.

Your waiter will remain the same throughout, so they can offer you the best experience as they learn your preferences, and it’s a good way of improving the variety of your complimentary dining.

There are speciality restaurants you can choose too, if you prefer, but there aren’t too many on each ship. And you can always stick to the buffet if that’s more your thing.

Royal Caribbean Food

On a Royal Caribbean ship, it’s all about variety – there are so many restaurant options to choose from that you’ll likely struggle to fit them all into a single voyage, so you’re going to have to pick favourites.

There is the traditional Main Dining Room where you can either enjoy set dining or opt for My Time Dining , where you can show up whenever you prefer (though you do need to prepay tips if you want this option). There’s a buffet too, and then several casual restaurants where you can grab sandwiches or pizza.

But it’s the choice of speciality restaurants where Royal Caribbean outshines Disney. Whatever type of cuisine you want, you’ll likely find it on a Royal ship, though you will have to pay a set fee. 

In the simplest terms, if your priority is trying lots of different cuisines, you’ll probably find a better variety of restaurants on a Royal Caribbean ship.

But if your priority is more around making sure the kids have an amazing dining experience, they’ll probably prefer the main dining rooms of a Disney ship, with all the entertainment they come with.

Onboard Activities

It’s impossible to be bored on either a Disney or Royal Caribbean ship. Let’s look at why.

Disney Cruise Line Activities

Disney ships are packed with fun things to do for kids and adults alike. The highlight on the Triton-class ships is the AquaMouse, which is billed as the first ‘Disney Attraction at Sea’ – essentially it’s a water coaster with a story, just like the rides you’d find at a Disney park.

Other attractions include:

• Water slides
• Splash zones
• Sport courts
• Spa and salon treatments

It may not seem like a long list, but that’s because so many of the features of the ships come in the form of entertainment or as part of the kids’ clubs, covered below.

Royal Caribbean Activities

Royal Caribbean is known for offering a huge range of activities that guests can enjoy onboard. Obviously, the bigger ships have more, but even the small ships have a lot of great things to try. Some of the attractions on a Royal Caribbean cruise include:

• Ice skating
• Escape rooms
• FlowRider surfing simulators
• Skydiving simulators
• Rock climbing walls
• Epic dry slides across multiple decks
• Dodgems at sea
• Thrill-seeking water slides
• Bungee trampolines

Royal Caribbean definitely has a wider choice of activities that guests can enjoy, especially for adults. It’s home to some of the most innovative attractions at sea, although the AquaMouse on the latest Disney ships really does showcase that Disney magic touch.

Entertainment

If you love to unwind in the evening, you’ll want to know more about the entertainment that each cruise line offers.

Disney Cruise Line Entertainment

Disney is arguably the king of entertainment, and that shows through on the cruise ships too. The live shows at night offer amazing interpretations of your favourite Disney stories, but there’s lots of entertainment throughout the daytime too, including character meet and greets which your kids will love.

It’s not just theatre shows at night, too. There are themed deck parties, such as Pirate Night, which will have everyone dancing along and singing sea shanties. Plus is it really a Disney holiday if the night doesn’t end with an amazing fireworks display?

Royal Caribbean Entertainment

The entertainment on Royal Caribbean is tailored more towards adults than kids, although guests of all ages should find something to enjoy. The theatre shows include some amazing Broadway musicals, including Grease, Cats, Hairspray, We Will Rock You, and Mamma Mia. 

There’s also live music played in bars across the ship, and comedy for the grown-ups too.

This really comes down to who takes priority in your travelling party. The kids will absolutely love the live entertainment on a Disney cruise, throughout the day and at night, while there are more grown-up choices on a Royal Caribbean sailing, whether it’s belting out the classics of Queen and Abba or some cheeky comedy sets.

Kids Facilities

Family cruise lines such as Disney and Royal Caribbean have to cater to younger guests – and neither disappoint.

Disney Cruise Line Kids’ Facilities

Disney’s Oceaneer Club and Oceaneer Lab are packed with fun activities for kids aged 3 to 12. The lab is an interactive space filled with games and experiments, while the Club offers lots of Disney-themed entertainment including live character interactions, dress-up and more.

Depending on your ship, kids can take part in special adventures on the Millennium Falcon, or in the Avengers Academy or Marvel Super Hero Academy, or enjoy storytime with Tinkerbell in Pixie Hollow.

Teens have their own spaces, with Edge being aimed at younger teens and Vibe offering a cooler, more grown-up space for 14 to 17-year-olds.

Royal Caribbean Kids’ Facilities

Royal Caribbean’s kids’ clubs aren’t quite as impressive as Disney’s, but your children may not notice the difference, especially if they aren’t big Disney, Marvel or Star Wars fans. There are still separate clubs for different age ranges, and different spaces such as the Adventure Science Lab, the Imagination Studio and an Adventure Theatre.

Teens will love their space too, which also has games consoles and table games, with organised events helping to encourage teenagers to mingle and make new friends for the duration of their cruise.

Disney’s kids clubs are slightly better than Royal Caribbean’s just because of the themed spaces and character interactions that they can offer. If your kid is into one of the big Disney-owned franchises (and the odds are good for most families), they’ll love being immersed in these experiences. 

Yet Royal Caribbean’s facilities for younger guests are far from dull and offer plenty of engaging, educational and fun activities. Good luck tearing them away on either cruise line for family time!

Cruiser Demographics

Here’s how the two cruise lines compare in terms of the typical guests onboard.

Disney Cruise Line Demographic

The vast majority of guests on a Disney cruise will be families with young children – often multigenerational, as the cruises aren’t cheap and the grandparents can often help fund them.

You will find some childless couples on a Disney cruise, if they love everything to do with Mickey Mouse and co, but it’s extremely rare to find solo passengers or friend groups.

Royal Caribbean Demographic

Royal Caribbean has quite a young demographic too, and will have similar-aged families onboard, but you’ll also find adults travelling without children on many cruises, including some older adults, especially on the smaller ships. The average age is between 30 and 50 for guests.

The cost of your cruise will be one of the biggest determining factors for guests unsure on which cruise line to book. So, let’s take a look.

Disney Cruise Line Prices

A Disney cruise is a very authentic Disney experience, and that unfortunately means it comes with the premium prices you’d pay at theme parks or resort hotels owned by the same company. 

Expect to pay between £130/$165 and £240/$300 per person, per night for a cruise in the Caribbean or to Mexico, with European cruises sometimes costing even more than that, depending on the ship.

Read more: How Much is a Disney Cruise?

Royal Caribbean Prices

Royal Caribbean’s cruise prices vary greatly depending on which ship you choose. The biggest ships come with a premium, but you can still get a great deal on a mid-sized ship that still offers plenty of fun.

A 7-night Caribbean cruise on one of the biggest ships, Wonder of the Seas, will cost between £100/$130 and £130/$165 per person, per night. The Icon-class ships will be more expensive, but this is still one of the newest ships in the fleet, bigger than any Disney ship too.

NEW DEALS JUST RELEASED!

Don’t miss these hot cruise offers…

The Verdict

If you’re in the lucky position of being able to afford either a Royal Caribbean or a Disney cruise, then you’ve got a tough decision to make. 

Most people will be drawn to Royal Caribbean because the cruise will be cheaper, but Disney really is magical. There are so many little touches too, and the crew go that extra mile to make you feel special – something that gets a little lost on the super-ships of Royal Caribbean.

Younger families will typically prefer a Disney cruise, but adults who aren’t Disney-mad will likely find Royal Caribbean to be more to their tastes.

Neither is “better” than the other, so if you can’t decide on a cruise line, make your choice based on the cost and the destination, and you’ll have an amazing time I’m sure.

Related Posts:

If you enjoyed this article please share!

Jenni Fielding is the founder of Cruise Mummy. She has worked in the cruise industry since 2015 and has taken over 30 cruises. Now, she helps over 1 million people per month to plan their perfect cruise holidays.

Read more about me

Most Popular

5 Things to Know When Cruising with a Third Person in a Cabin

Carnival Cruise Passengers Try to Sneak Portable Washing Machine onto Ship

Special Offers on Disney Cruise Line Sailings as of April 22, 2024 • The Disney Cruise Line Blog

Cruise Ship Rescues 27 People From Small Boat in Caribbean

The Magazine is the while the lovely valley teems with vapour around me, and the meridian sun strikes the upper surface of the impenetrable foliage of my trees.

RECENT POSTS

5 Things to Know When Cruising with a Th...

Carnival Cruise Passengers Try to Sneak ...

Special Offers on Disney Cruise Line Sai...

Popular posts.

Three Year Cruise Moves Closer to Realit...

Two of Carnival’s Cruise Lines Rel...

• Baby & toddler
• Celebrity Cruises
• Choosing a cruise
• Costa Cruises
• Cruise Lines
• Cruise News
• Cruise Special Offers
• Cruise Tips
• Disney Cruises
• First time cruisers
• Food and drink
• Holland America Line
• Hurtigruten
• Money saving tips
• MSC Cruises
• Norwegian Cruise Line
• P&O Cruises
• Princess Cruises
• River Cruising
• Royal Caribbean
• Uncategorised
• Uncategorized
• Virgin Voyages
• Windstar Cruises

Protect Your Trip »

The 10 best cruises for teens in 2024.

The best cruises for teens provide the right mix of autonomy and time with family.

The Best Cruises for Teens

Amy Smith | Courtesy of Disney Cruise Line

Teen spaces on cruise ships foster friendships through games, music, events and more.

Cruises make the perfect family vacation, especially when traveling with teens. Teens can mix and mingle with others their age in teens-only clubs, play games, listen to music, or grab a pizza and watch a movie under the stars. If your tweens and teens need more action-packed fun to keep them entertained, some cruise ships act like floating amusement parks with zip lines, racetracks, roller coasters, ice skating rinks, laser tag, waterslides and more.

The following lines offer the best cruises for teens and tweens, along with their parents.

Find your perfect cruise

MSC Cruises

Courtesy of MSC Cruises

MSC Cruises offers plenty of family fun and activities for teens on its ships, including sports tournaments, waterslides and a family disco. On select ships, you'll also find the full-size MSC Formula Racer simulator, an interactive XD cinema, a virtual reality experience, zip lines and an arcade room. The Young Club programming by MSC Cruises offers daily activities for 12- to 14-year-old tweens, while teens 15 to 17 can participate in sports and dance competitions as well as video game tournaments at the Teen Club. Older kids can also participate in fun themed events, karaoke, piloting practice at the Drone Academy and flash mobs – and there's a teens-only disco.

On MSC Seascape , teens can stay busy in three new concept spaces. "Future" features a state-of-the-art technology area with the latest-generation consoles, VR and video screens for hours of entertainment. "Chill Out" is just as it sounds – a place to hang out, chat, and play foosball and pingpong. Meanwhile, "Music" is a dance club where kids can choose their own tunes and dance the night away with cool lighting and sound effects. If all that isn't enough, Robotron, the first of its kind at sea, is an amusement park-like ride that combines the thrill of a roller coaster with personalized music and lighting.

MSC World Europa boasts the largest and most engaging kids area in the fleet with an impressive 8,245 square feet of action-packed space. The new Teens Lab features an immersive area for teenagers with more than 20 of the latest consoles, seven VR stations and dozens of video games. Drone Academy 2.0 is a high-energy relay race for drones. There's even more onboard fun at Z Active, a sports program that offers basketball, football and zorb ball alongside two firsts for the line – pickleball and hoverboards. Teens can also take a spin on the bumper cars at the MSC Sportplex.

MSC Euribia – the line's newest ship, which set sail on its inaugural cruise in June 2023 – has a total of 7,500-plus square feet of space dedicated to kids ages 0 to 17. The new Teens Club Extra Space offers three different areas: the Young Club (ages 12 to 14), the Teens Club (15 to 17) and the Teens Lab (12 to 17). Some of the activities include those found on other MSC ships, such as Z Active, Drone Academy 2.0 and the MSC Dance Crew competition. Teens will also have access to new video games; pingpong; World Quest, an interactive game show based on trivia and geography; and Caravaggio, an immersive spy game show about an art heist.

Compare  MSC Cruises on GoToSea , a service of U.S. News.

Norwegian Cruise Line

Courtesy of Norwegian Cruise Line

Norwegian Cruise Line boasts a teens-only venue, Entourage, which caters to young adults 13 to 17 years old. This supervised space – available on 16 of the line's 19 ships – keeps teens busy in an adults-free lounge that's filled with video games, movies, music, arts and sports. Teen counselors on Norwegian Cruise Line plan activities and challenges to keep kids entertained throughout the cruise. A list of detailed activities is available on embarkation day so teens can plan out their schedule for the cruise.

Norwegian Prima , the first vessel in the Prima class, features many first-at-sea innovations perfect for entertaining families and energetic teens, including the three-level Prima Speedway. With cars reaching up to 30 miles per hour, this quarter-mile-long racetrack is one of the highest-rated attractions on Prima. Adventurous teens will also want to check out The Drop and The Rush. Billed as the fastest slides at sea, these chutes offer thrill-seekers a heart-pumping 10-story freefall plunge.

If that's not enough action, teens can also play The Bull's Eye, a classic game of darts that uses a video tracking system, or check out Tee Time for a pumped-up version of mini-golf set against a Las Vegas backdrop. In the Galaxy Pavilion, an indoor gaming complex, you'll find more than a dozen attractions, including immersive simulator experiences, escape rooms and the Topgolf Swing Suite – all of which are unique to Norwegian Prima. When it's time to cool off, the Tidal Wave waterslide is another first for the brand, letting guests ride inner tubes to catch the surf.

Norwegian Viva, the second vessel in the Prima class, is set to launch in August 2023. As the newest ship in NCL's fleet, Viva will also feature these exciting high-tech attractions, including Viva Speedway. If you and your teens are fans of the movie "Beetlejuice," you're in for a treat: The Broadway musical adaptation will debut on the new ship.

The line's Breakaway Plus class – Norwegian Escape , Joy , Bliss and Encore – is also popular with families as these ships offer plenty of activities and attractions suited for active teens, such as go-kart tracks, outdoor laser tag and VR games in the Galaxy Pavilion.

Find  Norwegian Cruise Line deals on GoToSea .

Disney Cruise Line

Courtesy of Disney Cruise Line

Disney Cruise Line features two cool spaces dedicated to teens and tweens, who can hang out on comfy couches, watch shows or movies, and play video games. These hangouts, called Edge (for ages 11 to 14) and Vibe (ages 14 to 17), are available on all Disney Cruise Line ships.

On Disney Fantasy and Disney Dream , the space at Vibe also features a private outdoor deck with chaise lounges, wading pools, foosball and more. While indoors, teenagers can mingle with others their age, or just kick back and relax in individual nooks. There's a dance club area for karaoke contests, talent shows and dance competitions. The trendy indoor-outdoor space – at almost 9,000 square feet – is accessible with a teens-only card or DisneyBand+. On the new Disney Wish ship, Vibe has a French twist inspired by a Paris artist's loft with neon signs and funk pop art.

For tweens sailing on Disney Fantasy or Dream, Edge is a bright, loft-style gathering spot – located in the funnel – that has individual computer stations for gaming and a massive video wall for screening television, movies and games. There's also a lit-up dance floor for dance parties. Two nifty features of the space – and its location – are views of the pool decks below as well as three portholes that allow for glimpses of the riders on the water coaster, AquaDuck, as they zoom by.

On the first night of the cruise, kids receive information on what activities and events will be available during their vacation so they can curate a personalized entertainment itinerary. Some fun options throughout the week may include "Gotcha," a game of elimination where one teen will become the ultimate victor. For a special treat – and a bit of pampering – guests ages 13 to 17 won't want to miss an afternoon at Chill Spa, located inside Senses Spa & Salon.

Book a  Disney cruise on GoToSea .

Royal Caribbean International

Michel Verdure | Courtesy of Royal Caribbean International

The newly updated space for teens 13 to 17 years old on Royal Caribbean International vessels is hidden behind a secret speakeasy entrance. The dedicated venue, which has a gaming lounge and music, is a cozy place to hang out to meet other teens on the ship. There's also an outdoor patio where you can relax in the sun or chill out under the stars. Teens will find planned activities throughout the day at the lounge, including sports tournaments, a nightly teen disco and themed parties.

Social 100 is an exclusive new space for ages 13 to 17 on Wonder of the Seas . The outdoor space sits next to the waterslides and boasts a hot tub, lawn games, cozy seating, a selfie area, and a bar serving zero-proof cocktails and shakes. The indoor part of Social 100 features a gaming area, foosball tables, a vending machine and more comfortable spaces for teens to mingle.

Teens have plenty of activities they can do with their families on Royal Caribbean's ships, especially on the new Icon of the Seas, the first vessel in the Icon class. Slated for its inaugural sailing in January 2024, Wonder of the Seas will be the  world's largest cruise ship .  Cruisers of all ages will have endless opportunities for fun with more venues, activities and attractions than you've ever seen on a cruise ship.

Teens and their parents will appreciate Chill Island, a three-level pool deck with the first swim-up bar at sea. The new water park, Thrill Island, boasts six waterslides, including exciting firsts at sea, such as Pressure Drop, the first open freefall slide. If that's not enough to get the adrenaline pumping, teens can check out Crown's Edge – a combination thrill ride, skywalk and ropes course – or other Royal Caribbean favorites like Adrenaline Peak, Sports Court, the FlowRider surf simulator or the reimagined mini-golf course.

If you're hanging out in the new Surfside neighborhood on Icon, a dedicated space for young families, teens will have easy access to the supervised teens-only club, Social 020, from this open-air space.

When you head ashore to Perfect Day in CocoCay, one of the best  cruise line private islands , teen cruisers will find plenty of fun land-based activities like Thrill Waterpark and 1,600-foot-long zip lines. Be sure not to miss another thrilling experience: Up, Up and Away. The helium balloon ride soars 450 feet above the ground to the highest vantage point in the Bahamas , offering incredible panoramic views of the island and surrounding turquoise waters.

Explore  Royal Caribbean cruises on GoToSea . 

Holland America Line

Michel Verdure | Courtesy of Holland America Line

The Kids Club on Holland America Line offers a fun supervised program for 13- to 17-year-old guests in an adult-free zone known as The Loft. The name is in the process of changing to High Score!, and you'll already find the updated concept on Oosterdam and Eurodam . The line's other ships will change over to the new venue throughout 2024. High Score! is a family game room that serves as a secret getaway for teens by day. In the evenings, entire families can come to play skeeball, board games and join in other activities.

The teens-only space (during the day) on Holland America Line resembles a New York artists loft where kids can listen to music, watch movies, play games and meet and hang out with same-age cruisers. Programs and activities at the current space, The Loft, include themed events, karaoke, a teen disco and nighttime activities such as Poker Night and video game tournaments. Youths can also participate in pingpong, basketball and other teens-only sporting events. If they still need more entertainment to keep them busy, the Kids Club offers origami lessons and watercolor painting as well as competitions in "Mario Kart," air hockey, foosball, pinball and more.

The Kids Club is complimentary for guests. The space is open daily, and you'll also find teen events around the ship. When it comes to dining, there are many teen-friendly dining options – where teens can even enjoy mocktails like nonalcoholic mojitos – at venues throughout the ship.

If you're cruising to Alaska with Holland America or other adventure-filled destinations, look for excursions that will appeal to younger family members like zip lining tours, trail hikes, float trips, helicopter tours and wilderness safaris. Alaska is a teen favorite, especially in Skagway (one of Alaska's top destinations ), where travelers can get a thrill out of dog mushing with a team of Alaskan huskies, taking a ride on the White Pass & Yukon Route Railroad, or going on a rock climbing excursion.

Find  Holland America Line cruises on GoToSea .

Tips on Trips and Expert Picks

Travel tips, vacation ideas and more to make your next vacation stellar.

Princess Cruises

Courtesy of Princess Cruises

The modern Beach House lounge is the go-to place for passengers ages 13 to 17 to socialize and meet others their age when sailing on a Princess Cruises ship. Fun activities for teens include late-night movies and tournaments where they can challenge their peers in video games or at air hockey, foosball and table tennis. For more energetic activities, join in the fun during indoor dodgeball and basketball games. Or, learn new dance moves from some of the dancers in the crew, then hit the dance floor for one of the competitions. At the "Rock the Boat Party," teenagers can dress up and party the night away with mocktails and new friends on the ship.

"Movies Under the Stars" is one of Princess' signature events. Guests can watch movies, sporting events and concerts while bundled up with cozy blankets on the pool deck outdoors. Teens will enjoy the complimentary snacks – not to mention the special movie nights designed with them in mind, such as "Scary Movie Night." You might even find teen makeovers and glitter tattoos some evenings on the ship.

The line's three newest ships – Discovery Princess , Enchanted Princess and Sky Princess – offer the most activities for teens, but all of the ships in the fleet host youth programs in partnership with Discovery, along with plenty of other family-friendly activities. These offerings include Discovery Family and Animal Planet shore excursions and onboard entertainment like "The Voice of the Ocean," a musical competition.

Parents will be able to keep track of their busy teens anywhere on the ship with the state-of-the-art Princess MedallionClass system. The quarter-size wearable medallion and accompanying app allow guests to personalize their itinerary and locate family members and friends on board.

When Sun Princess launches in February 2024, as the first vessel in the line's Sphere class, it will feature Park19. This top-deck family activity zone boasts many outdoor adventures, including Sea Breeze – the first Rollglider at sea. The ADA-accessible seated ride offers a hang-gliding experience with panoramic views of the ocean and ports of call. Families and teens can also check out the climbing obstacle course, cargo nets and lookout points. The ship also has a recreational court – which offers pingpong, shuffleboard, fitness classes and more – and a splash zone where you can cool off after all the outdoor activities.

Inside Sun Princess, tweens and teens will find two centers just for them: Neon Grove and The Underground. Both spaces offer cozy and colorful areas for young adults to hang out, socialize, and play video games on the PlayStation 5 and Nintendo Switch. They'll also find foosball, skeeball and air hockey on top of planned activities like movie nights, dance parties and scavenger hunts.

Explore  Princess Cruises on GoToSea .

Adventures by Disney

Adventures by Disney offers river and expedition cruises for the whole family; the itineraries span many choices and experiences for tweens and teens with a focus on culture, history, gastronomy and adventure. The river cruises are operated in partnership with AmaWaterways, while the expedition cruises are a collaboration with luxury French cruise line Ponant.

If you're sailing on the Adventures by Disney Rhine River Cruise itinerary, for example, guests can choose between various exciting excursions. While you're docked in Strasbourg, France , for the day, teen-friendly options include a tour of the Black Forest, complete with a toboggan run and a visit to a woodworking museum. Another choice here is to visit Germany's Europa-Park, a one-of-a-kind theme park located between the Black Forest and the Vosges Mountains. In Melk, Austria, on the Danube itinerary, families can go for a bike ride along the Danube River, hike to the castle in Dürnstein or visit a family-run apricot farm.

Another great feature of these cruises is that teens can opt to have dinner and evening get-togethers with same-age cruisers, so they don't have to dine with their parents or younger siblings every night. Adventure Guides also curate special activities for teens like game shows and pool parties.

In destinations like Antarctica, the Adriatic and the Galápagos Islands , expert naturalists lead tours during these bucket list trips. You might even find a bit of Disney storytelling woven into the presentations by the Adventure Guides.

Keep in mind if you have younger kids as well as teens that children need to be 5 or older to sail on the river cruises. For the Galápagos Islands expedition cruises, the minimum age for Junior Adventurers is 7, and for expeditions to the polar regions, kids need to be 10 years of age or older.

Read: The Best Cruise Insurance Plans

Carnival Cruise Line

Courtesy of Carnival Cruise Line

Carnival Celebration, which launched in November 2022, is the line's newest Excel-class ship. It features an expanded family and youth program, including its offerings for teens. The line also rolled out the new program fleetwide in spring 2023.

The Carnival Cruise Line teen programming at Circle "C" is for tweens ages 12 to 14, while Club O2 is for ages 15 to 17. In these venues you'll find entertainment like themed dance parties – and even a Carnival prom – as well as video games, movies and karaoke. Circle "C" stands for "Cruise, chill and connect," and that's what teens can do in this colorful, contemporary space with engaging counselors. New activities include anime drawing lessons and pop culture games at Circle "C." Older teens can foster new friendships while engaging in Japanese crafts and authentic tea ceremonies at Club O2.

Teens will appreciate Carnival's onboard water park, Waterworks, which includes a splash park and slides. Carnival Panorama even has the trampoline park Skyzone. Teenage passengers won't want to miss the first roller coaster at sea, BOLT, on Excel-class ships: Mardi Gras , Celebration and the upcoming Jubilee, scheduled to launch in December 2023.

For even more action, Vista-class ships feature Skyride. This two-lane, bike-like ride is suspended above the top deck of the ships and extends out over the ocean. More indoor fun can be found at Thrill Theater (on Horizon and Vista ), an immersive cinematic experience where you'll feel the seat rumble, the wind blow through your hair and even a spritz of water during the action-packed video.

Book a Carnival cruise on GoToSea .

Celebrity Cruises

Michel Verdure | Courtesy of Celebrity Cruises

This line's Teen Club features activities focused on kids 13 to 17. Some of the events offered for teens in the Camp at Sea program on Celebrity Cruises range from video game tournaments and sports competitions to culinary classes and silent disco parties. Teen cruisers can even book glass-blowing classes on Celebrity Solstice , Equinox and Eclipse . The offerings for young passengers are similar at either The Basement on Edge-series ships ( Edge , Apex , Beyond and Ascent, set to launch in November 2023) or at X Club on Solstice- and Millennium-class ships. Note, however, the line's three Galápagos expedition vessels do not have the teen venues. Families who need accessible accommodations, activities and programs will also find autism-friendly cruises on Celebrity.

When it comes to pampering, Celebrity's spas offer spa menus for 13- to 17-year-olds. Teens can book facials that are designed for young sensitive skin or have express pedicures and manicures. When you're ready to relax, schedule a two-by-two massage, where parents and kids can have a side-by-side treatment.

Celebrity also offers family-focused excursions that highlight cultural attractions, wildlife sightings and adventure. Some of these tours include seeing gentoo, king and Magellanic penguins in the Falkland Islands; taking an aerial tram through the treetop canopies of a rainforest in Costa Rica ; and going on a small culinary or sightseeing group excursion in Europe and other destinations around the world. On Caribbean sailings – especially when school is out for summer or on holidays – Celebrity has additional family-friendly shore excursions on its five- and seven-night sailings.

Find a  Celebrity Cruises deal on GoToSea .

Cunard Line

Cunard Line offers programs and activities for passengers ages 13 to 17 years old in its Teen Zone. This dedicated space is a place for teens to hang out with cruisers their own age and play video and team games, table tennis, and more. On the first day of the cruise, you'll find an activity program for young guests delivered to the stateroom so your teens can plan out their vacation experience, which may include entertaining theme days, deck sports, quizzes and dancing at the disco.

Teens on Cunard Line can participate in the activities around the ship, hit the pool for a dip, practice their putting or try their hand at croquet. If you're sailing on Queen Mary 2, those interested in science, wildlife and the solar system can watch up to four 3D films a day (on sea days) in the largest planetarium at sea.

Compare  Cunard Line cruises on GoToSea .

Why Trust U.S. News Travel

Gwen Pratesi has been an avid cruiser since her early 20s. She's sailed to destinations around the globe on nearly every type of cruise ship built, including the newest megaships, luxury yachts, traditional masted sailing ships, and expedition vessels in Antarctica and the Galápagos. Pratesi covers the travel and cruise industries for major publications, including U.S. News & World Report.

You might also be interested in:

• Cruise Lines That Let Kids Sail Free
• The Top Cruises for Babies and Toddlers
• The Top Adults-Only Cruises
• Cruise Packing List
• Royal Caribbean vs. Carnival

Top Resorts Where Kids Stay Free

Tags: Travel , Cruises , Family Vacations

World's Best Places To Visit

• # 1 South Island, New Zealand
• # 4 Bora Bora

If you make a purchase from our site, we may earn a commission. This does not affect the quality or independence of our editorial content.

You May Also Like

The best east coast beaches.

April 19, 2024

The Best Carry-on Luggage

Erin Evans , Rachael Hood , Catriona Kendall , Amanda Norcross and Leilani Osmundson April 17, 2024

The Best Hard-sided Luggage Picks

The Best Luggage Brands

Rachael Hood April 17, 2024

The Best Yellowstone National Park Tours

John Rodwan April 17, 2024

The Best Rome Colosseum Tours

Laura Itzkowitz April 17, 2024

Best Alaska Tours

Lyn Mettler April 16, 2024

The Best Fredericksburg Wine Tours

The Best Personal Item Bags

Rachael Hood April 16, 2024

The 17 Best Costa Rica Tours

Lyn Mettler April 12, 2024

Royal Caribbean vs Carnival Cruise-Which Is Better?

R oyal Caribbean vs Carnival Cruise-which cruise line is better? Carnival Cruise Line and Royal Caribbean International are two of the most popular cruise lines in the world. They offer a wide range of amenities and activities for families to enjoy during their vacation. Deciding between the two can be challenging, but it ultimately depends on your preferences and budget. In this comparison, we will take an in-depth look at Royal Caribbean vs Carnival cruise lines and compare them based on various criteria.

Ship Size and Amenities

Royal Caribbean is known for having the largest and most modern ships in the industry. The Symphony of the Seas is the largest cruise ship in the world, with a capacity of over 6,800 passengers. It features an impressive water park, 20 restaurants, a zip line, and a full-sized basketball court, among other amenities. On the other hand, Carnival has smaller and more budget-friendly ships. Their newest ships, the Mardi Gras and the Celebration can accommodate up to 5,282 passengers and features a roller coaster , water park, and a variety of dining options. 

Cabin Choices

Both Royal Caribbean and Carnival offer an impressive range of cabins to choose from, catering to every budget and preference. Carnival’s standard cabins are cozy and comfortable, but the line is known for offering smaller balconies. Carnival also offers several different categories of cabins, including interior, ocean view, balcony, and suite cabins. The interior cabins are perfect for those looking for an affordable option while still enjoying the amenities offered on the ship. The ocean-view cabins offer a picturesque view of the ocean and are perfect for those who love to watch the waves. Balcony cabins are the most popular option and allow you to have your own private outdoor space to relax and enjoy the ocean breeze. Suite cabins provide an extra level of luxury and come with a range of exclusive amenities, such as concierge service, priority check-in, and access to private lounges and dining areas. 

On the other hand, Royal Caribbean offers an even wider range of cabin types, including interior, ocean view, balcony, suite, and even virtual balcony cabins. Their interior cabins are cozy and comfortable, with a range of amenities to make your stay as comfortable as possible. Ocean-view cabins offer a stunning view of the ocean, while balcony cabins provide a private outdoor space to relax and enjoy the views. Suite cabins are available in several different categories, including Junior Suite, Grand Suite, and Royal Suite. These offer more space, extra amenities, and exclusive access to areas like the Suite Lounge and Coastal Kitchen restaurant. The ultimate in luxury is the Royal Caribbean’s Star Class suite, which comes with its own private butler and access to the Royal Genie, who can make all your onboard wishes come true.

Royal Caribbean’s virtual balcony cabins are a unique feature that allows passengers in interior cabins to enjoy a real-time view of the ocean on an 80-inch high-definition screen that spans nearly floor-to-ceiling. This feature allows passengers to enjoy the view of the ocean without paying the premium for a balcony cabin. 

In addition to their standard cabins, Carnival offers several unique cabin categories that cater to specific types of travelers. For families looking for more space, Carnival offers Havana Family Cabins on select ships. These cabins feature a large balcony with a hammock and patio furniture, as well as access to a private Havana pool and lounge area.

For those looking for a more luxurious experience, Carnival offers Cloud 9 cabins. These cabins are located in a private spa area and include complimentary access to the ship’s thermal suite, which features heated loungers, steam rooms, and saunas. Cloud 9 cabins also include upgraded amenities such as spa bathrobes and priority spa reservations.

Royal Caribbean also offers a variety of unique cabin categories. For those seeking a more exclusive experience, Royal Caribbean offers Suite Class, which includes access to a private suite lounge, a dedicated suite concierge, and exclusive dining options.

For families or groups traveling together, Royal Caribbean offers connecting staterooms, which allow for more space and privacy while still being close to each other. They also offer virtual balconies in select interior cabins, which feature a large screen displaying live footage of the ocean outside.

Both cruise lines offer accessible cabins for passengers with disabilities or mobility issues, and both have a range of cabin categories to suit every budget and preference. Ultimately, the choice of cabin type will depend on the individual traveler’s needs and preferences.

Dining 

Onboard dining is an essential aspect of any cruise experience, and both Royal Caribbean and Carnival Cruise Line offer a range of dining options to cater to different tastes and preferences.

Carnival Cruise Line is known for its casual, laid-back dining atmosphere. The cruise line offers a range of dining venues, from buffet-style restaurants to specialty dining options, including steakhouses and seafood restaurants. One of Carnival’s unique dining options is the “Chef’s Table,” which is a multi-course dinner hosted by the ship’s executive chef. This dining experience includes a tour of the ship’s galley and a private cocktail reception with the chef.

Royal Caribbean, on the other hand, offers a more upscale dining experience. The cruise line offers a range of dining venues, including main dining rooms, buffet-style restaurants, and specialty dining options. One of the unique dining options on Royal Caribbean ships is the “Jamie’s Italian” restaurant, which was developed in partnership with celebrity chef Jamie Oliver. This restaurant offers a range of Italian-inspired dishes, including pasta, seafood, and pizza.

Royal Caribbean also offers a flexible dining option called “My Time Dining,” which allows passengers to dine at their own pace and choose their preferred dining time. This option is ideal for those who want more flexibility in their dining schedule and do not want to be tied to a fixed dining time.

Both Carnival and Royal Caribbean offer dining packages that can help passengers save money on specialty dining options. Carnival’s “Chef’s Table” and Royal Caribbean’s “Ultimate Dining Package” are examples of dining packages that provide passengers with access to specialty restaurants for a set price.

Overall, both Royal Caribbean and Carnival Cruise Line offer a range of dining options to cater to different tastes and budgets. Whether you prefer casual dining or upscale dining, there is something for everyone on these cruise lines.

Onboard Activities

Both Carnival and Royal Caribbean offer a wide variety of onboard entertainment and activities for passengers of all ages. Carnival is known for its high-energy and lively atmosphere, with a focus on fun and entertainment. On the other hand, Royal Caribbean offers a more upscale and sophisticated experience, with a range of activities and entertainment options to suit all tastes.

Carnival’s entertainment options include Broadway-style productions, comedy shows, magic shows, and live music performances. The cruise line is also known for its outdoor parties and deck events, such as pool parties and dance parties. In addition, Carnival offers a range of onboard activities such as water parks, mini golf, and sports facilities. There are also kids’ clubs and teen clubs available, providing a range of activities and games to keep younger passengers entertained.

Royal Caribbean offers a similarly impressive range of entertainment and activities. The cruise line is known for its West End-style productions, featuring world-class performers, singers, and dancers. Other entertainment options include ice skating shows, acrobatic performances, and live music performances. Royal Caribbean also offers a range of onboard activities such as rock climbing, zip-lining, and surfing simulators. Kids can enjoy the “Adventure Ocean” program, which offers a range of educational and interactive activities, as well as age-specific clubs and hangouts.

Both cruise lines also offer a range of parties and events onboard. Carnival is famous for its “Fun Ship” parties, which feature live music, dancing, and entertainment. There are also themed parties and events such as 80s and 90s parties, white parties, and Halloween parties. Royal Caribbean offers a range of parties and events as well, including themed parties, such as Caribbean-themed parties, and formal events such as Captain’s cocktail parties.

Both Carnival and Royal Caribbean offer a wide range of onboard entertainment and activities to suit all tastes and preferences. Whether you’re looking for high-energy parties and shows or more sophisticated and elegant entertainment, both cruise lines have something to offer.

Kid’s Clubs

One of the most important aspects for families when it comes to choosing a cruise line is the availability of activities for children. Both Carnival Cruise Line and Royal Caribbean Cruise Line offer a wide range of activities and clubs for kids of all ages, but they differ in their approach.

Carnival Cruise Line’s Camp Ocean is a program designed for kids aged 2-11, divided into three age groups: Penguins (ages 2-5), Stingrays (ages 6-8), and Sharks (ages 9-11). The program includes arts and crafts, games, and other fun activities, all under the supervision of experienced youth counselors. Older kids and teenagers can enjoy Circle “C” (ages 12-14) and Club O2 (ages 15-17), which offer age-appropriate activities like dance parties, video game tournaments, and sports competitions.

Royal Caribbean Cruise Line’s Adventure Ocean program offers a similar range of activities for kids, divided into Aquanauts (ages 3-5), Explorers (ages 6-8), Voyagers (ages 9-11), and Teens (ages 12-17). However, Royal Caribbean’s program includes more educational and interactive activities, such as science experiments, theater workshops, and even scavenger hunts. The cruise line also offers a Royal Babies & Tots program, which caters to children aged 6-36 months and includes interactive playgroups for parents and babies.

Both cruise lines offer babysitting services for an additional fee, so parents can enjoy some adult time during the cruise. Carnival’s Night Owls program offers babysitting services until 1 am, while Royal Caribbean’s Late Night Party Zone offers babysitting services until 2 am.

Overall, both Carnival Cruise Line and Royal Caribbean Cruise Line provide a great experience for families with children. The choice between the two will depend on the specific needs and preferences of each family, as well as the age range of their children.

Private Islands

Private islands are a highlight of any cruise vacation, and both Royal Caribbean and Carnival offer unique experiences on their respective islands.

Perfect Day at CocoCay, Royal Caribbean’s private island in the Bahamas, has been recently transformed into a massive water park that is a playground for both adults and children. This island boasts the tallest water slide in North America, Daredevil’s Peak, which stands at a staggering 135 feet tall, and the largest freshwater pool in the Caribbean. The water park is packed with exciting attractions like Splash Summit, a collection of four exhilarating slides, and the wave pool, which simulates the feeling of swimming in the ocean.

In addition to the water park, Perfect Day at CocoCay also offers a helium balloon ride that ascends 450 feet in the air, providing passengers with a breathtaking bird’s-eye view of the island. Other activities on the island include snorkeling, kayaking, and beach volleyball. For those who prefer a more laid-back experience, there are plenty of cabanas and hammocks scattered throughout the island where guests can relax in the shade and enjoy the beautiful scenery.

On the other hand, Half Moon Cay, Carnival’s private island in the Bahamas, is a serene and tranquil tropical paradise that is perfect for those who want to unwind and relax. The island has pristine white sandy beaches with crystal-clear waters that are perfect for swimming and snorkeling. Guests can also enjoy a variety of water sports such as parasailing, paddleboarding, and kayaking.

Half Moon Cay also offers a range of excursions, including horseback riding, nature walks, and stingray encounters. The island has several bars and restaurants where guests can enjoy a refreshing drink or a delicious meal. There are also plenty of beach chairs and hammocks throughout the island where guests can soak up the sun and enjoy the beautiful scenery.

While Perfect Day at CocoCay offers a thrilling and exciting experience for those who love water parks and adventure, Half Moon Cay offers a more laid-back and relaxing experience in a tranquil tropical setting. Both private islands offer unique experiences that cater to different preferences, and the choice between them ultimately depends on the individual’s taste and interests.

Affordability

Carnival tends to offer more budget-friendly cruise options, making it an excellent choice for families on a tight budget. Their cruises typically last for 3-7 nights and start at around $200 per person. Royal Caribbean, on the other hand, tends to offer longer cruises and more upscale experiences. Their cruises can last for up to 14 nights and start at around $400 per person.

Itineraries

 Both Royal Caribbean and Carnival offer a wide range of destinations to choose from, including the Caribbean, Alaska, Europe, and more. Carnival tends to focus more on shorter, more affordable cruises, while Royal Caribbean offers longer, more luxurious itineraries. Royal Caribbean also has its own private island destinations, like CocoCay in the Bahamas and Labadee in Haiti. These private islands offer exclusive experiences like zip-lining, snorkeling, and beachside cabanas.

In contrast, Carnival has partnerships with port destinations like Half Moon Cay in the Bahamas and Amber Cove in the Dominican Republic .

Solo Sailing Options

Solo travelers can enjoy cruising with both Royal Caribbean and Carnival. Royal Caribbean offers single-occupancy staterooms, which are designed In terms of dining options, both Royal Caribbean and Carnival offer a wide variety of restaurants and cafes to choose from. Carnival’s dining experience tends to be more casual and laid-back, while Royal Caribbean offers a more formal and upscale experience. Both cruise lines also offer dining packages and specialty restaurants that cater to different tastes and budgets. For example, Royal Caribbean’s main dining room offers a three-course menu with multiple options for appetizers, entrees, and desserts. Carnival offers similar dining options but also offers unique features like Guy’s Burger Joint, BlueIguana Cantina, and The Steakhouse. Both cruise lines offer a variety of dietary options like vegetarian, gluten-free, and Kosher.

When it comes to solo sailing, both Royal Caribbean and Carnival offer options for solo travelers, but Royal Caribbean has more options for solo travelers, including solo cabins on some of their ships. These cabins are smaller than traditional cabins, but they offer a more affordable option for solo travelers who want to avoid paying the single supplement fee. Carnival also offers solo traveler meetups and social activities.

Royal Caribbean vs Carnival-Which One Is The One For You?

Royal Caribbean vs Carnival -which is better? Both Royal Caribbean and Carnival are excellent choices for families looking for a fun and memorable vacation. Both cruise lines offer a wide range of amenities and activities but with different strengths and weaknesses. If you’re looking for a more luxurious and upscale experience with a wide range of onboard activities and dining options, Royal Caribbean might be the better choice. However, if you’re looking for a more laid-back and affordable cruise experience, Carnival might be the way to go. Ultimately, the best choice for your family will depend on your specific needs and preferences.

The post Royal Caribbean vs Carnival Cruise-Which Is Better? appeared first on The Adventures Of Life-Spontaneous Travel, Food and Fun .